Saturday, November 21, 2026
Peter Richards
- In 1996, editor Ken Ali spent five days in prison and reporter Sharmain Baboolal was fined after a High Court judge ruled that their newspaper said too much about the ongoing murder trial of a reputed drug trafficker.
Now, six years later, a Court of Appeal has quashed the convictions against the two journalists in a move that media practitioners say represents a “significant victory for press freedom” in Trinidad and Tobago.
By a 2-1 margin the three-member court headed by Chief Justice Michael de la Bastide ruled Thursday that the High Court judge was wrong to find the journalists guilty of contempt of court in the absence of any evidence to support the charges.
“To concede to a judge the power to make an unchangeable order abridging freedom of expression and freedom of the press, and compromising the principle of open justice, is to create an anomaly that would disfigure the common law,” de la Bastide said.
“I have come to the conclusion that a judge at a criminal trial has no power to make an order prohibiting publication, even temporarily, of anything which has transpired in an open court before him except to the extent that the publication which has been forbidden would constitute an interference with the due administration of justice,” he added.
Media representatives applauded the decision.
“The ruling in our opinion vindicates the professionalism, high ethical standard to which the Media association of Trinidad and Tobago (MATT) has always urged media workers in general and its membership in particular to strive for, in the execution of their duty,” MATT President Dale Enoch told reporters immediately after the ruling.
“MATT shares the joys of Ken Ali and Miss Baboolal, who throughout the entire exercise never faltered in the exercise of their rights to function as professional journalists in Trinidad and Tobago,” Enoch added.
During the 1996 trial the judge banned the media from reporting that one of the accused men had earlier pleaded guilty to killing four members of a family and had then been sentenced to life imprisonment.
But in an article the ‘TNT Mirror’ newspaper made vague references to the confessed killer.
Ali and Baboolal were found guilty of contempt of court by the High Court judge, who said he made the “gag” order to counter the effect of prejudicial publicity and to guarantee the accused’s right to a fair trial.
The two journalists appealed the conviction and sentence and along with their newspaper filed a constitutional motion claiming, among other things, denial of justice and breaches of the media’s rights to freedom of thought and expression and freedom of the press.
The now defunct Independent newspaper also filed a separate constitutional motion arguing that the judge’s decision to prohibit reports on the contempt proceedings was a denial of the media’s right to freedom of thought and expression and freedom of the press.
Ali said he was “pleasantly surprised” by Thursday’s ruling but disappointed that the Court of Appeal dismissed the constitutional motions.
The Association of Caribbean Media Workers (ACM) also expressed “its delight” at the rulings, but said it would need to fully study the implications of the verdict.
“On the surface it appears as a tremendous victory for press freedom, but the words of the dissenting judges would have to be looked at again,” the ACM said.
While the chief justice ruled Thursday that the ban violated the media’s constitutional rights to expression and freedom of the press, Judge Margot Warner said in a dissenting opinion that the High Court justice was right to bar the media from reporting on the contempt proceedings.
His duty was “to carry out the balancing exercise in the face of unrelenting publicity which continued both prior to and up to the trial”, she said in her judgement.
“The prohibition would, in my view, not have caused great hardship to the citizenry or to the media because it was not a permanent ban, the trial judge was postponing publication,” she added.
Judge Sat Sharma warned that freedom of the press and expression “cannot be limitless”.
“The much vaunted statement by journalists, that their duty is ‘to report the news’ is not to be regarded as a licence to transgress or trample on other people’s rights,” he said.
The judge noted “the freedom to report public comments faithfully is vital to the proper functioning of any democracy, for it is only when a population is fed and freely receive accurate and fair reporting that sensible, independent and informed decisions can be made.”
“These fundamental freedoms, however, must only be restricted when it is absolutely necessary, and then the restrictions must be proportionate only to the dangers they seek to minimise,” Judge Sharma added.