Sunday, November 22, 2026
Corinne Barnes
- When a top businessman here called for government to abolish a popular maternity leave law, he probably gave little thought to the dramatic reactions it would elicit.
But women here have shown little constraint in their outrage showering abuse on Anthony Hyde, president of the Jamaica Manufacturers Association, and other advocates of this view.
The debate has divided the sexes here with men overwhelmingly supporting Hyde’s view that legislation be put in place to cut back on the maternity leave “privilege”.
Hyde believes women are taking advantage of the law and that their continued absence from the workplace while they are off giving birth and taking care of their newborn babies is adversely affecting productivity.
Under the laws of this northern Caribbean island women are entitled to three months’ maternity leave for up to three pregnancies while on the same job. But women employed for less than one year in an organisation are not entitled to this leave.
But the law is routinely flouted in many sectors of the society. Women who are unskilled workers are sometimes forced to return to work shortly after giving birth, others are not paid while they are off the job, while still others may be dismissed once it becomes known that they are pregnant.
“Some arrangement must be made to allow women to be mothers and not lose their jobs or their pay when they become pregnant. To do otherwise is a retrograde step with profound social consequences, a retreat to a situation where a woman needs a man as a meal ticket,” says Diana McCaulay, an insurance executive and newspaper columnist.
But for Wilmot Perkins a popular talk show host here, the country cannot afford maternity leave, and the law should be re-examined.
“The fundamental question from the social planner’s perspective is who should pay for the maternity leave benefit? If we as a society believe that women should have the right to maternity benefits, then society as a whole should pay for this benefit,” says Ashu Handa a lecturer in the department of Economics at the University of the West Indies.
Minister of Labour and Social Welfare, Portia Simpson, has however made it clear that she will not support any move seeking to deny women maternity leave benefits.
Hyde feels that the lack of maternity leave would discourage women from having so many children and with such regularity.
“This is complete nonsense,” counters McCaulay. “Women have children for the most complex of reasons, mostly unrelated to financial considerations. We have only to look around to see the truth of this statement. … The desire to have children is visceral, powerful, atavistic. Ask any woman who can’t have children,” says McCaulay.
Still other women argue that the maternity leave with pay policy cannot be seen as a disincentive to production given the fact that women are having fewer children now than 20 years ago, when the law was first enacted.
Women constitute 46 percent of the work force here, but there should be no serious run on the resources of firms to pay maternity benefits because over the last five years the fertility rate has been declining, observers say.
The National Family Planning Board (NFPB) says the total fertility rate, defined as the average number of children a woman is likely to have over her lifetime, has declined from 3.5 in 1983 to three children in 1992.
They also argue that it is the poorer, uneducated and unskilled women in the society who tend to have more than the two children per family as advocated by the NFPB.
These women are invariably employed in temporary, casual jobs where they are not entitled to maternity leave with pay.
“If we want women to have fewer children we must do two things: educate and employ women. Where is the society with high literacy and employment levels for women and a high birth rate? In country after country, when women are educated and employed birth rates fall — indeed to the point where some developed countries are concerned about their negative birth rates and aging populations,” says McCaulay.
The unemployment levels among women here have been consistently higher than that among men. In 1994 some 60.4 percent of women over 25 years were unemployed while the figure for men of the same age group stood at 24.7 percent.
“I ask those who are putting forward this extraordinary simplistic view in a country where so many men walk away from their parental and family responsibilities, who will look after those women (and their children) if employment is denied them as their babies slide into the world,” says McCaulay.
Studies have shown that more than 44 percent of families here are female-headed.
Along with maternity benefits employers are required to pay other non-wage costs associated with hiring workers which together make up roughly ten percent of the wage bill.
“It is true our economy has serious problems of productivity, efficiency and competitiveness, but discontinuing maternity leave is not the solution,” says McCaulay.
Corinne Barnes
- When a top businessman here called for government to abolish a popular maternity leave law, he probably gave little thought to the dramatic reactions it would elicit.
(more…)