Development & Aid, Economy & Trade, Headlines, North America

CANADA-AID: Film changes minds on foreign aid

Stephen Dale

OTTAWA, Nov 9 1995 (IPS) - What would Canadian tax-payers think about government cuts to foreign aid if they had the chance to witness — personally — how their development assistance dollars are spent?

That question is asked — and answered — in a new documentary film called ‘The Skeptics’ Journey’, which chronicles the experience of four self-described foreign aid “skeptics” who were flown to India and Nepal to examine a series of Canadian- funded, NGO-run aid projects.

The four were selected from over 2,000 respondents to a national newspaper and radio ad campaign that offered foreign aid foes a chance to test their beliefs against reality.

Three of the four Canadians selected for the on-camera expedition had never travelled outside the developed world, except to southern tourist resorts.

“We wanted people who were skeptical and who were ignorant, in the sense that they hadn’t had the opportunity to travel a lot,” says producer Mark Wright. “But we also wanted people who were intelligent and could wrap their heads around an issue.”

“One of the failures of our media is that it always gathers things in large bunches,” the filmmaker told IPS. “But we wanted to look at individual projects, to have our typical Canadians look at very ordinary projects and test their own ideas. These people started out with very definite views, but as they (become familiar with) what foreign aid is, those ideas start to fall apart.”

The film, broadcast on the all-news service of the Canadian Broadcasting Corporation (CBC), has prompted significant discussion in the Canadian media on the value of foreign aid.

While most of the recent coverage of development issues here has focused on scandal, the new film prompted the Ottawa Citizen newspaper to run an editorial reminding Canadians that “there is such a thing as good aid, and an incalculably vast need for it.”

Indeed, negative coverage in the Canadian media may have made it easier for the government to make its recent cuts to development assistance. Canada’s announcement last March that it would shrink its foreign aid budget by 21 percent — roughly 400 million US dollars — has been greeted with little outcry here.

Similarly, a CBC documentary claiming misuse of funds by CARE Canada, seems to have undermined Canadians’ willingness to support non-governmental organisations (NGOS) active in development. CARE’s lawsuit against the CBC asks for a settlement of over 3.9 million US dollars to cover lost donations.

Wright believes that it’s time for Canadians to have a more balanced discussion on what’s wrong and right with the Canadian aid program. “The news generally is about bad things,” he says. “People see the scandal but little else. That’s what the system is about. It’s important to try to restore some balance.”

Perhaps the most compelling character in ‘The Skeptics’ Journey’ is Gerald Pilger, a dairy farmer and teacher from a small town in Alberta, on the Canadian prairies. At first, Pilger appears as a typical Canadian “redneck:” dressed in cowboy gear, he holds strong opinions and isn’t shy about expressing them.

In the last Canadian election, Pilger voted for the Reform Party, a right-wing populist party which has been highly critical of Canada’s aid program and has called for major reduction in government spending — included cuts to social programs and development assistance. At first, Pilger’s personal views seem very much in tune with this rising political force.

“I am very skeptical of the way we handle our foreign aid assistance,” says Pilger at the beginning of the film. “I believe that throwing money at the problem is the wrong way to go, and that money does end up in the wrong hands in most instances… I don’t think we need to sell the farm to help the people. We have to take care of our own people first.”

But Pilger’s views start to soften as soon as he arrives in India. Having rarely ventured away from “the fresh mountain air and open spaces” of Alberta, he is shocked by the crowded conditions in Bombay and distressed by the conditions endured by the young children he meets, who must work all day cleaning shrimp to help support their families.

Pilger soon reveals himself to be a practical and discriminating thinker, who can see both positive and negative sides of an issue. He questions whether a special school in Bombay for working children, funded by Canadian Save the Children, would be necessary if the children were given money in lieu of wages and allowed to attend a regular school. He also is concerned that an irrigation project supported by the Aga Khan Foundation will create two classes of farmers – those with access to water and those without.

But the Canadian farmer is completely captivated by an Aga Khan project to teach water-retention techniques to farmers in parched Gujarat State. “This is, in my opinion, aid that really works,” he tells the camera. “They provided one demonstration site and the farmers have gone ahead and put in 24 structures in order to save water and obtain better production. I can’t think of a better way to use a small amount of money to achieve a goal.”

Pilger is also deeply moved by the work of a drop-in centre for street children, who barely survive by working as seat-savers at the Bombay Central train station. Although they have lost their childhood, he says, this project helps them become children again for a few hours each night.

By the end of the film, this skeptic reports that “I am surprised that I could find within myself the degree of support for the aid we send over here… From what I’ve seen, there’s a lot more good use of that money than poor use.”

Will this film have any impact on the politicians who have called for chopping Canada’s aid budget? The Skeptics’ Journey was screened for a group of Reform MPs, and was received surprisingly warmly.

“I really liked that show,” Reform’s foreign affairs critic Bob Mills told IPS. “It really pointed out that the poorest people are really helped by projects that the NGOs do. As citizens of the world, perhaps this is one of our responsibilities.”

Mills complains that Reform’s position on foreign aid is misunderstood, and that while Reform would cut the bureaucracy of the Canadian International Development Agency and slash bilateral aid, it supports funding for NGOs.

He cites an aid project that paid oil company executives high stipends to work with the oil industry in Russia as an example of aid gone wrong. “It’s not a left-right thing but an honesty thing,” says Mills. “Let’s not call it aid if it isn’t really aid. The problem is that part of the aid budget has become a slush fund for other things that don’t help the poor.”

However, Mills is not clear on whether Reform favours cutting bilateral aid projects that do reach the poor. He also says that Reform would not provide funding to NGOs in amounts that exceed what they can raise from the public.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags