Asia-Pacific, Development & Aid, Headlines, Human Rights, Population

AUSTRALIA: Planned Reform of Aboriginal Body Provokes Protests

Kalinga Seneviratne

SYDNEY, Apr 26 1996 (IPS) - Australia’s Aborigines are up in arms over what they perceive as attempts by the new Conservative government to trample on their rights by arbitrarily “reforming” a state body that looks after the interests of the aboriginal community.

The Liberal-National party coalition, which took over the reins of power from the Labour Party at last month’s elections, says there is a need for greater transparency in the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Commission (ATSIC), alleging corruption within the body.

For a start, the Canberra government plans to appoint a special auditor to screen all grants made by the body and if there is evidence to show corruption or mismanagement, Aboriginal Affairs Minister, Senator John Herron, has signalled that the next step would be to establish a watchdog administrator.

Since a historic high court decision granted native title to Australia’s Aboriginal people in 1992, ATSIC has played a leading role in helping the former Labour Party government to draft and pass Native Title legislation in 1993.

Established in 1990 in response to repeated calls for self- determination by Australia’s aboriginal community, the body has also dispensed millions of dollars of government funds to indigenous organisations around the country.

Its commissioners are all indigenous Australians who are elected through a national poll by Aborigines and Torres Strait Islanders who are of Polynesian descent that first settled off the northern tip of Australia.

Against this background, the aboriginal community says Prime Minister John Howard’s government had no right to announce reforms to the body without consulting either the commissioners or indigenous leaders.

“It seems the government has said ‘to hell with them’ and spun the clock back 30 years,” said Dr Roberta Sykes, the executive director of the Black Women’s Action in Education Foundation and a recipient of the Australian Human Rights Medal.

“The government’s heavy-handed approach threatens to turn government policy full circle and return to the days of mission management and assimilation,” she added.

By spinning the clock back 30 years, Sykes was referring to a 1967 plebiscite in which a majority of the electorate voted in favour of granting Australian aborigines their rights as citizens of Australia following centuries of repression started under 18th century British colonial rule.

According to Sykes, tension is running high among the aboriginal community which numbers about 250,000. “Many feel their hard- gained rewards over the past decade have been overlooked and that a Howard government always intended to limit resources and restrict Aboriginal autonomy.”

The large swings recorded in the March general elections by conservative candidates — some of whom campaigned on a strong right-wing agenda — was interpreted by analysts here as a reflection of deep rooted racism in the Australian society.

President of the New South Wales Anti-Discrimination Board Chris Puplick said this week that he had noticed a “sharp” and “disturbing” rise in complaints by Aboriginal people about racist treatment since the federal elections.

He said that the furore caused by the allegations of corruption within ATSIC had been used by sections of the community as an excuse to “abuse, taunt and vilify” indigenous people.

“A portion of the community now find that they can crawl out from under their rocks because suddenly they think its more acceptable to do so,” said Puplick.

In the prevailing atmosphere, mining companies and pastoralists — with the support of state governments — are also now mounting legal challenges to the Native Title Act which recognised traditional land rights of indigenous aborigines.

The newly installed Queensland state government has appealed to the High Court to resolve the issue of whether pastoral leases take precedence over native title.

These legal challenges come at a time when Aboriginal Land Councils — very often with financial backing from ATSIC — are in the process of negotiating royalty agreements with mining companies.

These councils are also starting to develop tourism ventures on their traditional lands as a means of becoming self-supportive.

“The High Court decision has changed the notion that Aboriginal people were simply dependent on welfare. It proved that we were owners of land and had an economic base. It overturned the fiction which justified past policies of control,” said Dodson.

Prof Marcia Langton, chair of the Australian Institute of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Studies, takes the point further saying that only through creating their own economic development will aboriginal people break the vicious cycle of despair, welfare dependency and neo-colonial relationships.

“Income from the Aboriginal arts and crafts industry and joint- ventures and agreements with mining and tourism corporations is slowly replacing social security,” says Langton.

Prof Colin Tatz, director of the Centre for Comparative Genocide Studies at Macquarie University warns the government that it would be making a big mistake if it decided to appoint a ‘Big White Auditor’ to look over the shoulders of the indigenous ATSIC commissioners.

In a newspaper column under the title “Where are the wise, white voices?”, Tatz says that the Aboriginal community will register their protests in the most visible way during the 2000 Sydney Olympics which the “world’s cameras will be only too eager to film”.

The howls of protest from the Aboriginal community, writes Tatz, reflects comparisons drawn by the spectre of a “Big White Auditor” to the “welfare officers” who less than 30 years ago controlled what indigenous Australians could earn, how much they could withdraw from their savings accounts, and for what purpose.

Leading Sydney magistrate and Aboriginal Lawyer, Pat O’Shane, has also come out against the manner in which the government is going about its proposed reforms at ATSIC. “They certainly wouldn’t go into the Business Council of Australia with that approach and they have not done it with the unions.”

Stung by the intensity of the criticism that followed the announced reforms, Sen Herron met the ATSIC commissioners this week. The government however has no intention of backing down on an already announced decision.

“Fundamental questions about the appropriate degree of indigenous autonomy within the Australian Commonwealth are at issue,” notes Noel Pearson, the executive director of the Cape York (Aboriginal) Land Council. “Right now, the pendulum appears to be swinging towards less (autonomy).”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags