Development & Aid, Headlines, Health, North America

HEALTH: Wave of Asbestos Deaths Forecast in Poor Countries

Katherine Stapp

NEW YORK, Oct 3 2001 (IPS) - The epidemic of asbestos-related cancers that erupted in the United States and Western Europe will be vastly magnified in the developing world, warn doctors and experts who have called for a global ban on the mineral.

A conservative estimate of the looming death toll is one million over the next 30 years, mostly involving miners or workers in factories that make asbestos-containing products like floor and ceiling tiles, roofing materials, cement, and auto brakes.

Because there is a 10- to 40-year delay between exposure and onset of illness, the magnitude of the crisis in countries that actively import or mine asbestos will not unfold for many years, experts say. These countries include Angola, Brazil, India, Mexico, Nigeria, South Africa, Thailand, and Uruguay.

A known carcinogen, asbestos has been banned in 12 of the 15 European Union countries, along with some others like Saudi Arabia. Deaths in the United States – which imports but no longer manufactures asbestos – peaked a decade ago, after the introduction of stricter worker protection standards.

But in much of the developing world, studies show that millions of workers are handling asbestos without proper respiratory equipment or training.

Some experts draw a comparison between the asbestos industry and the big tobacco companies, which, facing tough regulations at home, sought to gain market share in developing countries with looser worker and consumer protection laws.

According to the Collegium Ramazzini, an international association of occupational health specialists based in Italy, “an international ban on the mining and use of asbestos is necessary because country-by-country actions have shifted rather than eliminated the health risks of asbestos.”

“Canada, Russia and other asbestos-exporting countries have developed major markets in the newly industrialising nations. Conditions of current asbestos use in developing countries now resemble those that existed in the industrialised countries before the dangers of asbestos were widely recognised,” the Collegium says.

New data on this “time bomb in the lungs” was presented last month at the 11th Annual Congress of the European Respiratory Society in Berlin.

“The epidemiological outlook is clear,” said Marc Letourneux, of the University Medical Centre Cote de Nacre in Caen, France. “There will be a steady rise in the frequency of asbestos-linked cancers until at least 2010 or 2020 because they take years to manifest themselves.”

In Belgium, Krassimir Mitchev of the Erasmus Hospital in Brussels found that one in seven people he autopsied showed scarring from asbestos exposure.

Doctors and researchers stress that while Europe and the United States now record the most asbestos-related illnesses, it is countries in the developing world that will be hardest hit when the effects of prolonged exposure begin to manifest themselves.

Asbestos refers to a family of six naturally occurring minerals that have been widely used in the construction industries because of their strength, flexibility and resistance to heat. Of the six – amosite, chrysotile, tremolite, actinolite, anthophyllite and crocodilite – the curly-shaped chrysotile is the most commonly used because it is thought to be the least carcinogenic.

The main health threat comes from airborne asbestos fibres, which are so slender that they can slip through the body’s natural mucous barriers and become lodged in the lining of the lung and chest wall. The fibres also are too long to be fully devoured by the cells that cleanse foreign objects from the lungs.

Once inside the chest, the fibres begin to irritate and scar the lung tissue. Not only does asbestos-related scarring make it difficult to breathe, it also increases a person’s chance of getting cancer five-fold. This jumps to 55-fold if the person is a smoker.

The most virulent cancer associated with asbestos is mesothelioma, tumours in the lining of the lung. Mesothelioma is caused almost exclusively by asbestos exposure. Once diagnosed, the average life expectancy of a person with this type of cancer is one year.

With the hazards of asbestos so clearly proven, many experts have long called for a global ban.

Richard Lemen, a former U.S. assistant surgeon general who has spent 30 years studying the effects of asbestos on workers, says there simply is no such thing as a “safe level” of asbestos.

“Asbestos is a deadly substance and has been known to be so for almost 100 years,” he said in testimony urging U.S. lawmakers to outlaw asbestos completely. “We know that suppression of the asbestos-containing dust will not work, as no thresholds for cancer can be established, and that even at the lowest standards to date, excessive disease and death will continue to occur.”

In July, Argentina banned the use of chrysotile asbestos in nearly all products. That same month, Chile – where an estimated 5,000 workers suffer from asbestos-related health problems – followed suit by outlawing the import and use of asbestos, despite pressure from Canadian Prime Minister Jean Chretien.

Canada is the world’s third biggest asbestos manufacturer, after Russia and China, and the number one exporter.

Even if asbestos was completely banned today, tens of thousands of people exposed in the past will still be getting sick for years to come.

There is no cure for asbestosis (scarring) and associated lung cancers, but one of the most promising avenues of research involves slowing or stopping the growth of networks of new blood vessels that nourish cancer cells.

Drugs that stop these networks from forming are called angiogenesis inhibitors, and many have shrunk or eliminated tumours in laboratory animals. Some, such as endostatin and combrestatin, are now being tested in human trials.

While these could eventually be used to treat mesothelioma, experts stress that the research is still in the early and experimental stages.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags