Saturday, November 21, 2026
Kalinga Seneviratne
- Pacific island nations are looking to East Asia and away from their dominant Western oriented neighbours in a bid to come up with media laws that allow for a measure of Press freedom that respects traditional culture.
The governments of Papua New Guinea (PNG) and Fiji, fed up with what they view as irresponsible and insensitive reporting on their countries by Western media and foreign-trained journalists, believe there are lessons to be learned from media regulations in non-Western cultures.
Critics however argue that Pacific nation governments, their failings exposed by aggressive reporting, are seeking to put undue curbs on the media and point out that the East and South-east Asian countries to which they have turned, have traditionally kept the Press under tight rein.
Fiji’s Prime Minister, Sitiveni Rabuka, told a ‘Media Freedom Day’ gathering in Suva in May that his government was studying media laws in Malaysia, Singapore and Thailand with a view to introducing confidentiality and privacy laws.
The media in these countries accepted as essential, checks and balances designed for national security, social cohesion and economic progress, he said.
In the case of Papua New Guinea, where the Constitutional Review Commission (CRC) is preparing a submission on media laws for presentation to parliament, the CRC’s chairman Ben Michah in February this year visited China, Hong Kong, Malaysia, Singapore and Indonesia in February to look at media laws there.
“We need freedom of expression in this country, but this freedom must be taken with responsibility,” he told reporters on his return.
The August edition of the Suva-based Pacific Island Monthly (PIM) — a magazine owned by Australian-born media magnate Rupert Murdoch — however views with suspicion, the region’s pre-occupation with a revision of media laws.
PIM, in an editorial under the heading “A Cultural Myth”, argues that much is made of cultural sensitivity and the need to respect local traditions, but “our leaders seem to have forgotten that their purpose is to serve their country and their people”.
The magazine observes that if media reports reveal facts which are negative or unfavourable of governments, they are labeled as of being culturally insensitive or accused of trying undermine social stability.
One typical case, said PIM, was the threat by the Vanuatu government to clamp a defamation lawsuit against the bi-weekly “Trading Post” for publishing a front-page story about the financial woes of the state-owned National Bank of Vanuatu.
In another recent incident, the Fiji government tried to stop expatriate spice farmer Dr Ronald Gatty from writing a weekly column in the “Fiji Times”. His columns on religion and the chiefly system were described as racist and insensitive to Fijian traditional customs.
Dr Gatty, who believes that freedom of expression exists only if people exercise it, refused to stop writing and the Fiji government later backed down. He told PIM that the government “tended to pick the ones that are embarrassing to the administration”.
He also claimed that the Indo-Fijians are afraid to speak out about these issues because “it might hurt their business”.
Fiji is of mixed race — with 50 per cent of the population is Indian — descendants of plantation workers who came to the Pacific early this century. The rest of Fiji’s 775,000 people are native Melanesians (43 per cent), Europeans and Chinese.
But while there are some in the Pacific media community that question the governments’ motives, a leading Pacific Islander academic says that the region’s leaders do have legitimate concerns about the negative light in which Western-oriented media portray their countries.
In a keynote speech to an international gathering of mass communications researchers held in Sydney recently, Professor Konai Helu-Thaman from Tonga, said the PIM article was reflective of a “lack of real understanding of the cultural contexts and complexities of our region”.
Helu-Thaman, who is the Head of the School of Humanities at the University of the South Pacific in Suva, said that both local and foreign journalists working in the region appear to have a “rather superficial understanding of the cultural histories of the people living in the Pacific”.
Ashley Wickham, former head of the Soloman Islands Broadcasting Corporation, shares that view.
“What is happening out there (in the Pacific) is not well understood from cultures that have pushed the modernisation theories we have come to know as development since the end of World War II,” said Wickham.
He said that journalists, especially from Australia and New Zealand, who have had a high degree of access to the Pacific media, have pushed the idea that the Pacific Island nations are in need of “salvation”.
“Some of these theories still cover the way people from outside our region see us,” he told IPS. “We, within the islands to some extent have been conditioned to believe some of those perceptions which undermine our confidence.”
Wickham explained that the small island nations in the Pacific were struggling to come to terms with the global political and economic changes that have taken place in recent years, and there is no room for an insensitive media fanning social discontent.
Papua New Guinea Prime Minister Julius Chan recently accused the Australian media of this kind of irresponsible and insensitive reporting.
Only after being promised by Australia’s Channel 7 “Witness” programme producer that a sought after interview would not form part of a “usual tabloid style” report, did Chan agree to talk in front of the cameras.
But, says Chan, the producers selectively took parts of that interview and others conducted with his two predecessors, and zoomed in only on the separatist war being waged in Bougainville, “rascal” hoodlums, and corruption in Papua New Guinea.
“The self-righteous approach and pontificating delivery chosen by your reporter and producer is a little sickening,” wrote Chan in a letter sent from his office to the programme’s producer “You…opted for a completely negative attack.”
Even native Pacific island journalists — many trained in Australia, New Zealand and Britain — are said to be guilty of irresponsible government and country bashing.
It is not training in journalistic skills that is lacking, says Wickham, who was the Educational Broadcasts Officer of the South Pacific Commission’s Regional Media Centre in Fiji from 1986 until earlier this year.
What is lacking, he explains, is the ability of Pacific writers and broadcasters to properly think through how stories should be handled. “We need a historical perspective for a start. Not the flawed one that we are working with right now.”
He adds: “The reality is, we can only live within the resources of our small islands. We can’t think like the people on the continent (Australia). This is where our media has failed.”
Prof Helu-Thaman agrees.
“Modernising agents, including Pacific islanders, who have been exposed to Western education…must realise the different assumptions and values that underpin the practices and ideas which they may be introducing willy nilly to people who have been socialised in different cultural contexts, that make different assumptions, and hold different values,” she said.
“As Pacific islanders, we need to have a better insight into these issues.”