Friday, November 20, 2026
Sonny Inbaraj
- There seems no end to the troubles that are dogging the peace process between Ethiopia and Eritrea. In 2000, the two Horn of Africa countries signed an accord in Algeria to end two years of fighting sparked by a border dispute. The indefinite postponement, last week, of the marking out of a border in the contested area posed a major setback to peace efforts.
The Hague-based Ethiopia and Eritrea Boundary Commission (EEBC), last Thursday said it was unable to begin the border demarcation of the two countries but was “ready and willing to proceed as soon as conditions permit.”
The border demarcation was originally scheduled for May, then July and finally last month. Last week’s announcement marked the first instance in which the EEBC announced a delay with no new date for the work to start.
The EEBC statement was read out to journalists in a video-linked press conference between Addis Ababa and Asmara, the capital of Eritrea, by Gail Bindley-Taylor Sainte, the spokesperson of the United Nations Mission in Ethiopia and Eritrea (UNMEE).
UNMEE presently has 4,200 troops deployed in a 25-kilometre wide buffer area – called the Temporary Security Zone – between the two states.
Sainte said the UN and the international community were engaged in discussions to solve the two countries’ differences, and to bring about a sustainable peace between them.
“Let’s allow the diplomatic community to do (its) best. I have nothing to add (on) what the outcome would be,” she told reporters.
Concerns about the fraying peace process were voiced during last month’s meeting in the Ugandan capital, Kampala, of the Intergovernmental Authority on Development (IGAD) – a regional grouping that comprises Eritrea, Ethiopia, Somalia, Djibouti, Kenya, Sudan and Uganda. An appeal was made at the talks for IGAD’s current Chairman, Ugandan President Yoweri Museveni, to be more involved in the process, along with African Union Chairman Joachim Chissano – who is also President of Mozambique.
But positions are hardening between Ethiopia and Eritrea, and the recent visit of the US Deputy Assistant of State for African Affairs, Donald Yamamoto, passed without any visible sign of progress.
The harsh reality is that three years after the signing of the Algiers Peace Agreement, the two countries are still not on talking terms, and in recent months have issued tit-for-tat statements and communiques.
The Ethiopian-Eritrean war, which began in 1998, was the biggest in the world at the time, surpassing the Kosovo conflict in terms of casualties, troops involved and displaced civilians. The number of dead and wounded was estimated at 100,000. About half a million troops were involved, and 600,000 civilians displaced.
At the heart of the matter was the border town of Badme, where the war first started. It is currently administered by Ethiopia. However, under the EEBC ruling – made in April last year – the town will ultimately be ceded to Eritrea.
Both Ethiopia and Eritrea have said they will be bound by the decisions of the EEBC in the border demarcation between the two countries, as spelled out in the Algiers Agreement.
But Ethiopia last month said it would not accept the EEBC ruling on Badme, and warned that the commission’s decision was a recipe for continued instability.
Members of the country’s Tigrayan community reportedly oppose the Badme ruling because they fear losing access to ancestral graves located in the area. There is also said to be a school of thought in Ethiopia that opposes giving Eritrea any territory at all; this is on the grounds that Eriterea’s 1993 seccession from Ethiopia already dealt the country a blow by cutting of its access to the Red Sea.
In September, Ethiopian Prime Minister Meles Zenawi, himself a Tigrayan, called on the UN Security Council to set up an alternative body to demarcate the contested parts of the border “in a just and legal manner so as to ensure lasting peace in the region.”
But the Security Council has rejected Ethiopia’s calls for a new body. In a one-page response, it urged Zenawi’s government to implement the controversial EEBC ruling on Badme.
According to Zenawi, the only way forward in the current impasse is further negotiations with Eritrea.
But Eritrea has said categorically it will not enter into dialogue, and it wants the international community to press Ethiopia to accept the Badme decision.
“The issue is not just the delay in demarcation…What appears to be at stake, now, is the entire Algiers Agreement,” Yemane Gebremeskel, the head of the Eritrean President’s office, told the British Broadcasting Corporation.
“The basic question is: why is this being tolerated by the international community,” he asked.
The question now is whether the United Nations can maintain peace-keeping operations in the disputed area longer than it originally intended to.
At 250 million dollars a year, the peacekeeping mission does not come cheap. In his September report to the Security Council, which included an appeal for the renewal of UNMEE’s mandate, UN Secretary-General Kofi Annan said the world body’s resources were scarce – and that peacekeepers were also needed elsewhere in Africa.