Headlines, North America

DISARMAMENT-U.S.: Clinton Policy on Landmines Disappoints

WASHINGTON, May 16 1996 (IPS) - President Bill Clinton intended to take a step forward to phase out land mines, but anti-mine campaigners argue that the step he took Thursday was not enough.

Following months of debate at the White House, Clinton announced that the United States “is launching an international effort to ban anti-personnel land mines”, and declared a halt to all U.S. production of “dumb” mines, which remain in operation until they are activated.

But, to the consternation of many in the administration who support a phasing out of all mines, the president made an exception for the border between North and South Korea, ostensibly to protect Seoul from attack by the North. He also exempted any mines the Pentagon may require for training purposes.

“The rest of these mines, more than four million in all, will be removed from our arsenals and be destroyed by 1999,” Clinton promised. He said the United States would also assist in removing the more than 100 million mines active underground currently, which kill or maim an average of some 500 people each week.

He also promised to boost research and development to provide alternatives to land mines and asserted that Washington will take the lead in negotiating an international treaty to ban all mines.

For anti-mine campaigners, the news was too little and too late.

Clinton’s announcement represents “the failure of U.S. leadership,” responded Senator Patrick Leahy of Vermont, who has prodded the White House for months to seek an overall ban on anti- personnel mines. “It simply reaffirms the Pentagon’s old policy: They support a ban, but not now, not anytime soon.”

“There is absolutely nothing new in this announcement,” added Steve Goose, programme director for the Human Rights Watch (HRW) Arms Project.

“President Clinton has missed a golden opportunity to assert leadership on what his administration has acknowledged as one of the most important international humanitarian issues,” Goose argued.

Anti-mine groups, including the leading coalition, the International Campaign to Ban Land Mines, sharply criticised Clinton for failing to change existing U.S. policy for phasing out the “dumb” mines. The activists also took the president to task for taking no stance against “smart” mines — which detonate themselves after a set period — until a worldwide ban on mines is negotiated.

But Clinton Thursday defended his policy as a first step to eliminate land mines entirely, and argued that phasing out dumb mines was vital to saving civilian lives.

“These smart mines are not the hidden killers that have caused so much suffering around the world,” he said. “They destroy themselves within days. And they pose virtually no threat to civilian life once a battle is over.”

By contrast, U.S. officials have stressed, dumb mines last indefinitely, and continue to kill civilians long after a war is over. “Indeed, they probably kill more children than soldiers,” Warren Christopher, the U.S. Secretary of State, argued.

Recent mine atrocities, including reports of U.S. soldiers killed by land mines in Bosnia, have sparked greater interest here to abolish all anti-personnel mines.

Two weeks ago, 15 retired military officers, including Gulf War commander Gen. Norman Schwarzkopf, urged Clinton in an editorial in The New York Times to ban the weapons entirely as a “humane and militarily responsible” measure.

But Pentagon officials at the same time lobbied Clinton not to give up even the dumb mines. As Secretary of Defence William Perry explained Thursday, “This objective to eliminate anti-personnel land mines…is partially in conflict with one of our most critical war plans; namely, the war plan to defend Korea against a mass assault.”

The mines strewn along the border between the two Koreas since their 1950-53 Cold War conflict are still useful, Perry argued, since, “if we simply remove those anti-personnel land mines, it is likely that North Korea could overrun Seoul before we could finally turn the invasion around.”

Anti-mine campaigners view that explanation with scepticism. Henry Emerson, a retired U.S. general who served in Korea, refused to appear with Clinton for the Thursday announcement, mocking the idea that land mines are needed to defend South Korea.

“We believe that U.S. military leaders are concerned not so much about the value of the anti-personnel mine, but rather about setting a precedent,” Goose said. “They do not want to give up a weapon on humanitarian grounds.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags