Economy & Trade, Headlines, North America

POLITICS-US: Hard Compromise Opens Congressional Action on IMF Funding

Abid Aslam

WASHINGTON, Mar 6 1998 (IPS) - U.S. administration efforts to win 18 billion dollars for the International Monetary Fund (IMF) survived a key Congressional committee vote late Thursdaythe first step in a potentially arduous journey through Congress.

The House of Representatives Banking and Financial Services Committee approved a bill authorising 3.5 billion dollars for an IMF line of credit to be used in financial crises and 14.5 billion dollars to bolster the Fund’s capital base, made up of membership subscriptions or ‘quotas’.

But in a last-minute twist, committee members agreed a measure that would block the funding unless U.S. Treasury Secretary Robert Rubin can convince lawmakers that private investors and banks have made a “significant prior contribution” to bail-out efforts in Asia.

Exactly what it would take to convince the lawmakers had yet to be worked out, according to a legislative aide to Rep. Bernard Sanders, one of the measure’s authors. Rubin has argued that private creditors already have sustained heavy losses and agreed to roll over short-term debts owed them by South Korean companies. Committee members were not satisfied with that response, the aide asserted.

Also to be seen was whether the blocking provision would emerge unscathed from the legislative battle ahead, Congressional sources said.

Administration officials, displeased by the measure, nevertheless touted the committee’s general approval as a victory not only for them but also for groups whose concerns were reflected in calls for greater “transparency” in IMF operations and greater sensitivity to environmental and labour concerns.

Members of those groups were less enthusiastic, however, and noted that conditions dealing with the IMF’s own performance would be enforced only after the funds were released.

“Some of the language is very good but anything that says, ‘Here’s the money, now we want you to do x, y, and z’ is meaningless,” said Marijke Torfs, international department chief at Friends of the Earth. Washington “can’t attach conditions to money once it has been given because the IMF is a multilateral institution,” she explained.

Sanders, an Independent from Vermont, acknowledged that problem and urged the committee to strengthen measures to enforce the bill’s provisions and supervise the IMF. “We have been successful in shifting the framework of the debate” he said, “but these words are not enough to be certain that our intent is carried out.”

The bill now must be taken up by House appropriations committees and by the Senate before Congress as a whole votes. That process likely will take another couple of weeks and will present new hurdles for the administration, according to lawmakers and analysts.

Right-wing Republicans vowed to oppose any deal unless the administration agreed to deny U.S. aid to foreign groups deemed to be providing or promoting abortions. Funding for the IMF was defeated last year over the same issue.

Legislative staffers had expected the House banking committee to reach its decision easily and early in the day, after U.S. Treasury Department officials agreed Wednesday to encourage the IMF to be more open to public demand for information about its operations and more sensitive to environmental and labour issues. They also agreed to report to Congress every year on progress toward those goals.

“The deal is on,” Rep. Barney Frank of Massachusetts, the ranking Democrat on the committee, said afterwards.

Also Wednesday, IMF Managing Director Michel Camdessus met with committee members behind closed doors, his second trip to Capitol Hill since the current legislative session began in January. Fund officials have been worried that if the United States, their largest shareholder, failed to come up with the money, nobody else would contribute to a 45-percent increase in the agency’s lending resources.

In the end, the bill passed only after exhausting negotiations during which Sanders, with support from Republicans and Democrats, pushed through a resolution calling for the release from detention and dropping of all charges against Indonesian constitutional lawyer and independent labour leader Muchtar Pakpahan.

Committee members also backed a provision to assess the effect of IMF prescriptions on borrowing countries and the U.S. economy – and in particular, to track U.S. jobs and imports in the wake of overseas bail-outs. Washington would place conditions on its participation in future financial rescue efforts on the basis of these studies.

The 1994 ‘Sanders-Frank amendment’, which required the U.S. government to use its “voice and vote” to urge the IMF “to adopt policies to encourage borrowing countries to guarantee internationally-recognised workers’ rights”, was updated to require Washington to “vigorously promote” those rights and make their enforcement a condition for loan approvals.

“In three and a half years there has not been one concrete example of the U.S. executive director casting a vote against an IMF initiative” because it failed to advance collective bargaining or other labour rights, Sanders lamented.

That now could change, according to his legislative director, Jane O’Meara Sanders. Reformers in key subcommittee positions seemed intent on bringing the IMF under the banking committee’s oversight “as never before”, she said.

The proposed law, while “not as strong as we would have liked, is still the best IMF bill we have ever seen from Congress,” she argued.

Others, however, questioned whether the new bill – if finally passed by Congress and signed by Clinton – would have any lasting effect. Said one environmental lobbyist: “Congress has a very short memory. Once the legislation’s passed, who cares about the IMF.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags