Saturday, November 21, 2026
Zofeen Ebrahim
- They are forced to relieve themselves along roads and railway tracks, behind bus stops and in empty plots piled high with dirt, or beside festering drains. Men, women and children have no option but to perform a private act in full public view.
This despite studies on health and sanitation in urban Pakistan having revealed a high mortality rate in children under five years old due to diarrhoeal diseases. These are caused by inadequate access to safe water, household and environmental sanitation and poor hygiene practices.
The need for well-maintained, clean public toilets which have an adequate supply of water is dire. Yet where there is an attended public toilet, as with the unit next to Karachi’s City Court, the pattern of use indicates a continuing apathy towards such a facility.
Jawed is the caretaker of this public toilet and is at his post from 6 a.m. to 7 p.m.. He reminds those who use the toilet to pay the charge, which is the equivalent of 34 U.S. cents. Few respond.
”The police don’t even pay for the food they eat from these vendors, do you think they will pay for using the toilets?” he asked.
Accepting a rare payment from one toilet user, Jawed told IPS: ”People don’t part with their money easily, specially those who work here. I make money from those who have come to meet their relatives in prison.”
Users not paying is only part of the problem. To use soap one must ask Jawed for it. ”Earlier, when I put it on the sink, people would just pinch the soap.” He also cleans the toilet only twice a day. ”I refuse to clean after every individual,” he said. ”People have this bad habit of not flushing.”
One toilet user however put the problem in perspective. ”There is no water and the flush never works, what are we supposed to do?” he asked. This reaction illustrates, in part, why squatting to relieve oneself in public is preferable to using public toilets, most of which are dilapidated and stinking.
Syed Imran Naqvi is an engineer with the Citizen’s Police Liaison Committee (CPLC), an independent statutory institution originally formed in this southern port city to help tackle crime, but which has taken on the task of providing Karachi’s citizenry with public toilets that work.
”People have to meet us half-way,” said Naqvi. ”Instead all we hear is complaints – when we put in urinals, people said it was not in keeping with our culture. When we then constructed Pakistani-style pans they told us they can’t squat.”
Shamim Junejo, chairman of the city’s Public Toilet Committee (PTC), takes the complaints in his stride. ”When public telephones were first installed people vandalised them, and it’s the same here,” he said. ”The idea is to keep making the facility available till people realise it’s for their convenience, and until they feel a sense of ownership.”
The CPLC toilet facilities are designed as units with four toilets each, two for women and two for men. They are built in partnership with the Town Municipal Administration, and the effort followed a 1999 survey to examine the state of public sanitation facilities in Karachi.
The picture emerged was far from pretty – it was found that there were only 38 toilets, some not in working condition. Others had become hideouts for drug addicts or shelters for the homeless.
”No one in their right mind would have wanted to use these toilets,” said Tasneem Siddiqui, chairperson of the Task Force on Municipal Services, which carried out the survey. ”Squatting in public was definitely a better option than using the toilets, which even stray dogs refused to enter.”
With the city’s needs for public toilets determined, discussions between the CPLC and the Karachi administration followed. The agreement was that the CPLC would raise funds for the construction of public toilets while the city municipality would provide the land.
Shahid Abdullah, a leading architect in Karachi, designed the model toilet, which is now being installed all over the city. The design is simple, easy to reproduce and the material used is indigenous.
”The emphasis is on ventilation, to keep them free of stink,” explained Imran Faiz, who is in charge of managing the toilet network. ”Water is supplied either by being piped, from a borewell or a storage tank. The Town Municipal Administration is responsible for providing land, water, sewerage and electricity.” With all factors in place, construction of a toilet block takes less than a month.
Of the 100 units the CPLC has promised to construct, 27 have so far been built and are operating. The units near hospitals are considered the most welcome by citizens. With a unit recently having been opened to public use near the out-patients department of the Civil Hospital, Junejo recounted, ”A doctor there told us that the patients have such a clean toilet, and can’t we do something about the ones used by doctors.”
More welcome is the simple fact that women’s needs are reflected in the new toilet blocks. Few of the toilets that were surveyed were designed to be used by women. That appalling lack is illustrated by the comment from the caretaker of the public toilet at the city’s Frere Market: ”There is no separate toilet for women, but if a lady wants to use it she’s most welcome – we won’t even charge them anything.”
While the CPLC effort relies on funds from businesses, philanthropists and members of the public – flush tanks, wash basins and water storage tanks are donated – Junejo emphasised that equally important is changing attitudes. ”Once that is achieved half the problem will be solved,” he said.