Friday, November 20, 2026
Abid Aslam
- The first comprehensive attempt by governments and global institutions to reduce the debt burden of the poorest countries is in danger of joining the long list of failed efforts to solve the debt crisis in the Third World.
That is because “the political alliance behind (it) has fragmented,” Oxfam International says in a report released before meetings scheduled Thursday and Friday, between finance ministers and central bank governors from member countries of the World Bank and International Monetary Fund (IMF).
The report highlights resistance from the IMF, Japan, Germany, and Italy. “Our assessment is that the initiative was passed over their objections in the first place so we need to rely on other countries to keep pushing it along,” said Justin Forsyth, director of Oxfam’s advocacy office here.
The governing boards of the Bank and IMF in 1996 approved the ‘Heavily Indebted Poor Countries’ (HIPC) debt initiative. Until then, the agencies had insisted that the Third World debt crisis involved only bilateral and commercial lenders. Oxfam risked its relations with other non-governmental organisations when it became the first and most prominent group to throw its support behind the effort.
“We believed that, implemented with political resolve and subject to some changes, the initiative had the potential to facilitate a transition to debt sustainability, with attendant benefits for poverty reduction, investment and economic growth,” the report states. “Unfortunately, the potential remains unrealised.”
HIPC was unique for bringing together the ‘Group of Seven’ (G-7) industrial powers, the ‘Paris Club’ of bilateral lenders, and the Bank, Fund, and other multilateral creditors. But as a result, countries cannot receive relief unless all parties foot their proportional share of the bill.
“In East Asia, over 100 billion dollars has been mobilised in the space of a few months, with the IMF bending its rules in every conceivable direction to ensure rapid disbursement,” Oxfam notes. “In the case of the highly indebted poor countries in Africa and elsewhere, it has apparently been impossible to drive forward an initiative which will cost around seven billion dollars over five years.”
Mozambique’s application for relief in particular “underlined the Paris Club’s woeful incapacity to take decisive action and pointed to an apparent willingness on the part of the (G-7) countries to allow HIPC to drift.”
Bank and IMF officials had determined that Mozambique, one of the world’s poorest countries, would need a 1.5 billion dollar reduction in debt stock to achieve the HIPC goal of ‘sustainability’ – or a level of debt which can be serviced within the government’s means.
Mozambique owed a large share of its debts to Paris Club members – and Russia in particular. Club rules allowed for a reduction of up to 80 percent in debt not previously rescheduled but this would provide insufficient relief to meet the bilateral lenders’ portion of the relief bill.
Club members in January ended a nearly year-long stalemate by offering to add a 170 million dollar aid package to their standing offer. That left a 100-million-dollar shortfall for the World Bank and others to cover.
Similar difficulties await at least five other countries with debt portfolios similar to Mozambique’s, Oxfam warned. These include Guinea-Bissau, Madagascar, Nicaragua, Rwanda, and Sao Tome.
Uganda, Bolivia, and Guyana will reach their HIPC ‘completion point’ – at which they begin to see relief – this year. Mozambique and Cote d’Ivoire will not benefit until 1999 and Burkina Faso, not before 2000.
Mali is under consideration and could see relief in 1999 or 2000. Ethiopia, Guinea Bissau, Mauritania, and Zambia are in line for relief in 2001. Madagascar, Nicaragua, Niger, Sao Tome and Tanzania will have to wait until 2002 and Burundi, Congo and Rwanda, at least until 2003.
Cameroon, Honduras, Senegal, Togo, Viet Nam, and Yemen have yet to learn whether they qualify at all.
Ironically, while HIPC offers the prospect of reductions in debt stock some six years after countries qualify for treatment, in the interim it threatens African countries with an increase in debt servicing costs that could undermine the end result.
“During the 1990s, the scheduled debt service ratio for sub- Saharan Africa has been around 30 percent (of export earnings). Actual payments have been in the range of 15-20 percent, resulting in a continued build-up of arrears,” according to the report.
Because HIPC deems service ratios ‘sustainable’ at 20-25 percent, however, it “will only reduce debt service to levels above those which are being paid at present, with the result that debt will continue to impose a severe strain on foreign exchange and fiscal resources.”
Even the minimum 20 percent would double Mozambique’s current payments. HIPC also has been hobbled by the requirement that, to qualify, countries first obtain the IMF’s stamp of approval for implementing structural adjustment programmes. Reforms were needed but should not be entrusted to the IMF, Oxfam argued.
“It’s not a question of not reforming but one of the IMF’s domination of the decision-making process,” said Oxfam debt analyst Veena Siddharth. The Fund, she argued, was rigid in applying the criteria and ill-equipped to see through recommendations that relief be geared toward education and health programmes, and that preferential treatment be granted countries making progress in these areas.
The World Bank’s ‘Development Committee’ is expected to review progress on HIPC in meetings here Thursday. The Bank and IMF last week announced that Uganda would begin to receive debt relief – including some 229 million dollars from the agencies – as early as this month.
Relief could have been offered sooner but was held up largely because G-7 officials feared swift action would raise the hopes of other countries, according to Siddharth. World Bank officials agreed privately with that assessment.