Europe, Headlines

BRITAIN-RELIGION: Muslim School Boycott Raises Tolerance Debate

Darius Bazargan

LONDON, Jan 24 1996 (IPS) - Some 1,500 Muslim parents in the borough of Kirklees, West Yorkshire, withdrew their children from Religious Education classes this week – a dramatic gesture that could trigger similar mass actions elsewhere.

Worried that “multi-faith” approach of religious teaching would undermine the children’s Islamic beliefs at a formative period in their lives, the parents said Islam should be taught by Muslim teachers.

“Islam is presently being taught by non-Muslims who don’t really understand the religion properly, and may teach things that are contrary to our faith,” said Ahmad Versi, editor of the newspaper ‘Muslim News’.

Versi added that the dispute, which has affected 40 schools in the town of Batley, centred around primary school children. At age 11, they were considered the most susceptible to the influence of other religions, particularly Christianity.

“The parents feel that matters of religion are of a sensitive nature, particularly where children are concerned,” said a statement released by the Muslim Associations of Batley.

“Religious Education is open to much interpretation. As such, if the element of individuality is removed or the subject matter misinterpreted then the whole purpose will be impaired.”

The 1944 and 1988 Education Acts allow parents to withdraw children from Religious and Sex Education classes. A mass boycott of the kind undertaken in Batley was not envisaged under the law.

The Muslim Associations’ statement added that the Muslim parents were “pleased with the response from the Kirklees Metropolitan Council and the local schools on the issue of withdrawal of Muslim children”. The withdrawals should not be seen as a protest directed at neighbourhood schools or the Local Education Authority.

It is precisely to take account of faiths other than Christianity that the Education Act was amended in 1988. The present dispute has highlighted the way in which the system, in seeking to cater for all religions, has ended up pleasing none.

“The 1988 Act requires that teaching in British schools should reflect the fact that the religious traditions of Great Britain are in the main Christian, while taking account of the teachings of other principal religions represented in Britain,” a Department of Education spokesman told IPS.

Religious Education is not centrally organised under the National Curriculum. In some parts of the country Standing Advisory Councils on Religious Education comprising members of all faiths supposedly alter the core curriculum to reflect local circumstances.

However, the Education department insists that Religious Education, even if taught in majority Muslim areas, must remain “broadly or mainly Christian.”

Some observers argue that such localised guarantees do not go far enough. “The RE syllabus has, in theory, to be agreed locally,” said Ibrahim Hewitt, development officer of the Association of Muslim Schools, which promotes 45 non-state funded Islamic schools around Britain.

However, Hewitt notes that the Secretary of State for Education has the veto on all syllabuses, regardless of what is agreed locally. Thus, if legislators said ‘no, sorry, it’s not Christian enough’ the local Religious Education advisory council had to go back and do the syllabus again.

However in mainly Muslim areas, like Kirklees, “having a predominantly Christian syllabus makes no sense at all,” said Hewitt.

Muslims generally made up only one voice on one committee of a given local advisotyr council. These usually comprised four committees. “Even if Muslims are the majority in any particular area, they are still going to be a minority on the committee — so representation is perhaps a very generous use of the word,” he said.

Hewitt’s misgivings were echoed by others.

“Many Muslim parents did not understand the broadly — or totally — Christian character of the RE format. Most were totally ignorant,” said Faisal Bodi, News Editor of the Islamic magazine ‘Q-News.’ “Someone had to take the lead. And that is what has happened in Kirklees.”

The dispute, which has so far been centred around the West Yorkshire town, looks likely to grow.

“I think this action is going to have a ripple effect with the withdrawals spreading,” Versi said. “Even now in neighbouring towns, like Huddersfield and Savilletown meetings have already taken place. We expect further action in the next few weeks with at least another 5,000 children being withdrawn.”

He added that the schools boycott was likely to spread to other regions of the country with significant Muslim populations because of the universal nature of the issue. Some observers predict it will spread to Britain’s three largest Muslim communities – in London, Birmingham and Bradford.

“This problem is affecting all schools now. People have been waiting for someone to start the withdrawals and Batley has given them the lead,” Versi said. “Other Muslim communities will follow suit — and this will take time — but ultimately we predict a national withdrawal.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags