Armed Conflicts, Headlines, Human Rights

COMMODITIES-COFFEE: Retention Policy Heralds Downward Price Spiral

Andi Spicer

LONDON, Feb 4 1995 (IPS) - Coffee could be on course for a ‘catastrophic’ price fall if the current retention scheme runs its course, according to the new market report by London-based trader ED&F Man.

It claimed that the scheme has been designed to keep prices at high level, rather than protect it from a glut, and that this could lure growers into a production boom, the stocks from which would have to be dumped on world markets.

On Monday, coffee closed on the LCE at 2,915 dollars a tonne for January, 2,917 dollars a tonne for March. Wednesday it closed at 2,855 dollars a tonne for January, 2,800 dollars a tonne for March. By Friday evening it has dropped to 2,633 dollars a tonne for January, 2,691 dollars a tonne for March.

“The coffee market resembles a bad adventure film, consisting of all action and no clear narrative thread. There is a wide divergence of opinion about where the market is heading and plenty of rumours about retention to keep the pot boiling,” said the report.

Man argued that “there is no clear trend to prices, either up or down The market seems to be balanced in a range of 160-180 cents a lb, with roaster buying supporting the market at the bottom of the range,” it added.

The retention scheme, which has been agreed by Central American producers and Colombia, with partial support from Brazil, is only partially off the ground and has been greeted with scepticism in some quarters.

In some ways it has followed a precedent set by the 1993-94 programme, but the World Coffee Situation report argued that as market conditions are so different it cannot be justified in the same manner.

“The big difference between the present and the last retention is the ambition of the price target which is being pursued by the retaining countries,” said the report.

“The first retention was an emergency response to a desperate situation. Coffee prices were near historical all time lows in the second quarter of 1993, just before it was signed.”

It said the aims were modes, to defend a composite indicator price of 80-85 cents a lb. In contrast, the new scheme is targeting another Mild indicator price of 190 cents a lb.

“The lessons learned from the break-up of the ICO quota system shows that this price level is insupportable in the long term,’ said ED&F Man.

“The price will cause a sharp increase in world coffee production in the absence of future climatic problems in Brazil. This excess production will eventually be dumped in consumer markets causing a catastrophic fall in coffee prices.”

The report suggested that the price was set at such an ambitious level to help out exporters caught holding stock which they bought when the market was above 200 cents a lb. There is an argument that this reflects long term fundamentals, and that it reflects declining consumer inventories.

But the high prices throw up a number of difficulties in implementing retention. The cost of financing retained coffee has increased in proportion to the coffee price, and price increases would offer a big selling opportunity to anyone holding coffee.

“Current market levels allow producers and exporters to make a very healthy profit,” said the report.

“The temptation will be to grab the profit on retained coffee immediately, rather than gamble on a further rise above the retention target.”

Trade and speculators are extremely nervous of a market which has shown itself to be so vulnerable to sudden and violent changes in sentiment, it said.

There is some concern that the extreme volatility which has characterised the market for the last six months will return once the current trading range is broken.

“This is based on the belief that the underlying reason for volatility in the coffee market is unchanged. It still remains extremely hard to work out the “intrinsic value in the price of coffee which is justified by market fundamentals”, argued Man.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags