Friday, November 20, 2026
Ferry Biedermann
- The Israeli-Palestinian conflict is balancing between hope and fear as Israel maintains its stranglehold over Gaza and the West Bank and Yasser Arafat is pushed to reassert control over his own people.
While just before Christmas there was a lull in the fighting, most forecasts were extremely gloomy.
“This is the most dramatic crisis in the peace process”, said Europe’s long-time envoy to the region, Miguel Moratinos before he left the region mid-December. “There is no peace and there is no process”, the normally unflappable diplomat told reporters. “We are looking to avoid a total collapse.”
The situation is murkier than ever, with Israeli troops still present on nominally Palestinian controlled land and unflinching determination on the government’s part not to let Arafat “get away with it this time”.
There is a reduced but erratic level of violence and a mixed show of determination by the Palestinian Authority to deal with the militant opposition.
Israeli memories of the dozens of people who died in the militants’ suicide attacks are still to fresh to allow much room for compromise. The same goes for the Palestinian memories of the people killed in Israeli actions and the still-present everyday hardships of life under the Israeli stranglehold.
In this tense atmosphere, Israel and the international community are watching how Arafat is using the pause in military actions and the relative quiet to re-impose control over his people.
As he has done before, the Palestinian leader uses a mix of force and persuasion to bring the militants of Hamas and Jihad into line.
While this may calm down the situation, it leaves the operational infrastructures of the militants largely intact. Hamas has, for example, now promised to cease suicide attacks and to stop firing mortars at Israeli positions but it reserves the right to fight the Israeli’s if it sees fit.
The question is whether in the current climate the international community, and especially the U.S., will agree to such loose arrangements.
The international shift in the approach to the crisis after the recent series of suicide attacks on Israelis is remarkable.
The Israeli demand that first of all there should be a total cessation of violence was hardly taken seriously until recently.
Now it is seen as the only way out, not only because it is impossible to negotiate while such attacks go on, but also because proof is needed that Arafat is still in control and is genuinely interested in negotiations. Israel’s willingness to compromise can be tested only after that.
The fact that Israel has itself contributed to the current situation by continuing violent operations against the Palestinians, even in relatively quiet times, is overlooked more than before in foreign, particularly western, capitals because of the unacceptable nature of the Palestinian struggle in the post- September 11 climate.
The intifada is perceived to have turned from a popular uprising into a terror and guerrilla war, which cannot be condoned under the current international circumstances.
The right wing of the Israeli government still sees a “golden opportunity” in the words of one minister, to deal a knockout blow to the Palestinian Authority (PA) and possibly even to “send Arafat back to Tunis, where he belongs”.
Sharon and his ultra-rightist colleagues in the broad “coalition of national unity” have never had any sympathy for the 1993 Oslo agreements that established the PA. They are eager to find a way to turn the clock back to the situation of more or less full Israeli control and re- impose the right’s cherished and indefinite ‘status quo’.
That is why they are not bothered by the seeming absence of an alternative or a successor to Arafat. Not having anybody to deal with, to them means not having to deal with anybody.
The right is getting what it wants for now as the Palestinian Authority is being taken apart bit by bit. Many of the Israeli attacks have struck at the heart of Arafat’s ambitions. His helicopters and his symbolically important Gaza Airport lie in ruins and this month even the antenna of his radio station was brought down.
The Israelis are targeting all the trappings of a state, making clear that this Palestinian goal is farther removed than ever before. The strikes for now seem to leave the operational capacity of the PA more or less intact. The option of Arafat reasserting control is still left open but the door is closing rapidly.
The eagerness to sideline Arafat is worrying the left wing of the Israeli government. Foreign Minister Shimon Peres did not agree for example with a recent government statement declaring Arafat “irrelevant”. This may be out of a growing realisation that it was not Arafat that is being made irrelevant but he and his moderately dovish Labour Party.
Peres and the other Labour ministers are starting to feel less and less comfortable in a government that is seeking to dismantle the heritage of Yitzhak Rabin and everything they have worked for over the past decade.
Peres clearly favours a return to the negotiating table but Sharon’s policies lack a diplomatic component that would make that possible.
The Palestinians are well aware of this and, according to observers, have used the lack of diplomatic perspective as a justification for the continuation of the violence.
This, along with ongoing Israeli operations, such as incursions, so-called targeted assassinations of militants and the bombing of the PA infrastructure, appears to be making it difficult for Arafat to re- impose control.
“Let them first stop their attacks, then we can try and take steps”, a Palestinian minister recently said.