Saturday, November 21, 2026
Gustavo González
- Opponents of government regulations and industry-imposed guidelines have begun a legal battle against censorship of televiision services in Chile.
Four congressional deputies from the governing center-left coalition have joined a right-wing member of the opposition in a bid to limit the broad cenship powers of the National Television Council (CNTV).
On April 16, the Chamber of Deputies voted 34 to 25 to request that President Eduardo Frei send Congress a proposal to modify the law that established the CNTV toward the end of Gen. Augusto Pinochet’s dictatorship (1973-90). The deputies hope to eliminate, or at least sharply limit, the council’s power to order cuts in television films transmitted after 10 pm, the so-called “adult hour.”
Congressional representatives also insist that although some carefully delimited regulations may be appropriate for open-signal VHF or UHF broadcasts, there should be no censorship of cable television.
In 1995, CNTV ruled that local distributors of cable TV programming were required to block or transmit alternatives to films or other programming deemed pornographic or extremely violent.
The deputies seeking legal reform agree with television industry representatives and viewers who argue that cable TV is a “private and voluntary” service whose content should not be regulated or interfered with by any authority.
At present, self-censorship to avoid risking the CNTV’s sanctions can be widely observed in Chilean television. The regulating agency has the power to warn and fine channels it finds violating the law and may also shut them down temporarily or revoke their transmitting licenses for serious and repeated violations.
The current law gives the council members broad discretion for determining when a program violates acceptable standards because of excess violence, horror, or pornography.
The CNTV’s 12 members represent government and private interests and include well-known politicians and conservative academics. Some observers fault them for narrow-mindedness.
The council has sanctioned several channels for TV news reports showing women with bared breasts and has warned or fined sex- education programs like the animator Geraldo’s “reality show.”
Last year, fear of sanctions prompted the government station to cancel a broadcast of a Chilean short film that included a scene with a boy observing a sexual situation even after the station had bought the broadcasting rights from the film director, Cristián Galaz.
And the Catholic University television station has cited the law to justify removing any direct, indirect or even humorous reference to condoms from the movies it transmits.
Party for Democracy deputy and CNTV legislative reform leader Víctor Barrueto warns that Chilean television faces a “dearth of freedom of expression.”
Barrueto noted that the Council of Film Censorship already approves the films televised during the adult hour as suitable for viewers over the age of 18 but they are often cut anyway.
The deputy called this “an insult to citizens’ intelligence and ability to discriminate and at the same time an injury to the integrity of the cinematic work.”
The proposed new legislation would precisely define the depictions of scenes and behaviors judged inappropriate for television transmission rather than allow the CNTV to make these decisions under its current broad criteria.
CNTV president Pilar Armanet, a Frei appointee, says she personally agrees with the proposed rules but adds that the definition of objectionable behaviors should not solely allude to such standard aspects as violence or pornography.
Armanet believes that a combination of breadth in criteria and specificity in defining behaviors should ease self-censorship and free the CNTV of complaints that it acts arbitrarily.
The censorship debate has also brought the issue of family responsibility to the foreground. Socialist deputy José Antonio Viera-Gallo and others justify the CNTV’s censorship of adult hour programming by noting that many parents allow their children to watch these programs.
While Viera-Gallo supports censoring even cable television on this ground, journalist Fernando Paulsen reaches the opposite conclusion even as he acknowledges parents’ irresponsibility.
“Families are lax because there is a regulating agency. That’s why it would be good to take away the CNTV’s role as programming ‘sheriff’,” said Paulsen, who heads the Network, a private broadcasting company.