Development & Aid, Education, Headlines, Latin America & the Caribbean

EDUCATION-VENEZUELA: Caught in a Tug-of-War

Andrés Cañizález

CARACAS, Feb 19 2001 (IPS) - The Catholic Church, private schools and other sectors of civil society have not given up their fight against a controversial decree in Venezuela granting the state a stronger supervisory role over education.

Civic groups staged two major protests in Caracas early this month, and new demonstrations have been announced to protest decree 1,011, which strengthens the state’s role in overseeing both private and public educational institutions.

Analysts say the decree is just the tip of the iceberg of a much broader debate on education policy that will continue to rage. A new law on education is to be passed this year, and two different bills have already been drawn up.

President Hugo Chávez, a former paratrooper officer who has pushed a peaceful “Bolivarian revolution” – for South American liberator Simon Bolivar – since he took office in February 1999, re-drawing the political map of this South American oil-producing country, is the main advocate of decree 1,011 and the government’s draft law on education.

The president, who headed a Feb 7 demonstration in favour of public education, berated private schools and even threatened to eliminate the public subsidies received by some institutions, although he later denied that there was any possibility that the government funding might be cut off.

The elimination of state funding would have affected half a million children in this country of 23 million, mainly in poor neighbourhoods, who attend schools run by the Catholic Church.

Chávez was simply “explaining the faculties he had to eliminate the subsidy for private education, but he later clarified that he would not do so,” said the president of the National Assembly (parliament), William Lara, one of the leaders of the president’s Fifth Republic Movement (MVR).

Lara said the criticism of the decree and of the bill submitted to parliament by the Education Ministry were coming from “a sector of society with links to private education based on an elitist conception.”

Education Minister Héctor Navarro, for his part, said the problems were being caused by the “merchants of education.”

The minister said the controversial decree 1,011 was based on article 106 of the Bolivarian Constitution of Venezuela, in effect since late 1999, which stipulates that all private educational institutions are subject to strict state oversight and control.

“The aim is to create a level of supervisors who answer directly to the minister, and who report irregularities that might crop up in any institution,” said Navarro, such as the charging of tuition in public schools, poor quality teachers, dilapidated buildings or school principals who divert funds.

While the decree has drawn fire from sectors which see it as part of an interventionist government trend, the candidates for the new supervisory posts have already begun to be selected, although it has not yet been announced when they are to begin working.

A number of court challenges, backed by around 40,000 signatures, were filed with the Supreme Court on Feb 5 to keep the decree from going into effect.

The Venezuelan Episcopal Conference called for the government to open the question up to a “national dialogue”, while Leonardo Carvajal with Education Assembly, a civic group, announced simultaneous protests throughout the country for Mar 31, which could draw as many as one million demonstrators.

However, Chávez recently downplayed the opposition to the government’s plans, saying “the people are calling for supervisors.”

Deputy Minister of Education Maryann Hanson said the process would go forward, despite the criticism and legal challenges, and recommended that private institutions “improve their staff in order to function as quality” schools, and that they not fear state supervision.

The coordinator of the National Educational Project, Carlos Lanz, considered the architect of the new decree, stressed the need for community participation in running schools, another innovation contemplated in the government’s plans.

“The aim of this process is to prepare the community to take part in the schooling process,” said Lanz, who added that in the future, parents would get involved “in the selection and supervision of school principals, and in overseeing the administration and functioning of the schools themselves.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags