Friday, November 20, 2026
Brian Kenety
- The environmental pressure group Greenpeace International has welcomed the European Parliament’s vote for legally binding national minimum targets in a directive on renewable energy. The directive also excluded waste incineration from the definition of renewable energy sources, another move Greenpeace has applauded.
The document by Member of European Parliament (MEP) Mechtild Rothe (Germany, Socialist), adopted with a number of amendments, stressed that renewable energies form an effective strategy for environmental protection and would help the European Union (EU) to achieve international targets set in Kyoto for reducing greenhouse gases believed to contribute to global warming.
“This is a great step towards effective promotion of true renewable energies,” said Axel Singhofen, EU Advisor for Greenpeace International, of Thursday’s vote. “The message of the Parliament is clear: binding targets for clean energy have to be established instead of vague intentions that would even allow the promotion of dirty technologies such as waste incineration.”
The Greens-EFA Group in the European Parliament welcomed the support for the directive. MEP Claude Turmes (Luxembourg), the co-ordinator on energy matters for the group, said: “By rejecting the Conservative amendments on inclusion of waste incineration, the European Parliament … preserved its credibility in the eyes of the public on renewable energies. It is also a call on the (COP 6) climate change negotiations currently underway in The Hague to follow suit.”
Indeed, Greenpeace is now calling on the 15 EU member states to support the position of the European Parliament on targets and the exclusion of waste incineration. EU Energy Commissioner Loyola de Palacio had supported the exclusion of waste incineration from the definition of renewable energy sources.
According to Greenpeace, this will make it very difficult to see waste incineration included in the definition of renewable energy; the United Kingdom, Italy and the Netherlands and other countries have argued for its inclusion.
“Such a move would not only result in ‘greenwashing’ of a highly polluting activity, but would actually allow member states to achieve lower targets for energy production from true renewable sources,” said Greenpeace in a statement.
In December 1997, industrialised countries meeting in Japan set down binding, quantitative obligations to reduce emissions of greenhouse gases. The ‘Kyoto Protocol’ sets targets for industrialised countries to reduce emissions to 1990 levels by 2008-2012.
For the EU as a whole, that would mean an eight percent cut. Environment ministers meeting here Tuesday compared each EU member state’s position for the last time before leaving for The Hague conference (Nov. 13-24), known as COP6 (the 6th Conference of Parties to the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change).
The EU is working towards having renewable energy make up 12 percent of energy consumption by 2010, in part by encouraging the use of low-carbon fuels.
Incineration of municipal waste is Europe’s single largest source of dioxins; one of the world’s most dangerous chemicals and known to cause cancer in humans. A global ban on dioxins is currently being discussed by the world’s governments.
The last International Negotiating Committee meeting to discuss the first global ban on persistent organic pollutants, which prioritises dioxins as one of 12 chemicals in need of urgent action, is scheduled to take place in Johannesburg, South Africa from Dec. 4 ¡ 9.
Greenpeace, however, condemned the vote of the European Parliament to include peat into the definition of renewable energy. Commissioner de Palacio had stated here on Wednesday that the European Commission, the EU’s executive arm, would not support the inclusion of peat into the definition.
“Everyone knows that peat is fossil matter, and moreover, its exploration destroys environmentally precious moorland”, said Singhofen. “Promoting peat as a ‘renewable energy’ source is technically incorrect, environmentally destructive and counterproductive to the promotion of true renewable energy sources.”
Peat is found in moorland and is the result of century-long degradation of plant material, which qualifies it as fossil matter. The quarrying of peat has led to the destruction of much of the moorland in Europe, endangering fauna and flora specific to such environments and impacting substantially on their effectiveness as terrestrial carbon sinks.
Finnish and Irish parliamentarians had pushed for and won the ‘annual increment of peat’ to be included in the definition of renewables, prompting MEP Tumes to quip: “How anyone is going to figure out which piece of a turf bog grows each year, so they can call it renewable is beyond me”.
Parliament also left room to develop investment into large hydropower plants, for modernisation purposes. But it maintained the 10 MW limit for operating supports, to protect other sources of renewables from the competitive nature of these large hydro plants.
MEP Tumes added that it was now incumbent upon France, which currently holds the rotating EU Presidency, to bring a better proposition to the next gathering of EU energy and environment ministers on Dec. 5.