Friday, November 20, 2026
Claude Robinson
- The legal and political knots which have tied up the outcome of the US presidential elections have tarnished Washington’s democratic credentials in many parts of the world, but there is also a widely held view that the damage will not be long-lasting.
Furthermore, there are still important lessons for emerging democracies in Latin America, Africa and other developing regions from the process by which the United States will finally determine whether Texas Governor, George W. Bush, or Vice-president Al Gore is the next president.
From Havana to Harare, from Montevideo to Moscow, from Beijing to Bangalore editorial writers and cartoonists, political scientists and politicians, constitutional lawyers and scholars have had a good, long laugh at the world’s premier democracy.
Victor Benitez, writing in Diario Noticias, in Asuncion, Paraguay noted that Paraguayans were “maestros when it comes to bungling elections” and so he was happy to see someone else in the same boat.
“It’s always nice to see citizens in countries that are economically superior to ours copying our under-developed practices,” he wrote.
And Mariano Grondona, of La Nacion in Buenos Aires wrote: “The sarcastic response to the sluggish, messy vote-counting does not hurt the people in the United States, because a bath of humility lowers them to the level of the rest of us mortals.”
For many commentators, the protracted dispute demonstrates the fragility of the US electoral system with wide variations between states and local communities, serious weaknesses in recording and counting votes despite technological leadership in the world and an essentially “undemocratic” way to elect a president.
It has also been seen as a natural outcome of a process that disenfranchises many, including African-Americans and other racial minorities and the de-politicisation of nearly half the electorate who simply drop out.
So, the view that the US electoral process was “the common yardstick for measuring democracy can now be put to rest” observed Victor Alarcon Olguin, professor and chairman of the department of political science at Mexico City’s Metropolitan Autonomous University (UAM). “There is a crisis in the credibility of the US system.”
The continuing uncertainty over who polled the most votes in Florida in the Nov. 7 election has led to many offers of electoral help, including vote counting.
“In its programmes of mutual inter-American aid, Uruguay should include a loan to the United States of our mechanisms of vote-counting and control, manual and slow but sure,” the editorial writers at Uruguay’s national daily El Observador, offered.
From Africa, has come the idea of an African democracy corps being dispatched to the United States.
“It is a shameful reflection on our continent that, in their hour of need, we were not there beside our American brothers and sisters to help and advise where we could, in the same way as they do when our elections come around,” commented South Africa’s Mail & Guardian, an English-language newspaper widely circulated in Africa.
Zimbabwe, where President Robert Mugabe came under intense international scrutiny and criticism for the conduct of election recently, joined the global chuckling at “the recount of a recount of a recount” in Florida. Zimbabwe’s Herald newspaper wondered “whether the Americans would have accepted a recount in African elections if the ruling party candidate had been beaten, as happened in Florida”.
Editorialists all over Latin America have noted that the confusion, used to be explainable and expected from a ‘banana republic’ but unheard of in the democratic solidity of the world’s leading power. Furthermore, if the events unfolding in Florida were taking place in a developing country, the United States would be demanding fresh elections.
Part of the global interest in the Florida drama stems from the growing importance that the United States and Western Europe and the multilateral institutions, have placed on governance and transparency, especially since the collapse of the Soviet Union.
Economic and development aid has been increasingly tied to democratic governance and market economies and so many former military and one-party regimes in Africa and Latin America have been making the sometimes painful transition.
Despite the confusion at home and loss of credibility abroad, commentators like UAM’s Alarcon believe that there are real opportunities in the present crisis for both the United States and its critics to improve democracy globally.
For the United States, it is “the right moment to perfect (its) democracy. They have impressive institutional strengths and solid separation of powers. Only the electoral formula is outdated”, he remarked in an interview with IPS.
The “old-fashioned system” of electing a president through the electoral college in which each state has votes in relation to the number of seats it is allocated in the House of Representatives needs to be modernised to bring it in line with current practice in much of Europe and emerging democracies in Latin America and elsewhere.
Alberto J. Olvera, writing in La Jornada of Mexico also criticised the indirect method of presidential election as “a holdover from the arrangements that US regional elites invented to prevent civil wars and to be able to hold together the fragile federal pact that created the nation.
Its shortcomings include “the de facto exclusion of the poor and minorities from the political system, the lack of credible party options, and the holding of the political system hostage by a small elite which, through the growing cost of election campaigns, has closed the doors to new leaders and groups.
One possible alternative, said Alarcon, was to introduce an element of proportional representation in the electoral college. This would retain the present number of electoral votes for each state, but instead of winner take all, each candidate would get a proportion based on their popular vote in the state.
For emerging democracies, the lesson from Florida is that democracies ultimately work where all the contenders have faith in the judicial process as a way of resolving disputes and at the end of the process the “loser will recognise the winner”.
Alex Yurin, a Russian commentator who has been in the United States as one of more than 1,000 foreign observers of the election, remarked in a CNN interview Friday that he was pleased at how the process in Florida was unfolding.
“It is up to the courts. I haven’t seen any general or anyone from the government telling” the Florida officials what to do, he said.
Alarcon also believes that respect for the rule of law was a lesson that could be learned outside the United States. Asserting that the “final result will be accepted by all sides” Alarcon added, “that will be a strong message for democracy”.