Sunday, November 22, 2026
Peter Zirnite
- The Bill Clinton Administration remains steadfast in its commitment to establishing a hemisphere-wide, free-trade zone by 2005, even though officials now concede that the wind that once filled the plan’s sails has been replaced by an air of pessimism.
A parade of top White House advisors emphasised unwavering support for the Free Trade Area of the Americas to some 300 high- level, public and private sector leaders at a forum this week, titled, ‘The Outlook for Free Trade in the Americas’, sponsored by the U.S. State Department and the Organisation of American States.
Potential partners from the hemisphere endorsed the FTAA, but they warned that the process of economic integration will not regain its momentum until the Clinton Administration shows it has sufficient congressional support to implement needed legislation.
Brazilian trade officials said that even if the FTAA does get back on track, 2005 will remain an unrealistic target date for implementation.
“It is too tight,” said Jose Botafogo, Brazil’s Under- Secretary-General for Economic Integration and Foreign Trade.
Brazilian officials argued that more time should be allowed to develop existing sub-regional trade agreements, such as Mercosur and the Andean Pact, because their success would make approval of the FTAA more politically viable.
Deputy U.S. Trade Representative Charlene Barshefsky told Wednesday’s opening session that the Clinton Administration will not back down from its “commitment to make the FTAA a reality.” But she acknowledged that prospects for implementing a region- wide, free-trade zone have dimmed since the idea was first proposed at the 1994 Summit of the Americas in Miami.
“There is an air of pessimism,” Barshefsky said. But, she dismissed as “completely unwarranted” growing domestic concern about moving ahead with the FTAA. This concern has been fueled, in part, Mexico’s financial crisis and lingering questions about the benefits from NAFTA.
Thomas McLarty III, counselor to President Clinton, said FTAA proponents were losing ground because they had failed to explain to the public the benefits of free trade. He urged the private sector to take a more active role in explaining “how trade creates more jobs than it destroys and how it enriches the lives of our citizens.’
“It is clearly essential that we work together to overcome our common problems,” McLarty said.
The strongest indication that the administration is losing political momentum for expanded free trade was the refusal of Congress last year to provide “fast-track” authority in negotiations for Chile’s ascension into NAFTA. Such authority, which the White House received for the original NAFTA negotiations, would require Congress to take a simple yes-no vote on the final agreement, without allowing action on specific measures.
Argentine Ambassador Raul Granillo Ocampo said the Clinton Administration’s failure to secure fast-track authority for negotiation with Chile has made regional leaders reluctant to move ahead with FTAA.
“Americans need to give a message to the region,” that shows that this failure “is just a political difficulty, and it is not that America has changed it mind,” he said.
Granillo made it clear that the only way this “message” can be delivered is through quick passage of fast-track legislation.
Barshevsky placed most of the blame for Congress’ failure to approve the measure on election-year politics.
“If (approval) doesn’t happen this year, President Clinton will pursue it vigorously in 1997,” she said.
Although acknowledging the likelihood that the fight for free trade “will get harder,” Barshevsky said she is “still confident that at the end of the day, the core of Democrats and the core of Republicans believe that these agreements are in the interest of the United States.”
Barshevsky’s optimism was not shared by Gary Klein, a top aide to the chairman of the Senate Subcommittee on International Trade.
“It is going to take a political sea change to get fast track passed, or any other free trade bill,” he said.
Klein illustrated his contention by pointing to the strong showing made by Republican presidential hopeful Patrick Buchanan in Tuesday’s Iowa primary election. He noted that the staunch trade protectionist’s message “resonated” with voters, even though Iowa’s economy “depends on exports.”
Public wariness about expanding free trade is growing, according to Klein, because during the NAFTA debate, proponents made too many promises about its benefits that could never be fulfilled.
Even if the Clinton Administration were able to regain political momentum, Brazilian officials said the 2005 target date for implementing the FTAA will remain elusive.
The Brazilian official said countries should be “gradually constructing the FTAA” by first implementing regional trade pacts, such as Mercosur, the 1994 agreement that liberalises trade in goods and services among Argentina, Brazil, Paraguay and Uruguay.
“If we rely on regional building blocks,” Botafogo argued, “we are going to have more political success.”
He also maintained that the region currently lacks the physical infrastructure necessary to make the FTAA a success.
“We will need a tremendous effort to physically integrate Latin America,” Botafogo said.