Headlines, Latin America & the Caribbean

MUSIC: Thumbs Down Over Reggae Grammy Nominations

Howard Campbell

KINGSTON, Jan 20 1998 (IPS) - There has been a lot of muttering among Caribbean aficionados over nominations for this year’s U.S. Grammy awards in the Best Reggae Album category.

As has been the case since reggae was granted Grammy status in 1985, the selection panel of the National Academy of Arts And Sciences (NARAS), is under fire from the purists for “questionable” and “ill-advised” nominations.

The nominees for Best Reggae Album are Ziggy Marley and the Melody Makers for their “Fallen Is Babylon”; Burning Spear for “Appointment With His Majesty”; Steel Pulse for “Rage and Fury”; Aswad for “Big Up”; and Yellowman, who was nominated for his “Freedom Of Speech” set.

The winner will be chosen on Feb. 25 at the Grammy Award ceremony in the Radio City Music Hall in New York.

Neither the Melody Makers’ Fallen Is Babylon and Yellowman’s Freedom Of Speech have gained extensive air play here. In fact, some say the album of Bob Marley’s offspring for Elektra Records is virtually unknown.

The Melody Makers have won the Grammy for the Best Reggae Album twice. Their previous successes came with One Bright Day and Conscious Party which were both distributed by Virgin Records. Though sales are not considered a big factor for Grammy selection, sales for Fallen Is Babylon has been disappointing since it was released in July.

But according to respected reggae historian Roger Steffens, the Marley name, as it has shown in the past, is enough to give Bob Marley’s children their third Grammy.

“If my theory works, then Ziggy Marley will win yet again, simply because people recognise the Marley name,” said Steffens. The Los Angeles-based Steffens had criticised Bunny Wailer’s win last year as sentimental. Wailer’s album was a commemorative set in tribute to Marley’s 50th birthday.

Though several others agreed that the NARAS committee did not choose the best albums, Steffens said the poor standard of reggae albums during 1997 left the selection committee with no alternative.

“The albums chosen reflect the lacklustre quality of the past year,” Steffens stated. Managers at two labels that distributed two of the albums, took the news of their nominations in stride.

“As usual the nominations are quite interesting,” said Garret Vandermolen of Heartbeat Records, the label which handled Appointment With His Majesty’s distribution. Gary Himelfarb at RAS Records was just as somber. “It goes to show that it’s all about big names,” was how he summed up the selections.

Interestingly, Fallen Is Babylon is the only album of the nominees from a major record label. The others are distributed by small, independent companies, several of which have been unable to tap into the lucrative North American market.

Steel Pulse and Aswad, two groups that heralded the reggae movement on a mass scale in the United Kingdom in the 1970s, have both won the Grammy on one occasion. Both are signed to Mesa Records, a subsidiary of Atlantic Records.

Burning Spear, one of the most revered reggae performers, earns his seventh nomination on the strength of appointment With His Majesty’s strong showing. While not a mass seller by music industry standards, it reportedly topped the 5,000 unit mark, strong figures for an independent label like Massachusetts-based Heartbeat.

“He is the sentimental favourite in my opinion,” said Steffens. “It’s Spear’s seventh nomination, I hope this one will be his lucky one.” Yellowman rounds off the list with an album featuring the self-proclaimed king of deejay’s teaming with several big-name acts, like present dancehall kingpins Anthony B and Beenie Man.

While it is widely considered as Yellowman’s best of his six albums to date for Washington DC-based RAS, it too received little, if any, exposure in Jamaica. Others that did, like Luciano’s Messenger, failed to make the cut though it fared as well in terms of sales, as Fallen Is Babylon and Appointment With his Majesty.

There have been few popular winners of the reggae Grammy since Black Uhuru first took it home 13 years ago for Anthem. Peter Tosh’s No Nuclear War, which won posthumously in 1988, one year after the singer was murdered, was also seen as a token gesture.

Prior to winning for the third time in 1997 with Tribute To Bob Marley’s 50th Anniversary, Wailer’s previous wins were also regarded as cosmetic.

Though criticism abounds, some pundits blame the anonymity of the selections in reggae land to the strong bias of local radio to dancehall music. Many believe that until that trend is reversed, Jamaicans will continue to be left in the dark as far as Grammy selections go.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags