Europe, Headlines

POLITICS-EUROPE: Case Against Milosevic Vanishing

Fitzroy Nation

THE HAGUE, Feb 27 2004 (IPS) - It began more than two years ago as the most important case of its kind against a former head of state. Now, after 300 days of hearings, the ill health of key participants is casting doubts over the eventual outcome of the trial of former Serbian president Slobodan Milosevic for war crimes.

The frequent illnesses of the main suspect robbed the International War Crimes Tribunal of 65 days of hearings. Last weekend it was announced that the judge presiding over the three-member panel, Richard May, was too ill to continue. He will leave his position on May 31.

The prosecution closed its case of genocide and other crimes against the former Yugoslav leader Wednesday, paving the way for Milosevic – who is representing himself – to begin his defence June 8.

United Nations Secretary-General Kofi Annan is expected in the meantime to look for a replacement for Judge May. The new judge will be expected to use the three months up to June 7 to read thousands of pages of testimonies from 300 witnesses.

Some legal experts predict that Milosevic – who has held all along that the proceedings have no validity – will use the resignation of the lead judge as a basis for considering proceedings so far as a mistrial. That would force the prosecution to reopen its case – and lead to another long and arduous process.

"The prospect of this ever coming to a close with Milosevic being subject to a decision as to his innocence or guilt has just about disappeared," Michael Byers, a professor of international law at Duke University who has followed the case, was quoted as saying here Thursday.

But Avril McDonald, head of international law at the Asser Institute of International Law at The Hague notes that the tribunal itself will have to decide on a mistrial motion. "If they restart this case, it could take another four or five years to complete." She expects the case to continue.

Spokesman for the tribunal James Landale said that while the judge’s unavoidable resignation was "a setback", the three months between now and the time the case resumes will be enough for a new judge to "get up to speed."

Milosevic will present the tribunal a list of witnesses he will call at a preparatory sitting May 17.

Even that schedule may not be kept, given the recent ill health of the war crimes suspect. Milosevic, 61, suffers from high blood pressure. He is also frequently down with the flu.

These health concerns, and the desire to press ahead with the trial, were among factors cited by the prosecution in announcing that it would not go through the final two days of testimony.

Prosecutor Carla Del Ponte accepted that "difficulties are not entirely predictable but are most likely to cause additional delay to the time when the accused can start his case."

The tribunal, officially called the International Criminal Tribunal for the Former Yugoslavia (ICTY), was set up by a resolution of the UN Security Council in 1993 to deal with war crimes committed in the territory of former Yugoslavia since 1991. Some 38 persons accused of war crimes are being detained by the tribunal. An equal number of accused are still at large.

Milosevic faces 66 charges related to atrocities committed in Kosovo in 1999 and in Croatia in 1991 and 1992. One charge of genocide relates to atrocities in Bosnia between 1992 and 1993.

Several legal experts and genocide researchers expressed doubts in interviews published here Thursday whether the prosecution case in relation to the main charge of genocide against Muslims and Croats in the Bosnian Republic was strong enough to gain a conviction.

They said that in order to prove a charge of genocide, the prosecutors must satisfy the tribunal that Milosevic clearly had the "intention" to destroy non- Serbian groups in whole or in part under the definition of genocide in the 1948 UN Genocide Convention.

"People such as Milosevic do not leave a paper trail," says Prof Eric Markusen, researcher in genocide at the Institute for International studies in Denmark, who has been following the trial. "The strongest hope was pinned on finding evidence in police reports and similar documents wherein the clear intention to commit genocide was made. But that has not been found."

Geert-Jan Knijken, professor of criminal law at the university of Utrecht says: "The case regarding genocide is not watertight. That is quite clear to see, after the presentation of 300 witnesses."

Experts say the most compelling evidence came from Rade Markovic, former head of the Serbian security service. He and others have provided details of events in Kosovo, Croatia and Bosnia allegedly linking Milosevic to crimes against humanity. But the prosecution case, however thorough and exhaustive, did not present a "smoking gun" on the main charge.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags