Development & Aid, Economy & Trade, Headlines, Labour, Latin America & the Caribbean, Population

LABOUR-ECUADOR: Under- and Unemployment Fuel Historic Exodus

Kintto Lucas

QUITO, May 1 2001 (IPS) - International Labour Day this year finds Ecuador suffering the biggest wave of emigration in its history, attributed to the high unemployment and under-employment generated by the severe economic crisis.

Around one million Ecuadoreans left this country of nearly 13 million in 1999 and 2000, according to the National Institute of Statistics and Censuses (INEC) – a proportion without match in Latin America.

“The deepening of the economic crisis and the high unemployment in 1999 gave rise to a panorama that led to a skyrocketing of emigration flows,” said INEC director Johny Cevallos.

Cevallos noted that 67.1 percent of the emigrants who left in search of work were women. Under-employment has grown steadily in this Andean nation, from 56.9 percent in 1999 to 65.9 percent in 2000, he added.

One of the paradoxes presented by the high level of emigration of labour power in 2000 is that it led to a drop in unemployment, which according to INEC fell from 14.4 percent in 1999 to nine percent last year.

Cevallos also attributed the fall in unemployment to the fact that a sector of the labour force “has found work in self- generated jobs.”

However, some independent studies put the unemployment rate at 13 percent of the economically active population.

INEC statistics indicate that the under- and unemployed currently account for 74.9 percent of the economically active population.

The long queues outside the Ministry of Foreign Relations of people taking out a passport, or outside the Spanish Embassy in Quito to apply for an entry visa provide a graphic reflection of the magnitude of the emigration problem. So do the hundreds who gather outside the fence surrounding the Quito airport every day to wave good-bye to loved ones going abroad.

Humanitarian organisations and official statistics estimate the number of Ecuadoreans living abroad at 2.5 million, most of whom are in the United States, Spain and Italy.

Ecuadoreans use a variety of methods and routes to reach the industrialised North, many of them illegal, and some downright dangerous. Many emigrants even die before reaching their final destination. In fact, 450 Ecuadoreans died in Central America in the last five months of 2000.

In addition, 2,978 undocumented Ecuadorean emigrants have been captured by authorities in Guatemala, El Salvador, Mexico and the United States so far this year, according to statistics provided by the Ecuadorean consulates in those countries.

The emigrants were attempting to enter the United States with the help of “coyotes” or people who traffic in human beings in exchange for 5,000 to 10,000 dollars per person.

One Ecuadorean, María Gaucho, did not see her “American dream” come true because she was caught in Mexico, where she has been held in custody for the past two months. However, she said she did not regret having failed in her attempt, but that she was worried about being deported to her home country, where she would not be able to find work.

Gaucho said she did not know how she would pay the “chulqueros” (moneylenders) who lent her the 10,000 dollars to pay the “coyote”, for which she had to take out a mortgage on her mother’s house.

Ecuador’s general consul in Mexico, Fernando Prócel, reported that in the first three months of the year, 1,872 safe-conducts were granted for Ecuadoreans who were sent home, compared to 700 in the same period last year.

Another popular destination for Ecuadorean emigrants is Spain, where 12 undocumented immigrants from this country were killed last January when the van in which they were being taken to work was hit by a train in Lorca, in the southeastern province of Murcia.

The employers of the migrant workers were sanctioned, and the accident led to the dismissal of many undocumented workers in the province.

Last week, another incident shook public opinion here when Spain’s Work and Social Security Inspection office discovered a strawberry farm in Huelva, in the southern province of Andalucia, which employed more than 100 immigrants in exploitative conditions.

Spanish authorities said the undocumented workers from Ecuador, Morocco, Lithuania and Romania were suffering “extremely glaring exploitation,” living in substandard housing and owed several weeks of back pay.

The report said the clean drinking water provided the workers was rationed, that they had neither latrines nor showers, and that they slept packed together in sheds made of corrugated iron measuring six square metres each, with no electricity or ventilation.

Spain’s new law on aliens, which went into effect on Jan 23, orders the deportation of foreign nationals lacking residency papers or work permits, and heavy sanctions for companies that hire them.

The implementation of the strict new law triggered protests by immigrants, especially Ecuadoreans, with huge marches and occupations of churches and public offices in several regions of Spain.

After the protests, Spain’s then-minister of the Interior Jaime Mayor Oreja signed an agreement with Quito to regulate the situation of the more than 150,000 Ecuadoreans currently living in Spain.

The agreement stipulated that Spain would legalise the situation of some 40,000 Ecuadorean immigrants this year and another 200,000 over the next five years.

But the immigrants must return to their home country in order to legalise their situation in the Spanish Embassy in Quito, as part of a “voluntary return” programme.

Human rights and immigrant groups complained that the agreement did not guarantee that all of the emigrants would be allowed to return to Spain.

Reports from the Spanish Embassy in Ecuador indicated that of the 24,544 emigrants who signed up for the voluntary return programme, only 2,175 have returned to Ecuador, and just 649 have been issued visas so far. Embassy officials argued that “85 percent of those people had no sure job offers.”

Moreover, at the established rate of 40,000 visas and work permits a year, more than 100,000 Ecuadoreans already living in Spain will be left without papers, making it difficult for them to find jobs under the new laws.

The rest of the immigrants have until May 14 to sign up for the voluntary return programme.

In the view of Juan Carlos Manzanilla, one of the founders of the Rumiñahui Association of Ecuadorean Emigrants, the agreement between Spain and Ecuador did not resolve the problems of people from this country living in Spain.

“The agreement sets an annual quota of workers who can be accepted in Spain. But the papers are issued on the basis of the business community’s demand for employees, and the job offers do not even cover half of those who are already in Spain. So we better sit down and wait, because those offers will never arrive,” he explained to IPS.

The Rumiñahui Association was founded five years ago to address the problems of immigrants in Spain.

“The idea was to orient them, help them when they arrived in a very vulnerable psychological state, provide technical and legal advice and, when possible, find them jobs,” he said.

Manzanilla, who has a degree in journalism from the Social Communication Faculty in Quito, emigrated to Spain when he had a hard time finding a job here, and found work in the construction industry and painting houses.

“What produced the appearance of the immigrant as a new social subject is the law on aliens, and the restriction of their rights triggered loud opposition. Furthermore, the accident in Lorca shook international public opinion,” said Manzanilla.

He said the situation of the undocumented Ecuadoreans in Spain was extremely difficult. “There are Spanish employers who have kept them on as employees, even illegally. But many have lost their jobs and are packed into churches or shelters, living practically as beggars. The important thing is to find legal channels to allow them to keep working,” he added.

The Rumiñahui Association believes it is better to have a job in Spain, “even an illegal job”, than to have none in Ecuador – an attitude that has drawn criticism as a position overly permissive with a system under which cheap labour is exploited.

But according to Manzanilla, legal jobs are not the salvation, because the only work available are menial or unskilled jobs.

“Even with papers, the immigrant has no guarantees, because the work permits must be re-extended annually,” he argued. “And in any case people prefer to be exploited over there and work, than to be exploited here, where wages – when work can be found at all – are not living wages.”

The massive outflow of emigrants, meanwhile, means Ecuadoreans living abroad send more than 1.2 billion dollars a year to their families in Ecuador. Those remittances constituted one of the main sources of foreign exchange last year, second only to exports of oil.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags