Asia-Pacific, Global, Global Geopolitics, Headlines | Analysis

UNITED NATIONS: Boutros-Ghali – The New U.S.-China Flashpoint

Analysis - Yojana Sharma

HONG KONG, Jun 27 1996 (IPS) - Beijing and Washington are headed for another showdown — this time the political battle lines are being drawn over the re-election bid of U.N. Secretary General Boutros Boutros-Ghali.

Earlier this month, Washington officially announced its opposition to Boutros-Ghali’s re-election once his term of office expires at the end of this year, but since then Beijing has made it equally clear that it will stand behind the Egyptian diplomat whom China regards as an “old friend”.

In recent times, the two protagonists have wrestled over a number of issues ranging from trade to human rights and copyright piracy, and while compromises have been reached, bilateral eations remain strained.

This latest issue however may have broader implications as a result of the very nature of the battleground and the democratic principles on which it prides itself.

“I don’t think that because one member state says one thing, it should become the rule of law,” U.N. spokesman Ahmad Fawzi said in New York last week. “This is a democratic institution.”

For all the criticisms of the United Nations, its is the one representative body for the rich and poor countries of the world and while the West, particularly the United States is the main funder and power broker, the election of the U.N.’s top diplomat is not a foregone conclusion.

As a member of the United Nations Security Council, with the right of veto, Beijing is a powerful ally in Boutros-Ghali’s corner.

So that though most analysts acknowledge that without U.S. support Boutros-Ghali is unlikely to secure another term, Beijing would still be in a position to veto all U.S.-backed candidates for the post.

Moreover, the secretary general’s own determination to fight for the post with the support of much of the developing world, provides China with a platform on which it can go on the offensive in questioning the motives behind the U.S. objections to Boutros- Ghali’s re-election.

U.S. officials say Washington wants a new face in the post because it says Boutros-Ghali has failed to carry out the reforms needed in the body.

China, through its official media, in particular the Communist Party organ ‘The People’s Daily’ argues that the U.S. opposition to Boutros-Ghali is because the secretary-general’s efforts to reform the United Nations did not conform with U.S. aims.

A Chinese foreign ministry spokesman earlier this week described the U.N. chief as an “old friend of China” and said he had played a positive role during his four years in office.

Last week the official “Guangming Daily” also accused Washington of blocking Boutros-Ghali’s bid for a second mandate because he had refused to make the United Nations “an instrument of U.S. policy”.

The are several reasons why Beijing regards Boutros-Ghali as a friend.

In 1993, the secretary general barred a dissident Chinese student Shen Tong from entering U.N. headquarters in New York for a press conference on the eve of the fourth anniversary of the Tiananmen Square Massacre of June 1989.

Boutros-Ghali had been responding to a request from China’s ambassador to the United Nations to stop the press conference. Observers say he was the first U.N. secretary general to openly and officially ban from U.N. property, someone who displeased a member state.

During a five-day visit to Beijing in March when tensions in the Taiwan Strait were at their height due to belligerent military exercises launched by Beijing, the secretary-general made clear that Taiwan chances of admission to the United Nations were virtually nil.

“You cannot admit a member without the recommendation of the Security Council, and China has veto power,” Boutros-Ghali said. “Unless there is a change of mind by Beijing there is no possibility to admit Taiwan as a member.”

The U.N. chief is also in Beijing’s good books for not backing observer status at the U.N. for Taiwan last year “under any circumstances”.

U.N. observers with non-voting status include the Vatican, Switzerland, and the Palestine Liberation Organisation (PLO). North and South Korea were observers before they were admitted to full membership.

With Taiwan unlikely to give up its bid for U.N. membership, Beijing feels that Boutros-Ghali’s support would be crucial in coming years.

Notes one diplomat here: “For China to have an ‘old friend’ like Dr Boutros-Ghali is very usefulganise the United Nations and admit Germany and Japan as permanent “We have the veto power and we are prepared to use it,” he told reporters in Washington.

But so does China, as do two other permanent Security Council members Russia and France (the other is Britain) which are both reported to favour giving Boutros-Ghali a second five year term.

As the first African to hold the top post, Boutros-Ghali also has strong support on the African continent and in the developing world as a whole.

“The United States has a veto, yes, but I don’t think that is the end of the game,” Nabil el-Araby, Egypt’s U.N. ambassador said in New York last week.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags