Africa, Headlines

ZIMBABWE-MEDIA: New Independent Weekly Hits the Streets

Pedzisai Ruhanya

HARARE, May 10 1996 (IPS) - A new weekly hit the streets here Friday, its owners apparently undaunted by the many difficulties that have plagued the independent media here.

The ‘Zimbabwe Independent’ aims to expose corruption and bad governance whenever they manifest themselves, assistant editor Iden Wetherell said Friday. He said the Zimbabwean public had been hungry for the paper, whose publication was announced some weeks ago, and promised that it would not go under.

Independent papers have not found it easy to survive in Zimbabwe. Financial constraints led to the liquidation of ‘The Daily Gazette’ in 1994 and ‘The Sunday Gazette’ and the ‘Sunday Times’ in 1995.

Wetherell says the new weekly will not share their fate. “We have a strong advertising community to guarantee our survival,” he told IPS, adding that the paper is run by experienced business people with excellent management.

The advent of the ‘Zimbabwe Independent’ brings to three the number of independent weeklies here, the others being the ‘Financial Gazette’, which is likely to be its main competitor, and ‘The Weekly Sun’, a less popular paper.

The editor of the new weekly, Trevor Ncube, held the same function in the ‘Financial Gazette’ until asked to resign following a report that angered government officials. However, he recently told ‘The Sunday Mail’, an official weekly, that the paper would be independent of any political, social or business grouping, and that this would ensure its objectivity.

The ‘Zimbabwe Independent’ targets the business community and other high- and middle-income Zimbabweans. According to its maiden editorial, it will avoid thoughtless criticism of the government and even offer an occasional pat on the back for successes, but will hold Zimbabwe’s rulers to account.

“Far too much has been lost, stolen or squandered in recent years and we are, as a society, immeasurably poor as a result,” ran the editorial.

Only time will tell whether the paper will have a longer life that ‘The Daily Gazette’ and ‘The Sunday Gazette’, which lasted less than three years.

Critics argue that the difficulties faced by the independent press are due not just to financial woes but also to the government’s intolerance of alternative views, which has translated into costly lawsuits, usually for defamation.

“The independent press can not thrive because the political system in the country is towards a one-party state,” Dr. John Makumbe, a political scientist at the University of Zimbabwe, told IPS. “It is also shunned by the private sector which tries to please the government in order to get tenders.”

He feels the new weekly will fall unless it has a strong economic base.

But Wetherell insists that his paper stands a good chance of survival since it will appeal to a discerning readership given the void left by the state media’s inability to criticise the government’s failings.

“The climate is ideal because Zimbabweans, including our leaders, now do not want to see doctored news by editors who are scared of politicians,” he pointed out, adding: “We are not going to be frightened by politicians or anybody else. We will carry news fearlessly.”

For Tafataona Mahoso a social scientist and lecturer at Harare Polytechnic’s Division of Mass Communication, one of the factors that have hampered independent papers in Zimbabwe is the quality of their editorials.

“It’s too narrow and kindergarten to concentrate on attacking political parties and other journalists,” argued Mahoso, in a reference to the ‘Financial Gazette’, whose ‘Muckracker’ column often derided the state press and questioned its professionalism.

Ncube told ‘The Sunday Mail’ that his new paper would not be muckracking since “we have realized that we are part of the larger community of journalists” and that it did not pay to fight other journalists.

However, the ‘Muckraker’ column, which disappeared from the ‘Financial Gazette’ after Ncube left the paper, featured prominently in the first issue of the ‘Zimbabwe Independent’, celebrating its reappearance with a promise to take Zimbabwe’s politicians to task.

“Muckraker’s back folks, just when politicians thought it was safe to open their newspapers, their nemesis is back,” wrote the columnist. “Details of their mistakes and misdeeds which they have been concealing from us can now be found weekly in this column.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags