Friday, November 20, 2026
- Government plans to toughen Canada’s immigration and refugee laws have run into increased opposition across the country with demonstrators decrying proposals to end any chance of immigrants being reunited with their familes here.
The protests have dogged Immigration Minister Lucienne Robillard who has stumped the country trying to put across the proposed changes at public meetings.
The new laws affecting Canada’s immigration system, once among the most open in the world, would severely hinder the chances of most potential newcomers, unless they were highly skilled, wealthy, and English or French-speaking.
The government’s proposals followed a recent report by a three- member commission that set out 172 recommendations for sweeping changes to immigration laws and tough new controls on people who claim refugee status in Canada. The report favoured a yearly cap on the number of newcomers and placed greater emphasis on English and French language proficiency among all immigrants, even the big investors that Canada has been courting in Asia.
The new system would emphasize the need for immigrants to come equipped with the skills – language, business experience and education — that would allow for speedy integration into Canadian society. The new laws would also close loopholes in the family sponsorship programme, under which established immigrants agree to support relatives financially for a several years after they come to Canada. The programme has suffered from an estimated 14-per- cent default rate.
Under the new scheme, sponsors would have to prove they’ve met previous obligations and are not on welfare. Governments would be able to garnishee the wages of defaulters.
Now the protest are building up.
“No more language barriers. Canada was built by immigrants” and “Don’t betray Canadian tradition,” read signs carried by demonstrators who picketed a hearing into the proposed changes in Toronto on Thursday.
Most of the protesters were Sikh and Iranian immigrants who said they were worried that Canada would slam the door on refugees and make family reunification impossible.
Ali Gholipour from Iran, who came to Canada in 1980 as a refugee was one of the leaders of the Toronto protest. Labelling the government report “heartless,” he said that “it takes away much of the right to appeal, and puts the power into the hands of civil servants.”
The government report says immigrants who enter Canada without a basic knowledge of either language should pay a “tuition fee” to offset the cost of language training. Teaching English as a second language has become a heavy burden on many big-city school boards and their taxpayers, costing the Toronto region alone 200 million dollars a year.
While in Canada, refugee claimants should be monitored closely through the introduction of a computer tracking system, the report says. Refugees would have to carry coded cards and check them into a computer station at particular intervals. Those who flout the rules, the report said, should be detained until their hearings are complete.
The proposed policy would make investors give the Canadian government a 500,000 dollar interest-free loan for five years and clean up the fraud-riddled entrepreneur program by making applicants prove they have 250,000 dollars to establish a business in Canada.
It also recommends the government introduce a new refugee system that puts more emphasis on ensuring Canada serves the people most in need – most often women and children – rather than the people who manage to make it to this country’s shores.
The use of discretionary power by the immigration minister, who can now grant status on broad humanitarian and compassionate grounds, also would be limited. “One of the flaws in Canadian politics is the difficulty in dealing with subjects like immigration, as if to raise the issue itself were tantamount to questioning its benefits, the place of immigrants, or the value of a certain category of immigrants,” the report says.
Robillard says all of the report’s ideas are being considered. “Everything’s on the table, all of the recommendations,” she says. The report “sets the stage for change” and was first aired at regional public hearings last month which continue in March.
Legislation could be introduced by the end of the year.
The report does allow for revolutionary changes. It would broaden the definition of “family,” making same-sex and common-law spouses eligible for the immigration programme. It also recommends a new, streamlined agency take over from the slow and expensive Immigration and Refugee Board, which is now backlogged with 29,000 cases and can take years to decide. Civil servants, rather than the present system of boards of political appointees, would decide cases within four or five months.
The 168-page report was prepared over the past year by an independent, three-member advisory group under Chairman Robert Trempe, a retired Quebec public servant.
He maintains the new system is “fair to all” and said those scared that “we are going to close doors to people in real need of protection” had misplaced fears. “Those who claimed that Canada should give protection to every economic refugee will be certainly disappointed, as will those who believe that mere structural changes can have magic consequences on a protection system.”
Critics say the proposed system will make it easier for economic immigrants to get into Canada at the expense of humanitarian cases.
“They’re tearing down the refugee system,” said Winnipeg immigration lawyer David Matas. “They’re replacing the refugee board with civil servants who won’t be as independent and won’t bring the same level of experience to the job.”