Asia-Pacific, Development & Aid, Headlines, Population

PAKISTAN-WOMEN: Growing Resistance to “honour killings”

Beena Sarwar

LAHORE, Jan 24 1996 (IPS) - Tribal and feudal customs still discriminate against women in Pakistan, along with more recent laws. But resistance is steadily increasing, thanks to the awareness created by women’s rights groups and the media.

Two teenaged schoolgirls were killed last year by their uncles for having stayed over at a friend’s house in Larkana, where they had gone to participate in the Sindh Games. Their crime: suspicion of tarnishing the family honour.

But the murders, for once, were not condoned. There was a massive one-day strike in the Sindh town of Ratodero — an indication of the growing sense of outrage against this brutal practice that is carried out in the name of honour.

Pakistan’s state-run electronic media has contributed immensely to raising awareness. ‘Hawwa ke Naam (In the name of Eve)’, a talk show hosted by journalist Jugnu Mohsin, is the latest television programme to highlight women’s problems and discuss issues like rape, honour killings and forced marriages.

Widely-watched soaps on TV have also dealt with such themes, including the issue of “marrying” a woman to the Quran — condemning her to a lifetime of celibacy — or to a young boy just to keep property in the family. These practices have been condemned by the Council of Islamic Ideology, a constitutional body that advises Parliament on laws and practices regarding their repugnance or otherwise to Islam.

Although Islam takes a strict view of sex outside marriage, it also prohibits an individual from taking the law into his own hands. “Even if a man actually sees his wife in a ‘compromising’ position with another man, that is no justification for murdering her,” says Dr Khalid Mahmood Soomro, chief of the Sindh chapter of the religious party Jamiat Ulema-e-Islam (F).

But many of Pakistan’s tribal customs are older than the state religion Islam, and are often considered to be as valid as religious laws.

The practice of “honour killings”, believe sociologists, originated in ancient Babylon, and spread from the Middle East to the area that is now Pakistan. Here, it was first prevalent among the Baloch tribes in Pakistan’s western province bordering Iran. Further east, in Sindh or Punjab, ostracism rather than murder was the answer for women who strayed. But the practice of “honour killings” spread, and many Sindhi tribes now also practice this form of murder.

In the tradition-bound rural areas, where a man’s honour is considered to lie with the purity of his women, “honour killings” are tacitly condoned. The police and the legal system often give benefit of the doubt to the murderer in such cases.

In urban areas too, murder “on suspicion of illicit relations” is not uncommon, and is often used to cover a multitude of crimes ranging from property disputes to cold-blooded revenge.

In Pakistan, murders committed under “grave and sudden provocation” can be admitted as a plea for a mitigated sentence of two years or so, although they are actually premeditated.

“Media focus, combined with the work of women’s groups, has at least brought issues out into the open that were previously never discussed,” says Sohail Warraich, a journalist working with a women’s group, Shirkat Gah.

Shirkat Gah has been working with community-based organisations to identify traditions and laws which discriminate against women. One of the organisations has been performing a street play on so-called honour killings, called ‘Karo-Kari’ — karo being a man and kari a woman who are accused of having illicit relations.

“Ma, they will label me ‘kari’ and kill me”, the chorus intones as the play ends. The line is from a famous poem by an immensely popular Sindhi poet, Sheikh Ayaz.

Many of the several avidly-watched dramas on Pakistan Television on the problems faced by women in traditional Sindhi families have been scripted by another Sindhi writer, Nurul Huda Shah, who is herself from a feudal Sindhi family.

“Ironically,” says Shah, “honour killings have increased in urban areas as well. It’s just that they don’t call it ‘karo- kari’.” Karo-kari is the name for honour killings in conservative Pakistan. The solution, she believes, is “mass awareness and sensitisation … It is everyone’s responsibility to take up these issues.”

Awareness is growing, even among the male-dominated Pakistani judiciary. Senior Larkana-based criminal lawyer Noorullah Unar says that in the last few years, courts in Sindh have begun to convict “karo-kari” killers to life rather than the mitigated

two-year sentence that was common earlier.

“They are recognising that nothing, not even religion or custom gives a person the right to kill another human being,” he says. But he adds that rulings in other areas are still generally tilted in favour of persons convicted of murder under “grave and sudden provocation” in the name of “ghairat” (honour).

Sobho Gianchandani, 80, a long-time political activist and lawyer in Larkana, Sindh, is dismissive of the notion of “ghairat”, calling it “the second name of ignorance”.

It is this ignorance that so many individuals and groups are now combating, with whatever means they have. The results may not be visible immediately, but in the long run are bound to have an impact, say optimistic women’s groups.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags