Headlines, North America

CANADA-QUEB: More Questions Than Answers

Stephen Dale

OTTAWA, Nov 5 1995 (IPS) - The tight vote in the referendum over independence for Quebec may have gone against the separatists but Canadian federalists remain uneasy.

While pro-independence forces have been encouraged by the smell of victory, some federalists see the result as a call for changes in Canada’s constitution to give more power to French-speaking Quebec. But there are no easy answers for either side.

Fears that the separatists may have a xenophobic streak has clouded the vote. And problems remain between the separatists and aboriginal people who threaten to derail any move that would give the French-speaking province special constitutional rights.

“I will do what is needed to keep this country together,” promised Prime Minister Jean Chretien after the Oct. 30 defeat of the Parti Quebecois (PQ) in its bid to launch Quebec as a separate nation. The vote was 50.6 to 49.4 percent.

“The time has come to turn the page on holding referendums over and over again, and the time has come to bring the necessary changes to keep this country united,” Chretien said in Toronto.

Gerald Alfred, political scientist at Concordia University in Montreal, says aboriginal rights will again be a major impediment if Canada tries to grant a new constitutional place to Quebec.

Speaking as a Mohawk from Southern Quebec, Alfred said, “Our role is to ensure that any special status for Quebec isn’t granted before they deal with the native issue which has been on the table a lot longer than the grievances from Quebec.”

Canada’s Aboriginal people oppose Quebec separatists, partly because they see Quebecers’ claim to sovereignty over the land as a contradiction of their own claim that Aborigines remain sovereign nations and the rightful owners of much of the territory in question.

During the Quebec referendum campaign, the Crees of northern Quebec voted overwhelmingly – in their own referendum – to refuse to allow their land to be incorporated into a sovereign Quebec. Alfred believes, however, that future clashes are not likely to come from any dispute with the Crees but from the Mohawk communities close to Montreal.

“The Crees are much more conciliatory than we are,” he told IPS. “The Crees have never had a violent relationship with Quebec like we have,” he said, referring to the armed stand-off between the army and Mohawk Warriors at Oka in 1990.

The federal government would face another obstacle in offering Quebec a new deal. Quebec, which accounts for roughly 25 percent of Canada’s population and 22 percent of the gross domestic product (GDP), will soon have no leader.

It is not clear yet who will take over from Premier Jacques Parizeau, who has announced plans to resign before Christmas.

Parizeau may have embarrassed the separatist cause when he suggested just after the vote that ‘old stock’ Quebecers had lost the referendum because of “money and the ethnic vote.” His comments were deplored by federalists and separatists alike. The national Globe and Mail newspaper said Parizeau had “lost his moral authority to speak for all Quebecers”.

The front-runner for the job of Quebec Premier — federal Bloc Quebecois (BQ) leader Lucien Bouchard — has not yet said whether he would accept the new post.

In any event, Quebec separatists are confident that Canada will again fail to produce a convincing offer for a constitutional reform, thereby adding momentum to their cause.

“Nobody will drag us sovereigntists into another 30-year cycle of sterile discussions, diddling, sham and verbal tricks,” said Bouchard, whose separatist BQ party is the official opposition in the federal Parliament.

Many observers agree it will be difficult for Ottawa to come up with a proposal that would lure Quebecers away from separatism. Two previous attempts failed at a time when the political landscape in Canada was less polarised.

Professor Alfred says a successful effort by the federal government is all the more unlikely because Quebec’s government will not take part in the process.

“I don’t know if Canadians will support any initiatives by the Prime Minister if Quebec is not involved,” Alfred said.

Quebec has not been a signatory to the Canadian constitution since 1982. The Quebec government of Rene Levesque refused to endorse a new constitution introduced by then Prime Minister Pierre Trudeau.

The former Conservative government of Brian Mulroney won provincial support in 1987 for a document called the Meech Lake Accord, that attempted to bring Quebec back into the “Canadian family.”

But the deal, which required the unanimous support of provincial legislatures, died when Elijah Harper, an aboriginal politician in Manitoba, held up an eagle feather and withheld his vote, saying the accord did not provide Aboriginals the same kind of cultural recognition extended to Quebec.

A new document that recognises Quebec’s “distinct society”, the Charlottetown Accord, won the support of provincial leaders in 1992, but it was rejected by the Canadian public in a nation-wide referendum.

Meanwhile, Prime Minister’s Chretien’s ability to negotiate with Quebec may also be hampered by his own drastic drop in credibility.

Chretien has been under constant attack in the House of Commons. Reform Party leader Preston Manning has charged that the government fought the referendum campaign with “meaningless cliches that almost put this country over the edge.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags

Headlines, North America

CANADA-QUEB: More Questions Than Answers

Stephen Dale

OTTAWA, Nov 5 1995 (IPS) - The tight vote in the referendum over independence for Quebec may have gone against the separatists but Canadian federalists remain uneasy.
(more…)

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags