Europe, Headlines

CORRECTED/POLITICS-EUROPE: A New Fight Over An Old War

Brian Kenety

PRAGUE, Mar 2 2002 (IPS) - A row over policies on ethnic Germans going back to the Second World War is blocking joint efforts by four Central European nations to gain membership of the European Union.

An annual summit called March 1 by the four members of the Visegrad Group (the Czech and Slovak Republics, Hungary and Poland) on subsidies for farmers and financing in an enlarged EU was cancelled after new disputes over an old matter.

The dispute arose after Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orban demanded cancellation of the Benes decrees. Those decrees were issued in August 1945 by then Czechoslovak President Edvard Benes. The decrees had stripped about 2.5 million ethnic Germans, or the Sudeten Germans as they were called, and about 30,000 Hungarians of Czechoslovak citizenship.

The Sudeten Germans were about 2.5 million people of German origin who had come to settle in Sudetenland along the northern, western and southern borders of what is now the Czech Republic. That migration continued from the 12th century into the last one.

They are alleged to have welcomed Hitler’s forces in 1938. This led to their expulsion from what was then Czechoslovakia after the end of the Second World War. They fled to settle mostly in Germany.

The dispute now involves both the Czech Republic and Slovakia which seceded from Czechoslovakia in 1993.

Hungarians were affected because Hungary had supported Germany during the War. The messy dispute follows a bloody separation after the end of the War. Thousands were killed in a mass exodus of the Sudeten Germans over two years up to 1947.

The dispute has lingered on. Czech Prime Minister Milos Zeman is under fire from neighbouring Germany and Austria for an interview in January with the Austrian magazine Profil in which he described the Sudeten Germans as “Hitler’s fifth column” and as “traitors” lucky to have escaped death. German Chancellor Gerhard Schroeder cancelled a visit to Prague scheduled for March 22-23.

Now as the Central European countries prepare for EU membership, Orban told the foreign affairs committee of the European Parliament February 22 that those expulsion decrees, which still stand, are “incompatible with European legislation.”.

The Czech Republic and Slovakia, he said, should repeal these decrees before joining the EU.

The prime ministers of the Czech Republic and Slovakia announced that they would boycott the March 1 meeting in protest against the Hungarian leader’s remarks. Hungary was then obliged to cancel the annual summit of the Visegrad Group.

It was a critical meeting. The Visegrad Group states hope to join the EU in 2004 along with Slovenia, Cyprus, Malta, Latvia, Lithuania and Estonia. Bulgaria and Romania are expected to join a few years later.

EU Commissioner for Enlargement Guenter Verheugen said following Orban’s comments that the Benes decrees were a “bilateral” matter that would not figure in negotiations over EU membership. But that has not ended the dispute.

Centre-right politicians in Germany and Austria have threatened to block Czech efforts to join the EU unless the decrees are repealed.

Orban, who faces a tight election race this April, said he was “convinced that they (the decrees) would automatically lose their effect once Slovakia and the Czech Republic joined the EU.” Some Czech politicians say they have in effect “expired”. But not all Sudeten Germans are satisfied with that.

Erika Steinbach, head of Germany’s Federation of Expellees, insists that the Czech Republic be admitted to the EU only if the Benes decrees are repealed. “It is long overdue and bitterly necessary for the German government and other European Union states to demand severance with the expulsion decrees…as an absolute condition for membership,” she said in a recent interview.

Leaders are taking hard positions also in the Czech capital Prague and the Slovak capital Bratislava. Czech Foreign Minister Jan Kavan insists the Czech and Slovak officials were right to boycott the Visegrad Group summit.

“The Czech government has the same stand on this demand (to repeal the decrees) regardless of whether it comes from Vienna, Munich or from a visit by the Hungarian Prime Minister,” he said. “It is still the same demand and our reaction is still the same.”

Hungarian Foreign Affairs Minister Janos Martonyi sought to soften the dispute in an interview to Slovak Radio. Orban had only meant to “overcome some of the region’s troubling historical remnants,” he said.

Leaders from the Czech Republic and from Slovakia are asking for Hungary to put its own house in order. The so-called Status Law, which came into effect in Hungary last month offers seasonal work permits and educational, medical and travel benefits to an estimated 3.5 million ethnic Hungarians living in neighbouring countries other than Austria.

The EU has said the Hungarian law could mean unacceptable preference to a group of EU citizens after the EU enlargement.

Orban went on to alienate Slovakia by hinting that Budapest might not back Slovakia’s campaign to join NATO (North Atlantic Treaty Organisation), unless Bratislava accepts the Status Law.

Several modern-day commentators say the Benes decrees give sanction to ethnic cleansing and a notion of collective guilt. Petruska Sustrova argues in the Czech daily Lidovenoviny that despite his lack of tact and populism, “Orban is right that modern-day Europe simply cannot tolerate legislation based upon the principle of collective guilt.”

If Hungarians sided with the Nazis, so did the Slovaks, he says. But some Nazi collaborators became traitors, while others won the rights to grab their property.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags