Global, Global Geopolitics, Headlines

RELIGION-GERMANY: Women Priests’ Ordination A Challenge to Pope

Ramesh Jaura

BONN, Jun 2 1996 (IPS) - When Pope John Paul II visits Germany in about three weeks, he will land in the middle of a vigorous public discussion about the role of women in the Catholic church.

Not for the first time, a German arm of the Old Catholic Church — a dissident Catholic body — last Monday ordained two married women as priests. The two (33-year old Angela Berlis and 48-year old Regina Pickel-Bossau) are the first women to be openly ordained as Catholic priests in Western Europe.

(Some women in Eastern Europe were reportedly ordained in clandestine ceremonies during the communist era which ended six years ago.)

Monday’s public ceremony in southern Germany, in the Church of Christ close to the Lake Constance on the border with Switzerland, was preceded by protracted activity of the Old Catholic Church which has some 30,000 members in Germany and about 230,000 worldwide.

A synod in Germany determined in 1994 that the church should give equal rights to women and men and therefore appoint them equally to service in the diocese at all levels.

The decision was taken after Anglicans in Great Britain ordained women as priests — triggering debate on the role fo women in the church particularly to Germany and Austria.

Believers from the two countries gathered hundreds of thousands of signatures to reinforce demands that the Vatican liberalise its stringent doctrines which prohibited the ordination of women and insisted on celibacy of priests.

“God is neither a man nor a woman, so his representatives do not all have be male,” argued Pickel-Bissau in an interview with the Catholic News Service (CNS) this week.

The freshly ordained priestess works as a teacher with the physically disabled at a school in Andernach, some 40 kilomerers from Bonn. She converted from Catholicism in 1991.

“I left the Roman Catholic church for theological reasons, and because I saw that my efforts at reform could go no further there,” she said. “Maybe steps like the one the Old Catholic church has taken will urge a gradual change elsewhere.”

Berlis — supervisor of Old Catholic studies at the University of Bonn — said she had received only positive feedback after being picked for priesthood, though she admitted that there could also be some resistance as well.

“Appointing women to high positions will enrich the spiritual offerings of the church,” she said. “One of the most important qualities for a priest is personal charisma, and there are many women who are perfect for the job.”

Berlis splits her time between Bonn and the Dutch community of EJumueden, where her husband is an Old Catholic priest.

“When I first came to this community in Holland as a vicar in 1988, people were sceptical,” she recalled. “But after a few weeks that disappeared. I am sure that if there are people who are now sceptical about female priests, it will only be a matter of time before they get over it.”

Their ordination by Bishop Joachim Vobbe last Monday obtained wide media coverage. It was attended by hundreds of congregants, including representatives of the Anglican Archbishop of Canterbury and the Evangelical Church of Germany, which has long admitted women to the highest echelons of its clergy.

They were nominated after polls by Bishop Vobbe throughout 1995, at churches across the country, to determine which women might merit the appointment.

The ordination of Berlis and Pickel-Bossau in Constance had a symbolic value of its own. This medieval town has a special significance for Old Catholics. The Council of Constance authored in the early 15th century the view that the highest authority in the Roman Catholic Church lay with its council, not with the Pope.

The group which came to be known as Old Catholics split with Rome over several issues, including the infallibility of the Pope as declared by the first Vatical Council in 1869/1870.

When Pope Pius IX excommunicated the German dissident priests, they found sympathy for their views among Catholics in Switzerland, France and the Austro-Hungarian Empire, and formed their own church.

In the ensuing years they made several reforms. Across Europe, the local language replaced Latin in mass starting in 1880. Requiring celibacy of priests was abandoned in 1878. Each change was preceded by lengthy and, sometimes bitter, debate.

While the Vatican has disputed the validity of the service held last Monday in Constance and called into question the two women’s priesthood, the German Bishops’ Conference appeared to observe silence.

“Anything that we say might lead to a misunderstanding,” said conference spokesman Rudolf Hammerschmidt. “So what would be the point?” he told CNS.

Of Germany’s 28 million baptised Roman Catholics, only around five million are regular churchgoers. Of those, some 1.5 million signed a petition last autumn urging the Pope to relax his rigid views on sexuality and women as priests.

Reports said such actions might be encouraged by the ceremony in Constance when Pope delivers on Jun 24 his final words to the German people in front of the historic Brandenburg Gate in Berlin, once a main passage through the wall which separated East and West Berlin.

Reaching Berlin on Jun 23 from Paderborn, the Pope will beatify two German priests martyred for their opposition to Nazi regime in Germany (1933-45). The ceremony will be held in Berlin Olympic stadium, built up Adolf Hitler to present a favourable image of Germany under his rule.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags