Headlines, Middle East & North Africa

POLITICS-LEBANON: Kidnapping By Hizbollah: Blunder Or Success?

Kim Ghattas

BEIRUT, Oct 11 2000 (IPS) - Opinions are still divided in Lebanon about Hizbollah’s kidnapping of three Israeli soldiers last Saturday in south Lebanon, as fears of a military escalation slowly settle, without, however, completely vanishing.

Words of war were still in the air Wednesday evening as Israeli premier, Ehud Barak, stated that Israel “kept to itself the right” to strike back in response to the kidnapping of the three soldiers.

The three Israelis were kidnapped along the Israeli-Lebanese border by Hizbollah, the local Islamic guerilla and political party, which spearheaded the fight to oust out the Israelis from south Lebanon. Israel’s 22-year long occupation ended in May this year.

Hizbollah is now looking for a swap with the 19 Lebanese prisoners held in Israeli jails but has given no details on negotiations or specific demands.

While the local newspaper “al Safir” reported that an unnamed US official had warned yesterday of an Israeli blitz against Lebanon if the issue of the three soldiers was not resolved, local observers were less certain that a military escalation would be Israel’s choice.

While the Lebanese brace themselves for whatever might happen, if anything, they are not all happy with Hizbollah’s renewed military activity along the border.

“We’ve no need now to reach a point that we’re not ready to confront,” said the head of the Christian Maronite league, Hareth Chehab.

“Anything that happens should take place according to Lebanese consensus first and Arab consensus second, instead of opening up the Lebanese front (for the Palestinians) at a time when other Arab countries are striving to normalize relations with Israel,” he added.

Another strong stance against Hizbollah’s move came from newly elected legislator and rightist Christian, Albert Mokheiber.

“Which authority has given Hizbollah the green light to carry out this war-like operation?” he said.

“It is illogical to believe that Hizbollah has staged the operation without the permission of a Lebanese or non-Lebanese (i.e. Syrian) authority. Such operations and the stone-throwing provocations are bound to trigger a new war on Lebanese soil,” he added.

For the moment, diplomacy seems to be taking over.

UN secretary general, Kofi Annan, was due to arrive in Lebanon Wednesday to meet with Lebanese president Emile Lahoud. There are no details yet as to whether he would meet with Hizbollah secretary general Sayyed Hassan Nasrallah.

The EU higher representative for foreign policy, Javier Solana, was also in Beirut as well as Iranian foreign minister, Kamal Kharrazi.

At a press conference on Wednesday, Hizbollah’s deputy secretary general, Naim Qassem, pointed out that Hizbollah would agree to Annan mediating in the swap, despite Hizbollah’s reservations about the UN’s interpretations of the UN resolution 425, which called for the withdrawal of Israel of south Lebanon and restoration of Lebanese sovereignty along the border.

While Annan said that the kidnapping was a violation of resolution 425, Hizbollah justified its action by pointing out that the area where the soldiers were kidnapped, the Shebaa farms, is Lebanese territory, which Israel has not returned yet.

Hizbollah has also maintained since the withdrawal that the UN resolution would not be fully implemented unless all Lebanese prisoners in Israeli jails were freed.

Qassem also did not rule out the involvement of another government in the negotiations.

Germany took part in previous such negotiations two years ago when Lebanese prisoners were swapped for the bodies of Israeli soldiers killed in a botched commando raid in Lebanon.

However, he did not give details about the negotiations, simply saying that there were contacts between the two sides.

“To start with, this is a swap operation. We wanted through the capture of the three Jews to swap them for prisoners in Israeli prisons. As for the details of the negotiations, we decided yesterday not to talk about them to maintain (a strong position),” said Qassem

“Nothing you hear, even if it comes from Hizbollah (leaders) is true, unless it comes from (Secretary General) Sayyed Hassan Nasrallah,” he added.

An earlier statement by a Hizbollah spokesman, Muwaffaq al Jammal, about the party’s demands stated that Hizbollah demanded the release of the 19 Lebanese prisoners held in Israel in exchange for information about the three kidnapped Israeli soldiers.

Qassem also seemed confident that no military escalation would take place, despite what he called Israeli “muscle stretching”, among others by acting foreign minister, Shlomo Ben Ami, who said that Israel demanded the unconditional release of the three Israeli soldiers.

“Barak knows very well what the consequences would be if he launched an aggression against Lebanon and he is not ready to deal with the consequences when he is faced with a quagmire in Palestine. Only acceptable channels of negotiations will achieve something,” said Qassem.

In military terms, the operation was a definite success for Hizbollah. Well planned and swift, there were no Hizbollah members injured and it took the Israeli army 30 minutes to realize what had happened, long enough for the kidnapped to be well away from the site of the incident.

Ironically however, the Israeli army was aware that Hizbollah was planning such a move and there were several reports in the press warning about such a possibility. Now, there are reports of negligence in Israeli newspapers to explain the kidnapping.

But for Simon Karam, Lebanese lawyer and former ambassador to the US, Hizbollah’s move is a political blunder.

“Hizbollah is not happy about their post liberation position and this is one way of fighting against being marginalized,” he said

Despite its leading role in driving the Israelis out of Lebanon, Hizbollah did not cash on their victory during the legislative elections in September, reigned in by neighboring Syria who calls the political shots in Lebanon.

But the party, who already had nine members in parliament and will now have 12, showed great constraint in discipline during the campaign and gained more in respect from the Lebanese.

“But if this is supposed to be a calculated performance to see Hizbollah’s political inclusion, it’s a blunder. You cannot act like they did during the elections and then return to this kind of behaviour,” he said.

The one possible benefit of this incident according to Karam is that the status quo that prevailed at the Lebanese Israeli border until last week cannot be put back in place after this incident.

Until now only a token presence of the Lebanese army has been sent to the newly freed areas, despite international as well as local calls for a larger Lebanese army presence along the border where Hizbollah outposts were still visible until Saturday.

The kidnapping has renewed these calls and it will be on the agenda of all talks between the Lebanese president and foreign diplomats.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags