Saturday, November 21, 2026
Maricel Sequeira
- Pope John Paul II will discover a region mired in poverty when he starts his visit to three Central American nations Feb. 5. He also may be unpleasantly surprised to find his Roman Cathlic church besieged by the growth of Protestant sects and believers who don’t practice their faith.
The institutional panorama for this second pontifical visit to Central America is of chaotic and divided church in Guatemala and one that is moving toward conservatism in El Salvador. These two countries, and Nicaragua, were chosen to receive the the Pope because of their rampant poverty, said the Archbishop of San Jose Roman Arrieta.
The Pope is concerned about the social situation in Guatemala and “the poverty and prostration found among the population, among all the indigenous people” who account for 60 percent of Guatemalans, Arrieta declared.
“The Pope will act as a voice for this population and advocate for the conditions of a dignified life,” he said. He added that the pontiff is also concerned about the high level of political violence that persists in Guatemala.
These conditions have not gone unperceived by the Guatemalans themselves. The writer and priest Ricardo Bendana described violence, militarization and family disintegration as among the leading national problems.
“There is still a great deal of rancor and fresh wounds, much inequality before the law, a great many lies and insensitivity to the inhuman conditions under which most Guatemalans live,” he declared.
Analyzing the current status of the church in his country, the priest said that anarchy and fragmentation reigned because of the rapid growth of the population, the proliferation of spontaneously- organized groups and ministries that are not properly supervised and fundamental disagreements.
Moreover, he declared that his countrymen had lost the sense of balance between their love of God and their love for their neighbor and had neglected both.
“On one side, we see a growing religious indifference and amoral materialism, and on the other, the rise of neo- conservatism, which offers security at the cost of restraining personal freedom and shapes people for the 21st century with 19th century ideas,” he asserted.
The Episcopal Conference in El Salvador believes that John Paul II will find a very different country than the one he visited in the throes of civil war in 1983.
But it warned that social problems persist nevertheless, “very serious ones that make daily life in the country very difficult.”
“We cannot be at peace when extreme poverty, insecurity and unemployment cruelly strike at so many brothers and sisters,” the church declared.
“It is not possible to live in peace when death lurks in every turn of the road and city street. It is not possible to experience peace when we are incapable of resolving social conflicts with a common search for realistic and just solutions,” it added.
Reconciliation will be a major theme for John Paul II in El Salvador.
“Peace in El Salvador – where war ended in 1992 – is, like democracy, a tiny plant that is just beginning to grow,” Roman Arrieta declared in an interview with IPS.
Changes are also occurring in the church’s internal life. Last year, the Pope replaced the late Archbishop Arturo Rivera y Damas, who was sympathetic to liberation theology, with the more conservative Fernando Saenz Lacalle, a member of Opus Dei.
In Nicaragua, the pontiff will call attention to the need for the international community to assist the nation, Arrieta said.
“Nicaragua now needs international solidarity more than ever because poverty is very widespread and difficult to surmount without aid following the devastation caused by the civil war that ended in 1988,” he added.
The archbishop noted that 60 percent of the economically active population is unemployed in that country.
The Pope’s Nicaraguan visit also responds to a repeated invitation extended by President Violeta Chamorro and the local church, who wish to make up for the way the pontiff was treated in 1983.
On that occasion, a group interrupted him repeatedly while he was saying mass to demand that he say a prayer for the Sandinista Front for National Liberation combatants who were killed during the insurrection that overthrew dictator Anastasio Somoza in 1979. The Sandinista Front held power at the time of that visit.
On the pastoral front, the Pope will confront two major problems for the Central American church: the proliferation of Protestant sects and growing secularism.
Arrieta believes that the second and relatively new problem is the more serious one. It encompasses a large number of people who say they are Catholic but don’t practice the faith.
Arrieta attributes the region’s growing violence to this religious indifference. “If people only respected the commandments not to steal and not to murder, our societies would be very different.”
The fundamentalist sects have made inroads on the Catholic conregations in Guatemala. Some 20 to 25 percent of the country’s population is now believed to belong to these groups.
The fundamentalists are less influential in the other regional countries, where Costa Rica’s sect membership of 8.5 percent of the population is typical.
Bendana attributes the growth of the fundamentalist to their “forming part of the neo-liberal systems, which needs their religious teachings to justify its policies and increase its influence in a profoundly religious society.”
After Central America, John Paul II will leave Feb. 8 for Venezuela.