Saturday, November 21, 2026
Yojana Sharma
- International satellite broadcasters are eager to prove they are committed to culturally sensitive programming as India threatens new restrictions on “obscene”, violent and culturally insensitive foreign broadcasts.
Bhaskar Pant of Turner International India told a recent conference on Satellite and Cable TV here: “It is no good coming to India with blazing guns saying take it or leave it. It just won’t work, here sensitivities are quite sharp.”
Gary Davey Chief Executive of Hong Kong-based STAR TV described the debate on cultural sensitivity as “Healthy”. “Offence is extremely bad for business,” he said.
“We’ve taken the view all along that if what we are bringing to this nation is wrong or inappropriate then we deserve to be thrown out,” said Davey.
STAR TV came under severe attack because of a talk show it aired earlier this year in which a guest was perceived to have made an insulting remark about Mahatma Gandhi whom Indians revere as the father of the nation. Caught off guard and severely embarrassed STAR withdrew the show.
Bhaskar Ghose, the government’s Information and Broadcasting secretary said the withdrawal of the programme showed that some degree of self control already existed among broadcasters.
“We think it demonstrated that a commercial entity can behave responsibly and do what is required when the public reacts,” Ghose said, but he warned that the government could have banned the programme making it an offence for cable operators to distribute it or advertise on it.
While foreign broadcasters have always had to be wary of cultural sensitivity in the Indian market — the second largest TV market in the world after the US — mediawatchers say that the climate has become even more restrictive as “cultural” invasion has become a political football in the run up to a general elections in India scheduled for early next year.
“We should not let our country be a dumping ground for unwholesome software,” Information and Broadcasting minister P.A. Sangma told the Bombay conference.
In late September the Delhi High Court came down heavily on foreign TV networks for showing obscene programmes and directed the censors to monitor the shows and films shown on these networks, adding fuel to debate.
The High Court judges warned the TV networks that they “cannot be permitted to destroy the culture of the country through vulgar and uncontrolled programmes.”
Analysts say the government cannot afford to be too relaxed about foreign broadcasters while opposition parties, particularly the right-wing Hindu Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP), are using it as a platform to attack the Congress party.
“It is obvious that foreign media will project foreign values,” says Malkani, BJP vice-president.
“They show all kinds of violence in India and the position of the government is that there is nothing objectionable. The government has shown no sensitivity at all.”
“I would say that today the foreign broadcast media is definitely aggressing on our culture,” thundered Ashok Singhal head of the Vishwa Hindu Parishad, a militant Hindu cultural organisation which has strong connections to the BJP.
Nationalistic issues appear to be striking a chord with the public, particularly among the middle class which has become more self-confident as a result of affluence brought about by the present government’s economic liberalisation measures.
The general public, which once welcomed with open arms any programming that broke the unmitigated tedium of the state-run channel Doordarshan, now feels ambivalent about satellite television.
“You have to remember that the whole family, the joint family from grandparent to toddler will sit down to watch a show, so it must not be embarrassing to watch,” says Reena Ashok spokeswoman for a new youth channel Youth Entertainment Service (YES), which she says will “avoid sex and violence.”
A recent study by the Delhi-based Centre for Media Studies found that the majority of viewers found that the impact of television was negative and promotes vulgarity and violence in public life.
While such concerns are no different from those long aired in the West about the impact of television, particularly on
children, media analysts here note the foreign satellite channels which heralded the TV revolution in India 5 years ago with the entry of STAR-TV, are being used as convenient whipping boys.
The foreign broadcasters are taking the onslaught on the chin. Most of them are “localising” their programming as fast as logistically possible. In particular the view of India as an ideal market for making money from programmes already aired in the West is fast disappearing.
“There’s no need for foreign broadcasters to pack up and leave,” notes David Fischer CNN International’s regional manager for South Asia. “But they shouldn’t bring all their baggage with them. They should leave some of their western baggage behind and they should try to achieve the right balance when they are here.”