Headlines

RIGHTS-CANADA: Court Ruling on Fishing Sparks Violence

Mark Bourrie

OTTAWA, Oct 9 1999 (IPS) - Indigenous communities are locked in a violent dispute with the non-native fishing industry over the future of fishing off Canada’s Atlantic coastline.

The row stems from a ruling last month by the Supreme Court that a 1760 treaty between two native bands and the British government gave indigenous groups the right to engage in “subsistence” fishing year-round.

After the court’s decision, native fisherfolk set thousands of traps for lobsters – now out of season – and fist fights broke out with non-native fishermen and there also were incidences of arson.

Focus of the violence has been the Mi’kmaq reserve of Burnt Church, New Brunswick, where a native prayer building was burned down. A house and several cars belonging to non-natives were then torched and, this week, three Mi’kmaq youths were allegedly beaten with baseball bats.

Last weekend, hundreds of non-native fishermen cut loose an estimated 3,500 traps belonging to Mi’kmaq fishermen from the Burnt Church reserve and vandalized three plants suspected of processing lobsters caught out of season.

Native “peacekeeper” warriors from across eastern Canada have arrived in the Mi’kmaq community to guard equipment and property.

The Supreme Court decision angered Canadian fishermen who maintained that unregulated fishing and lobster taking by the indigenous groups was unfair to others and harmful to fish stocks.

The Minister for Fisheries, Herb Dhaliwal, said the government might close the native fishery if indigenous leaders could not agree on conservation regulations.

“If no acceptable solution can be found through dialogue and co- operation, I, as minister of fisheries and oceans, will act on my responsibility and authority to protect the resource,” Dhaliwal stressed.

“Let me make it clear: There will be a regulated fishery or no fishery at all.”

Dhaliwal wanted native leaders to agree to a fishing season and catch limits, but most have rejected a deal with the government. Meetings between the minister and native chiefs continued throughout the week with no decisions reached.

In Ottawa, Prime Minister Jean Chretien told reporters the government may ask the Supreme Court of Canada to delay application of the ruling, but recognized the right of natives in the Maritimes to a commercial fishery.

“The lawyers are looking at the possibility of asking the Supreme Court to stay the judgement for some time,” Chretien said.

Mi’kmaq leaders, who urged their people to continue fishing, said Ottawa’s veiled threats were a slap in the face.

“I feel devastated. My people got hurt. Their property has been damaged, and now the prime minister wants to step in and suspend it? I can’t see that happening,” said Vernon Mitchell, a band councillor for Burnt Church First Nation.

“My members will continue fishing regardless of what the prime minister says.”

But not all chiefs are willing to risk further trouble. Bernd Christmas, a negotiator for the Assembly of Nova Scotia Mi’kmaq Chiefs, said chiefs of the native bands scattered in the region would reconsider whether to stick to the resolution they made in late September to keep fishing.

Alexa McDunnough, leader of the federal opposition New Democratic Party, urged Canada’s government to compensate the Mi’kmaq for their fishing equipment and the catch that they had lost.

“They have the legal right to fish, and they should not be victimized and intimidated,” she said.

Ken Clark, a municipal councillor in Miramichi, New Brunswick, admitted he helped plan the destruction of native fishing equipment after the federal government refused to stop the Mi’kmaqs from fishing during the lobster breeding season. He said non-native fishers were enraged when trucks began delivering thousands of lobster traps to native reserves.

“They (the natives) have no interest in conservation. It’s a matter of greed. It’s economics.

They are there for the fast buck. They don’t care if they destroy the industry,” he said.

lihris Bonnell, a fisherman and Burnt Church band councillor, was one of the few Mi’kmaq to venture onto the water after the first attacks on natives. He said he witnessed the destruction of his traps, worth 5,000 dollars, before non-natives forced him back to shore.

Bonnell said authorities looked on while the fishing equipment was wrecked.

“We got a good (court) ruling for a change, and we simply exercised our rights,” he said. We weren’t breaking the law but for some reason they went out there and they broke the law.

“They’re just like vigilantes. Are they above the law?”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags

Headlines, Human Rights, North America

RIGHTS-CANADA: Court Ruling on Fishing Sparks Violence

Mark Bourrie

OTTAWA, Oct 8 1999 (IPS) - Indigenous communities are locked in a violent dispute with the non-native fishing industry over the future of fishing off Canada’s Atlantic coastline.
(more…)

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags