Asia-Pacific, Development & Aid, Environment, Headlines

ENVIRONMENT-VIETNAM: Polluters Face Hefty Fines, Relocation

Tran Dinh Thanh Lam

HO CHI MINH CITY, Vietnam, Jan 28 2004 (IPS) - The year 2004 could be a tough one for polluters in Vietnam as the government considers slapping a hefty ”environment fee” on consumers and businesses caught dumping wastewater.

It has already told polluting enterprises they must move out of congested urban areas. But as usual, there are some difficulties with the plan.

The government has listed 4,295 enterprises nationwide responsible for severe environmental pollution and said it plans to sort out the industrial pollution problem before 2007.

Measures include moving polluters out of urban areas, shutting them down or improving their waste treatment facilities.

A task force headed by the Natural Resources and Environment (NRE) Ministry and including industry representatives has been set up to oversee the plan’s implementation.

But an NRE ministry official admitted this was not an easy task, especially as the ministry was only set up early last year. ”We have to be very careful because environmental pollution is a sensitive issue,” he said. ”Dealing with the polluters, we cannot affect their sustainable development.”

In Ho Chi Minh City, 52 businesses listed in a ”black book” for pollution offences were scheduled to leave their premises between 2002 and 2003. Another 30,000 polluting establishments must be relocated to the outskirts by 2004.

But to date only a few have complied. Most of the city’s businesses keep on discharging more than 150,000 cubic metres of wastewater daily, along with nearly 3,000 tonnes of waste gas and some 4,000 tonnes of untreated solid waste every year, according to official figures. Polluters have said that delays stemmed from the high cost of relocation. Resettlement implies a big cut in profits while production is disrupted. Moreover, large investments are needed to install new facilities and equipment and move existing ones.

Officials countered that the measures were necessary. ”We will not tolerate any more enterprises and factories discharging toxic products, causing environmental damage and affecting the lives of people in the city,” said municipal vice chairman Mai Quoc Binh.

Binh said that from this year, officials could stop production, revoke licenses or punish the heads of 10 businesses listed in the ”black book”, a register of major polluters. These include cigarette makers, foundries, tanneries, and textile and glass plants.

In the central port city of Danang, local authorities have drawn up a list of some 4,000 businesses that should apply complete measures to solve environmental pollution. Some 19 enterprises have been charged for emitting harmful industrial waste and have been ordered to improve their waste treatment systems or move away from residential zones. ”We are very serious about dealing with businesses that are causing contamination,” said Hoang Tuan Anh, Danang People’s Committee vice chairman.

But so far only the Danang Friendship Co, also known as Hunexco, has moved to the Danang Industrial Park. The remaining enterprises, although conceding that implementing environmentally sound production methods will improve the efficiency of their business, are not ready to fork out the large sums necessary to treat the waste generated during production.

”We’re aware of the city’s determination, and we have to move. But we need financial support,” said Nguyen Diem, director of Procimex, a company that processes fish for export and pork for domestic consumption. Procimex generates and discharges around 300 cubic metres of wastewater into rice fields without primary treatment.

In Hanoi, authorities have ordered eight polluting inner-city state enterprises to move to the city’s outskirts.

”Our biggest challenge has been raising capital to construct a new plant,” said Nguyen Thi Hang, vice director of the Ngoc Ha Shoe Co. ”We recently submitted an assistance proposal to city authorities.”

She may have to wait. For how local authorities can mobilise capital resources to support the businesses’ relocation remains a question mark.

Danang officials said they were considering special support policies, including one that would allow enterprises to sell land-use rights to raise money to cover removal costs.

Officials in Ho Chi Minh City announced that they had mapped out specific measures to support relocation such as low rent, preferential loans to renovate technology, and up to around 32,000 dollars in bonuses for companies that relocate early, depending on the size of their workforce.

To help local authorities speed up the anti-pollution process, the government last year announced that beginning January 2004 it would be charging businesses for the amount of pollution they produce. The proceeds would be earmarked for environmental projects and an Environment Fund.

”The more pollution a company produces, the more it will have to pay,” said Truong Manh Tien, a director with the NRE Ministry.

Tien said the amount each company pays would be based on the amount of heavy metals, suspended particles and other pollutants in the wastewater they produce. A kilogramme of lead in their wastewater would cost businesses 19.35-32.25 dollars, for example.

Businesses would submit their pollution data to the local NRE department, which would doublecheck the results. ”This method is expected to be fair to all enterprises,” Tien said.

Some businesses disagreed. Le Vo Thanh Binh, a specialist with the Vietnam General Rubber Co, said the fees should be tailored to specific industries. Rubber producers’ wastewater contains high levels of organic pollutants, he noted. If the levy formula remains unchanged, some might have to close down.

If the penalties were too low, however, smaller businesses would simply pay them rather than make larger investments in waste treatment technology, said Nguyen Mai Phuong, deputy director of the Vietnam Fruit and Vegetable Corp. About 90 percent of Vietnamese businesses are small or medium-sized and often lack wastewater treatment systems.

”The NRE Ministry needs to create a level playing field for small, medium and large businesses,” Phuong said.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags