Asia-Pacific, Headlines

MEDIA-MALAYSIA: Guessing Game on Editors’ Ouster

KUALA LUMPUR, Jul 30 1998 (IPS) - Media and political circles are in a tizzy over the recent resignations of the editors of two of Malaysia’s best-selling newspapers, after their ‘negative’ reporting had displeased the country’s top leaders.

But the case is not a simple crackdown on the media, in a country where it has long been tightly controlled by the government.

Some say the two editors are casualties in a power struggle between Malaysian Prime Minister Mahathir Mohamad and his deputy, Anwar Ibrahim, with whom they are allied with, and could signal an escalation of that top-level rivalry.

But whatever the real reasons, when the dust settled the editors — Johan Jaafar of ‘Utusan Malaysia’ and Ahmad Nazri Abdullah of ‘Berita Harian’ had been replaced within days of each other this month.

Jaafar, who announced his resignation to a shocked staff on Jul 14, submitted his resignation to Mahathir, the national ‘Star’ daily reported. Jaafar said he wanted “to prevent his presence from impeding the progress of the group’s newspapers and publications”.

Days later, Ahmad Nazri Abdullah was replaced as editor of the ‘Berita Harian’.

‘Utusan Malaysia’ is owned by a group whose stock is largely owned by the dominant United Malays National Organisation (UMNO), whose president is Mahathir. ‘Berita’ belongs to the UMNO-linked group that also owns the English-language daily ‘New Straits Times’.

Meantime, the Sun Media Group, which publishes the ‘Sun’ newspaper, is reported to be in danger of shutting down. This third largest English daily had irked Mahathir because of news it published which put the government in a bad light, says a source who holds a high-ranking position in the government.

Outsiders cannot easily decipher the real reason for Jaafar and Nazri’s replacement, but developments in the preceding weeks provide lots of clues.

For many, the type of criticism the two publications carried were not of the sort and degree to draw such a drastic response.

“Calling these resignations ‘a crackdown on the media’ does appear a trifle overstated, primarily because there wasn’t anything much to crack down on in the first place,” said Zaharom Nain, a lecturer in communications. “Such assertions merely reinforce the myth of an independent Malaysian media.”

“The media has generally not adopted an adversarial stance in its relations with the political leadership,” agreed Dr Mustafa Anuar of the Penang-based Aliran activist group.

But while the two editors were hardly known as champions of press freedom, their publications had recently carried criticism of foul-ups at Kuala Lumpur’s new airport and corruption in the ruling coalition, which displeased Mahathir and his allies.

At the recent UMNO general assembly, Mahathir had to contend with internal criticism, led by Anwar’s allies, about cronyism, nepotism and corruption within the party.

The premier silenced his critics by revealing long lists of those who had benefited from patronage. But he was said to be none too pleased with the adverse media publicity.

At the end of June, Mahathir complained that reports of problems at the new airport were often blown out of proportion, creating an inferiority complex among Malaysians. “(By reading such reports) we believe we are bad, we are guilty and so on,” he said, four days after Johan announced his resignation. “The power of the media must be used wisely.”

But perhaps most alarming for Mahathir was UMNO’s crushing defeat in a Jul 4 by-election in the northern state of Perlis. In rural Arau where 87 percent of voters are Malay, the opposition Islamic party PAS wrested control of a parliamentary seat that had been UMNO’s for 43 years.

The Malay media’s role in shaping public opinion cannot be understated: most rural Malays glean information about current events from state-controlled television and radio stations — and from Utusan and Berita Harian. Thus, ‘negative reporting’ is frowned upon by the top.

The purported Mahathir-Anwar rivalry provides the political backdrop to the resignations, and analysts say the two editors were viewed as furthering Anwar’s ambitions by criticising Mahathir’s projects and policies.

Mahathir has denied that the resignations are linked in any way to political pressure.

But Syed Husin Ali, president of the People’s Party of Malaysia, noted: “Johan has also been observed to be slanted toward Deputy Prime Minister Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim, through his reporting of the intra-party struggle of the UMNO. By removing Johan, Mahathir has also successfully eliminated Anwar’s supporters.”

Political analyst K.S. Balakrishnan says many view Anwar as having closer ties to civil society and encouraging more critical thinking. “This was carried on by his supporters in the media. By eliminating them, Mahathir has shown that he is more powerful. It is also a threat to Anwar,” he added.

By this theory, the two editors had simply backed the wrong horse and their gamble backfired.

Despite denials that Anwar plans to challenge Mahathir for UMNO’s — and consequently the nation’s — top post, speculation persists that he would do so at UMNO elections next year.

Recently, Mahathir made Anwar’s rival, Tun Daim Zainuddin, minister of special functions in charge of reviving the economy. “This is a direct slap on Anwar’s face as he is the Finance Minister,” pointed out Syed Husin.

Things do not look too good for Anwar’s camp which has remained silent. As one politician puts it: “Anwar comes across as someone very weak.” Syed Husin added: “Maybe Mahathir has a hold on Anwar, or Anwar is just waiting for the right time to strike.”

In any case, the pressure seems to be rising on Anwar. A book entitled ’50 Reasons Why Anwar Cannot Be Prime Minister’ has been circulating in the black market.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags