Friday, November 20, 2026
Analysis - Yojana Sharma
- After triumphantly hoisting the Chinese flag on the disputed Diaoyu Islands in the East China Sea, Hong Kong activists are beginning to discover that patriotism, in the East Asian context, is more complex than raising flags on a rock.
In September, a group of Hong Kong and Taiwanese protesters succeeded in evading a Japanese flotilla to land on the Diaoyu Islands and raising the nationalist Taiwanese and Chinese flags.
For many of the protesters, this was one way for Hong Kong people to display their “Chineseness” ahead of the British Colony’s scheduled hand-over to Chinese rule on Jun 30, 1997.
The protesters were hailed in the gung-ho Hong Kong newspapers as Chinese “Patriots”. The media has at times been seen to encouraged the campaign. The usually sedate ‘South China Morning Post’ has previously urged China, in an editorial, to send warships to back up its claim to the islands.
Tension over the long-running dispute over the islands first heightened in July when members of the Japan Youth Federation sailed to the islands — claimed by Japan, China and Taiwan — and erected a lighthouse and a monument with a Japanese flag to honour World War II dead.
Political relations took a further nosedive in early September when Japanese Foreign Minister Yukihiko Ikeda, on a visit to Hong Kong, reiterated Tokyo claims to the disputed islands known in Japan as Senkaku, in China as Daioyu and in Taiwan as Taioyutai.
That drew an immediate and unusually patriotic response from Hong Kong citizens who called on China to dispatch a naval unit to the uninhabited islands that lie 400 kms south-west of Japan’s Okinawa prefecture and about 175 kms from north-eastern Taiwan.
But while China has harshly criticised what it describes as a resurfacing of Japanese “militarism”, it has given no indication that Beijing is at the prepared to enter a direct military confrontation with Japan.
Hong Kong activists have however tried to force the issue. But now, after the heady effects of successfully planting the flag have worn off, Hong Kong people are beginning to examine their political awakening as “Chinese” people and to understand what it really means to stand behind the Chinese flag.
“Previously Hong Kong people psychologically resisted the Chinese five-star flag, but since the Diaoyu row, they no longer resist it, especially after it was draped over the body of David Chan,” said director of Radio Television Hong Kong, Cheung Man Yee, in an interview with the South China Morning Post Newspaper.
Hong Kong protester Chan died off the islands after jumping in the sea in protest. His body was brought back to Hong Kong draped in the Chinese flag –, an emotive symbol for many here.
“Patriots in mainland China are those who conform to the political behaviour that Chinese leaders approve of,” noted one observer, “But what the Hong Kong activists did, clearly made Beijing nervous.”
In China itself, there has been little mention of the Diaoyu dispute or Taiwan’s protests to Japan in official Chinese-language media.
And in Taiwan, newspapers gave as much emphasis to talks between Taiwan and Japan on fishing rights around the islands as to the anti-Japanese protesters.
Says Terry Cheng, editor of the Hong Kong Standard newspaper. “Concern in Taiwan about the political ramifications of the Diaoyu issue is understandable. The Diaoyus are much closer to Taiwan than the (Chinese) Mainland.”
A few people in Hong Kong had before this month’s action, questioned whether it was wise for “patriotic” Hong Kong protesters to be seen to be in league with Taiwan’s pro- independence groups.
But such concerns were shrugged off by those caught up in the emotion of the protests, and unwilling to see beyond the immediate goal of planting a flag on the islands.
The single-mindedness with which the Hong Kong groups pursued that goal made it all the more difficult for them to understand the political issues that came up in the wake of the flat- planting.
While Hong Kong, Taiwanese and Mainland Chinese groups were at first united in their opposition to the Japanese claim, the Hong Kong group who arrived home to a rousing welcome of bouquets and garlands from well-wishers, were shocked at the reaction in Taiwan.
Some 500 pro-Taiwan Independence protesters stormed the hotel in Taipei where the Hong Kong protesters were staying, holding banners saying “Hong Kong people go home, get out of the Diaoyu Islands” and “We are not Chinese, we are Taiwanese.”
In Taiwan, they also burnt paper Chinese flags, saying it was an insult that the Chinese flag had been raised on the islands.
Taiwan alone owns the islands, said the Democratic Progressive Party. “The barbaric behaviour (of the Hong Kong activists) not only shows severe ignorance of international political reality it is also contradictory.”
Members of Taiwan’s newly formed National Building Party shouted branded the Hong Kong group as “communist accomplices” and “communist running dogs”.
“Hong Kong people, in their rush to show how “Chinese” they really are, have failed to realised that “ethnicity” is not the same as patriotism, said one analysts here. “China and Taiwan harbour deep divisions despite being ethnically Chinese.”
Other analysts have noted that Hong Kong “patriots” who have proudly flaunted their allegiance to China may now find themselves under attack from others, whenever the Chinese government is criticised overseas.
But in Hong Kong, protesters continue to shrug off the political ramifications of their actions. Says Tsang Kin Sheng, the Hong Kong legislator who raised the flag on the islands: “We have successfully raised the issue, now it is for the Chinese government to bring it up with Japan.”
But on such an issue as important as Chinese “patriotism” Beijing wants to call the shots. Chinese-backed officials in Hong Kong are already making it clear what constitutes “patriotic” behaviour.
Peter Woo, a candidate for the post of Hong Kong’s first post- 1997 governor said in an interview this week that Hong Kong people had “no right to speak on foreign affairs before and after 1997”.
He said they could continue to express their views by “legal” means but had to support the stand of the Chinese government over the Diaoyu Islands.
And the New China News Agency, the de facto Chinese consulate here has circulated instructions to all Chinese-funded enterprises in Hong Kong to be alert to “people who might have ulterior motives over the Diaoyu issue”.
Analysts say that this is the beginning of moves by China to contain the new “patriots”, by calling their motives into question.