Africa, Headlines

ZIMBABWE-MEDIA: Write What I Say

Patience Rusere

HARARE, Jan 28 1996 (IPS) - If one test of true democracy is freedom for the media to express diverse opinion without fear or favour, then Zimbabwe has failed the exam.

Fifteen years after independence, the media in Zimbabwe still largesly is a mouthpiece of the state, and only two independent weekly papers, plus a few monthly magazines, do not devoutly toe the government line.

“This is a pathetic situation which has stifled those who have independent views from the government, because the official press cannot bite the hand that feeds it,” says Herbert Munangatire, former owner of the ‘Sunday Times’, which folded last year.

Currently there are only two national dailies, both owned by the government through its Zimpapers group, and the two independent weeklies, the ‘Sunday Gazette’ and ‘Financial Gazette’ owned by Modus Publications.

“The major reason why there has been no interest in running a newspaper is that no one is prepared to invest in the media. Running a paper requires a lot of money and has no immediate profit,” says media consultant Tonic Sakaike, a former journalist.

According to calculations by analysts, it costs roughly one million dollars to start a newspaper in Zimbabwer. With the economy dominated by state-owned enterprises and conservative white business, advertising to sustain the paper becomes a political issue.

“Another reason that has contributed to the absence of an independent press is that the media can be politically sensitive, and people do not want to risk offending the government,” says Sakaike.

“Geoff Nyarota and I once wanted to start a paper. At first we had donors who wanted to fund us. But at the last minute they pulled out, and I think Geoff’s background scared them.”

Nyarota, once the editor of the “Bulawayo Chronicle’, exposed a car dealing scandal in the late 1980s involving top government officials which shook the country. A number of ministers were forced to resign and one later committed suicide.

Nyarota was promoted to chief public relations officer for the Zimpapers group and sent to Harare in a move widely interpreted as being “kicked upstairs.”

Modus publications attempted to take on the leading official paper, ‘The Herald’, launching ‘The Daily Gazette’ in 1992.

Apart from a few celebrated exposes, including a land-grab scandal where farms acquired for thousands of landless Zimbabweans were allocated to top government officials – a story not covered by the official press – the paper began to pull its punches, lost circulation, and collapsed after two years.

“The paper had been infiltrated by the (Central Intelligence Organisation) CIO whom we had actually employed as reporters,” claims Nevhanji Madhanire, Modus Publications spokesman. “In a bid to make us lose credibility with our readers members of the CIO would approach our reporters with legitimate looking documents for a ‘scoop’ only to find ourselves being sued for publishing false information.”

The ‘Daily Gazette’ was labelled “sensationalist” and its sister paper, ‘The Financial Gazette,’ was attacked by President Robert Mugabe himself as “pink lies” (the ‘Financial Gazette’ is printed on pink paper).

“Since the Gazette folded, we have had to read ‘The Herald’, where one reads only about what the President said, to a group of party faithful, his arrival or departure from the country as a front page story,” complains Todd Hogwe, a law student.

Diana Mitchell, a former ‘Financial Gazette’ columnist shrugs: “Its a pity that the government regarded the ‘Daily Gazette’ as an opposition paper. But the competition was good, because ‘The Herald’ had actually improved during the ‘Daily Gazette’ days.

“They even tried writing articles on members of opposition political parties for a change,” she adds.

Oliver Gawe, a senior official in the Zimbabwe Union of Journalist and news editor at the Herald refuses to comment beyond: “All I can say that it is unfortunate that no one is willing to invest in the media.”

Although there is no law that prohibits independent newspapers, the Broadcasting Act – a colonial legacy through which the former white minority government churned out propaganda – does not allow anyone to operate radio or TV stations other than the government- controlled Zimbabwe Broadcasting Corporation (ZBC).

“This has resulted in people, through radio and TV, seeing and hearing what the powers that be want them to,” says Sakaike.

Although Minister of Information, David Karimanzira, reportedly is considering an amendment to the Act, conern remains on the government’s sincerity in freeing the airwaves to non-party approved broadcasters.

In the meantime, its business as usual. Last week the ‘Financial Gazette’ reported the blacklisting at ZBC of three perceived government opponents, with a circular ordering all reporters to submit stories on them for vetting.

Among those blacklisted was Margaret Dongo, an expelled member of the ruling party who stood as an independent in a 1995 Harare by- election. She won a court case after alleging the vote was rigged and, in the election re-run in November, trounced her Zimbabwe African National Union – Patriotic Front opponent.

This week the ‘Financial Gazette’ revealed that Karimanzira had ordered ZBC to stop using Cable News Network after CNN had reported on something “highly unfavourable about Zimbabwe’s politics.” No other newspaper carried the story.

“This has created a nation of rumour mongering,” says Munangatire, “because they don’t know, or are not supposed to know, they have turned to speculation.”

“The situation is so bad that we are not even sure of the President’s marital status,” adds Munangatire. It is a reference to Mugabe’s reluctance to comment about his rumoured marriage to his former secretary.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags