Headlines

RIGHTS-GERMANY: Deportee Death Raises Questions But Not Debate

Yojana Sharma

BERLIN, Jun 5 1999 (IPS) - It was supposed to be one of Germany’s “routine” deportations of asylum seekers. A motorcycle helmet was clamped onto Sudanese Aaamir Ageeb head in the flight from Frankfurt to Khartum”for his own protection” and to “stop him biting.”

He was held down in his seat by two German border police sitting either side of him in the Lufthansa Jet from Frankfurt to Sudan via Cairo. They pushed his head as far down as it would go.

The difference in this “routine” was that when police tried to raise Aamir, 30, who was also handcuffed and his ankles shackled, from his unnatural head-down position, they could not. He was dead. “The deadly results of an inhuman policy towards asylum seekers,” as Heiko Kauffman, spokesman of the German refuge e concern group Pro Asyl put it.

The incident last week, follows on the heels of the death of a Sierra Leone deportee who died four weeks ago, apparently of suffocation, when his mouth was taped during his deportation by Austrian authorities from Vienna.

These incidents call into question police methods in handling asylum seekers, particularly from the Third World.

Human rights activists in Europe believe it is no coincidence that the two cases and that of a Nigerian woman who died when police suffocated her with a cushion while being deported from Brussels last September, all involved Africans even though more than two thirds of those seeking asylum in western Europe are fro m Eastern Europe and the Balkans.

The case of the Nigerian woman caused uproar in Belgium, culminating in the resignation of then interior minister Louis Tobback.

In Austria, where a new right-wing government is in place, the death of Marcus Omofuma from Sierra Leone unleashed a major public debate which did not go unnoticed in Germany. German interior minister Otto Schily called for an overhaul of German deportation methods in the wake of the Omofuma case.

However in Germany a similar outcry is barely to be heard over the treatment of Aamir – the two German border police who accompanied Aamir have not even been suspended from duty pending an enquiry. Calls for Schily’s resignation have been muted and, unlike Belgium and Austria the issue is not front-page news.

In Bavaria the conservative Christian Social Union, the ruling party in the state which ordered Aamir’s deportation is even refusing to halt deportations of asylum seeker who are likely to resist, as ordered Monday by Federal interior minister Schily.

“This will merely reward violent deportees”, said Bavarian interior minister Guenther Beckstein who is known for his hardline stance on foreigners and refugees.

He called Schily’s order an “ill considered reaction”. The United Nations High Commission for Refugees, on the other hand has welcomed Schily’s decision and called for deportations only “under humane conditions.”

The Bavarian authorities want to deport another Sudanese asylum seeker who they claim had run amok during a previous attempt at deportation last year, and insist they will go ahead. However as the Border police come under Federal jurisdiction, the Bava rian authorities may not be able to defy Bonn – deportations cannot be carried out without the border police.

In 1997 over 17,000 asylum seekers were deported, 11,000 of them from Frankfurt, Germany’s main international airport which has special detention cells for deportees. Most left unwillingly. Yet Pro Asyl believes the report of violence and injury sustained during forced deportation are rising.

“Sometimes deportations must be interrupted because of strong resistance,” notes Kauffman, and occasionally the captain may refuse to carry violent passengers because of danger to other passengers.

The Border police say of some 15,500 deportations of asylum seekers carried out since January 1998, 113 violently resisted deportation.

“These people have had to be forcibly calmed,” said Klaus Ludwig, spokesman for the Border police although he added that since the death in 1994 of Nigerian asylum seeker Kole Bankole, who had been gagged and sedated while being deported, gags and anything that would hinder breathing are no longer permitted by l aw.

Pro Asyl maintains that prohibited methods are still used during deportations.

Countless other incidents of overuse of force by police are being reported to Europe-based concern groups which maintain incidents have increased as the rules tighten up on asylum seekers.

In some cases this is because fewer asylum bids are accepted by European countries leading to desperate attempts to stay . “Asylum seekers are extremely depressed, often distraught and sometimes suicidal,” says Pro Asyl.

However, some human rights groups say they detect an alarming tendency for police to use violence on more and more occasions. And in many cases this violence is unacceptable.

The Anti-Racist Initiative, a Berlin-based group says it has documented at least four cases of death as a result of deportation from Germany between 1993 and end 1998, and 58 injured. The deaths include the unborn baby of a Kosovo woman being deported in February 1998, in circumstances still unexplained.

They maintain dozens of others have attempted and some have succeeded in committing suicide when threatened with expulsion from the country, on their return to their homelands.

Even without such dire statistics, most deportations of Africans in particular are allegedly carried out without respect for human dignity. Pro Asyl calls the deportations “organised inhumanity”. Both Pro Asyl and Anti-racist groups say brutal treatment of deportees is widespread.

In one example in April 1998 a Ghanian, Joseph Gyimah was deported from Berlin. The border police were criticised for having manhandled Gyimah and eyewitnesses on the flight reported that Gyimah had been chained by the legs and stomach to his seat.

The Strasbourg-based Council of Europe’s anti-torture committee has requested information from the German authorities on the use of force during deportations from Frankfurt airport. A delegation from the Council even visited the airport in May 1998 in response to complaints from various human rights groups representing asylum seekers.

Between 1997 and the first half of 1998, as many as eight legal investigations were launched against German border police at Frankfurt airport for manhandling deportees.

Meanwhile in Germany, Green party politicians who are part of the ruiling coalition with the Social Democrats say public apathy and the lack of any outcry against the authorities mean that more such cases “are waiting to occur.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags

Europe, Headlines

RIGHTS-GERMANY: Deportee Death Raises Questions But Not Debate

Yojana Sharma

BERLIN, Jun 2 1999 (IPS) - It was supposed to be one of Germany’s “routine” deportations of asylum seekers. A motorcycle helmet was clamped onto Sudanese Aaamir Ageeb head in the flight from Frankfurt to Khartum”for his own protection” and to “stop him biting.”
(more…)

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags