Saturday, November 21, 2026
Rosario A. Liquicia
- Jakarta, like other cities across fast developing South-east Asia, is paying a high price for lopsided economic development that lures the rural poor to the capital but offers them little when they get there.
The signs of budding wealth — major highway construction, high- rise commercial blocks, clusters of five star hotels — are all here.
But this infrastructure caters only to rich Indonesian groups and foreign investors who cash in on the cheap labour that has lifted Indonesia’s annual economic growth to an average seven per cent in recent years.
Beneath the tall buildings, millions of poor languish in poverty in what is now the world’s 11th largest city.
The archipelago is home to 200 million people, making Indonesia the fourth most populous nation. Of this number, official statistics show that 15 per cent of the population lives in poverty. The figure is probably higher.
And while poverty-driven prostitution is not as rampant here as it is in for example Bangkok or Manila where street children hide in the shadows of huge shopping malls, the urban population crunch is proving to be just as painful a headache for Indonesia, as it is for Thailand and the Philippines.
In 1970, urban population in Asia was about 23 per cent of total population, by 1990, it was 35 per cent. During the period, urban population in Asia grew by 4.1 per cent a year, in contrast to 2.9 per cent worldwide.
Shared side-effects of the uncharted fast-paced economic development include housing shortages, increased pollution levels and an overburdened social system ill-equipped to cope with the rural influx to urban centres.
Household waste is the main source of surface water contamination, while lack of adequate sanitation facilities is a primary cause of faecal contamination of water supplies, the Indonesian government acknowledges in a paper prepared for next month’s Habitat II conference in Istanbul, Turkey.
Waste disposal problems will be exacerbated both by continued population growth and higher per capita income lifestyles that tend to produce more waste as incomes increase, the paper said.
For while Indonesia has managed to achieve a sharp cut in its overall population growth — it is projected to reach 209 million by 2000 — the urban sprawl continues at an annual population growth rate of five per cent, official statistics show.
Consequently, the percentage of the population living in urban areas is expected to increase from the current estimate of 31 per cent to around 40 per cent by year 2000 compared to 20 per cent five years ago, according to the government paper.
With continued industrial growth, pollution loads are also substantially increased. Recent monitoring of the discharge of large industries indicates that industrial pollution constitutes 25 to 50 per cent of total pollution load in different rivers in the northern coastal area of Java, it said.
Ground water also tends to be polluted in urban areas, where water tables are also dropping and salt water intrusion is affecting aquifers in coastal areas.
The World Bank estimates the environmental costs of air and water pollution in Jakarta at one billion dollars a year. The capital also suffers losses of up to 26 million dollars annually due to floods.
Another cost of pollution is that an estimated one per cent of Jakarta’s gross domestic product (GDP) is needed just to boil drinking water.
“Although incomes are rising in urban centres, this does not reflect real incomes that allow for congestion and environmental conditions that influence health and well-being,” Indonesia’s Habitat Agenda paper says.
It says many of the rural poor who have migrated to the cities have not improved their living conditions significantly. “This has resulted in the increase in the extent of urban slums and environmental degradation, reduction in basic infrastructure services, and limited employment opportunities.”
Housing space and basic amenities are also at a premium.
By 1993, only 14.71 per cent of total urban households were served by clean water, 55.29 per cent by electricity and 2.14 per cent by telecommunications facilities.
“Due to serious resource constraints and the poor performance of the housing sector in Indonesia, the gap between housing needs and supply has remained alarmingly large,” the government paper said.
Estimates of total housing demand vary. Under the government’s five-year development plan (1994-1999), there is need for 750,000 new units per year, 350,000 units to replace destroyed and obsolete housing and 100,000 units to make up for previous years’ backlogs, together amounting to 1.2 million units annually.
On top of this, another 700,000 dilapidated houses need to be upgraded.
The government acknowledges that given the magnitude of the housing needs and the constraints on available resources, any serious effort to address the housing problem will require a major policy shift in the delivery of shelter and related services.
“There is a need to shift the role of the government from its conventional role of supplier of housing to that of facilitator of the process,” the government paper notes.
For example, the government is now encouraging community groups to help themselves, providing them with access to credit, land and basic infrastructure.
In terms of physical structure, the paper notes that urban growth in many South-east Asian countries has recently been characterised by the emergence of fast-growing urban regions and corridors connecting large cities.
Traditional agricultural activities are now located side by side with industrial estates, new towns and even golf courses.
“These patterns of development have resulted in a growing intensity of rural-urban linkages and are blurring traditional urban-rural distinctions, especially in high density areas such as the northern coastal area of Java,” the paper said.
Rosario A. Liquicia
- Jakarta, like other cities across fast developing South-east Asia, is paying a high price for lopsided economic development that lures the rural poor to the capital but offers them little when they get there.
(more…)