Economy & Trade, Global, Global Geopolitics, Headlines, Labour

LABOUR: Flexibility Hurts Workers While Boosting Business

GENEVA, Oct 26 1998 (IPS) - Labour flexibility brings heavy consequences for workers in the machinery, electrical and electronics industries, while boosting competitiveness and jobs, according to a new report by the International Labour Organisation (ILO).

The ILO study, ‘Impact of Flexible Labour Market Arrangements in the Machinery, Electrical and Electronic Industries’, analyses the results of the changes in production arising from the incorporation of flexible labour practices.

The report says the change has been hard on workers, entailing increased part-time work, reduced overtime pay, higher job instability and “unsocial hours” (i.e. night work, weekend work and long shifts during peak periods).

Meanwhile, the changes accompanying flexible labour market arrangements, promoted by governments as part of the liberalisation of economies, have benefitted business, and “companies are doing better, productivity is rising and wage costs are falling,” the report adds.

Among those hardest hit by the introduction of flexible labour practices are workers in Germany, Japan and the United States, which account for 15, 25 and 27 percent of global production in machinery, respectively.

The ILO also warns that an increasing number of workers in developing countries are feeling the effects of the phenomenon.

The report began to be debated in Geneva Monday by the ILO meeting in which representatives of governments, companies and unions are discussing the repercussions of flexible labour markets on the machinery, electrical and electronic industries.

The sector focussed on by the report comprises the manufacture of general and specific-purpose machinery; domestic appliances; office or business machines; electrical machinery and apparatuses; television, radio, video and communications equipment; and medical, precision and optical equipment, including watches and clocks.

It does not include the automotive sector, however, where in fact many of the more innovative flexibility arrangements have arisen, the ILO specifies.

The total number of jobs in the sector worldwide has risen 12 percent since 1980, with the creation of 4.5 million new jobs and a 113 percent rise in production.

A large part of the growth in jobs was due to a shift in production toward lower-income countries, which currently account for 32 percent of the sector’s labour force, up from 22 percent in 1980. To illustrate the extent of that shift, the ILO points out that in 1992, China alone provided nearly 30 percent of jobs in the sector, while the United States only accounted for eight percent.

“In the global market, the driving force in industry is to stay competitive, which means searching for greater flexibility and lower labour costs,” the report stresses.

By contrast, “workers’ concerns focus on preserving jobs, dealing with problems of coordinating flexible production systems, and coming to terms with the long-term social implications of flexibility.

“Employment preservation and creation is a main objetive of unions in demanding reductions in working hours in exchange for more flexible arrangements,” it adds.

This week’s ILO meeting will seek “to reconcile the industry’s demand for flexibility and innovation with workers’ requirements for job security and satisfactory working conditions.”

However, it is clear that countries that have adopted more flexible labour practices either at the national level or at the organisational level “have tended to experience overall improvements in the competitiveness of the electrical and non- electrical machinery industries.

“The need to sustain high rates of capacity utilisation in the capital-intensive machinery, electrical and electronic sectors means that the trend toward innovation and flexibility is likely to accelerate in coming years,” the report concludes.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags