Armed Conflicts, Economy & Trade, Headlines, Human Rights

COMMODITIES-TRADE: EU and US Still Steaming Over Bananas

GENEVA, Dec 16 1998 (IPS) - A dispute over bananas between the European Union (EU), on one hand, and the United States and four Latin American countries on the other, flared up this week, with Washington rejecting an EU proposal for a new round of talks.

Negotiators from the two groups, meeting at the World Trade Organisation (WTO), disagreed on the procedures that should be applied by the WTO dispute panel to implement a ruling condemning the EU’s banana import regime.

The WTO panel ruled against the EU’s import preferences for Caribbean and African bananas last year, accepting the argument put forth by the United States, Ecuador, Guatemala, Honduras and Mexico that Europe’s banana-import scheme violated global trade rules. The decision was upheld by the WTO’s appeals organ.

U.S. rejection Tuesday of an EU proposal to start a new round of talks at the Geneva-based WTO on whether EU import rules discriminate against bananas grown by Dole Food and Chiquita Brands in Central America has heightened the risk of a trade war between the world’s two top economic powers. It also threatens to erode WTO credibility among developing nations.

The United States has warned that on Feb. 15 it will double the duties it charges on a list of European products – a move that would generate an additional 1.55 billion dollars in revenues – unless the EU implements further changes in its import regime by Jan. 1.

A Latin American negotiator who preferred to remain anonymous said developing countries had been closely following the evolution of the dispute. While the developing world is under pressure to strictly live up to WTO standards, the two leading powers are embroiled in futile battles, he pointed out.

“This is a provocation that hurts the system,” he added. Countries not involved in the banana dispute “believe that (the EU and US) are playing with WTO rules – and that is very touchy.”

The conflict, which revolves around some five billion dollars of annual banana sales to the EU market, has been limited in practice to the two economic superpowers – neither of which produces the tropical fruit.

Washington is protecting the U.S. transnational corporations Chiquita Brands and Dole Food, heirs to the fruit companies that perfected the Central American and Caribbean plantation system and exercised political influence in the region.

Brussels, meanwhile, is looking out for the interests of Africa, Caribbean and Pacific (ACP) nations, whose bananas are less competitive than the Latin American product.

The stakes are significant, not least among the banana exporters affected by the case, especially Caribbean producers, many of which depend on banana exports for their economic survival.

The Caribbean nations, which account for just three percent of global banana exports, have repeatedly appealed to Washington to accept the EU system of preferences.

Negotiations in the WTO have run aground over the interpretation of a provision concerning the measures designed to enforce WTO dispute panel rulings.

The United States and its Latin American allies want the case to be referred once again to the original panel which decided that the EU import scheme ran counter to WTO norms, while the EU wants a new panel to be set up.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags