Global, Global Geopolitics, Headlines

MEDIA-CULTURE: Calling All Couch Potatoes!

R. Craig Hobbs WASHINGTON, Dec 13 1996 (IPS) - With the increasing barrage of information rushing over cable and satellite, the world is awash with media messages and images.

But while mass communications researchers and theorists have disagreed for decades over the impact of television and other media images on viewers, the resurgence of media education campaigns around the world indicates a consensus on the need for action.

“Today, the family, the school, and all community institutions share the responsibility of preparing young people for living in a world of powerful images, words, and sounds,” says Elizabeth Thoman, director of the Centre for Media Literacy in Los Angeles.

Thoman says viewers need the ability to interpret the symbols and meanings of the thousands of messages people get every day from television, radio, print media, and advertising. “It’s the ability to choose and select, the ability to challenge and question, the ability to be conscious about what’s going on around you and not just be passive couch potatoes.”

The media literacy movement in the United States is relatively young compared to the efforts of other countries.

Barry Duncan, president of the Association of Media Literacy in Toronto, Canada, says that at best, citizen and alternative groups working to educate media consumers constitute a healthy, active 10 percent of a given population.

“Unless the school system is prepared to make this a mandatory part of the curriculum and take it seriously, then there are not going to be enough citizens’ groups to educate the big mass that are culturally naive as to how the media work,” he says.

The fundamental skills of media literacy allow viewers to be conscious and deliberate about what they experience. Skillful readers and viewers examine different stylistic features of a media product and pay careful attention to the context in which the message occurs.

“This concept turns the tables on the idea of TV viewers as just passive couch potatoes,” says Thoman. “We may not be conscious of it, but we are constantly trying to make sense of what we see, hear or read.”

According to Thoman, core concepts of media literacy can help consumers of information discriminate between reality and fantasy, bias and “unbias”. One of the first things media literacy campaigners teach is that media products are carefully manufactured cultural products, whose words and images are edited and manipulated by a production, creating an emotional experience that looks like reality.

While media products are not “real”, they affect people in real ways, because viewers, listeners, and readers take and make meaning for themselves, says Thoman.

George Gerbner, Dean Emeritus at the Annenberg School of Communication at the University of Pennsylvania, has long studied the world of television. He concludes that heavy watchers of prime- time TV receive a grossly distorted picture of the world that they tend to accept more readily that reality itself.

“The violence and terror we see on television bear little or no relationship to their actual occurrence,” Gerbner has written. “Neither their frequency nor their nature resembles trends in crime statistics. Rather, they follow marketing formulas that call for injecting ‘action’ into dramatic programmes and news.”

Media researchers see most Western media as ad-driven businesses, in which newspapers first lay out advertisements on their pages then place news in the space remaining. And corporate sponsors pay TV stations based on the number of people they expect to be watching. Advertisers want viewers who can spend their money on their products.

As Gerbner observes, media messages are provided to us by private corporations with something to sell rather than by the family, church, or school, who have something to tell.

Thoman notes that media also use unique “languages”, for conveying certain intended meaning. Scary music heightens fear, camera angles convey relationships, and headlines signal significance.

“Images are even more powerful, because they deal at the affective level rather than at the rational level,” she says. “So we’re more easily sucked into following our emotions rather than making intelligent and critical sense of messages.”

Edward Palmer, a former Children’s Television Workshop executive, is involved with the production of educational children’s television in Middle East countries. “We’ve conducted seminars in Egypt with the support of Unicef, with the objective of elevating awareness in the society,” he says.

The methods Palmer uses in such seminars carry many of the same fundamentals as campaigns in the United States. “We replay offenders and then discuss interesting examples of media literacy,” says Palmer.

While the media literacy movement gained momentum worldwide in the 1970s in response to the increase in media domination by Western countries, multilateral attempts to thwart what was seen as U.S. media imperialism were never effective.

“You cannot make a universal set of (media education) materials for the whole world,” says Carlos Arnaldo of the Information and Research division of UNESCO in Paris. “You have to put media literacy together with the social aspects of media: the family, the school, and the community.”

Arnaldo says UNESCO has not been active in media literacy since the 1980s. But this may change because of new technologies and a new medium — the Internet.

“We missed the boat in the last decade, and now we’ve got the Internet, and it’s expanding,” says Arnaldo. “What have we got to educate people about now? If they’re not educated, they are lambasted, abused, and hoodwinked.”

Groups working at the grassroots level are trying to spread education and empowerment around the world.

The World Association for Christian Communication based in London, produces a quarterly journal on media issues, hosts annual conferences on development and the communications industry, and funds projects — ranging from media literacy in Barbados, to strengthening indigenous communications practices in Mexico, to a women’s communication networking programme in Fiji.

“WACC came into existence after the second World War to try to ensure that nations never again face the onslaught of the propaganda machine that was used in Nazi Germany,” says Philip Lee, editor of WACC’ journal, ‘Media Development’.

Though the WACC has had to redefine its mission since its formation in the 1950s, its objectives have essentially remained the same.

“There is a notion in media education or media literacy in which people become responsible citizens,” says Lee. “An appreciation of how media functions in society can show you how democracy or other forms of government actually work.”

Development of responsible citizenry in developing countries is precisely what the WACC is trying to ensure. The organisation helped organise a media literacy drive in Papua New Guinea in the weeks before the country introduced television 10 years ago.

“It had a startling effect on the national media and on the groups that were involved,” says Lee. “They immediately became aware of other issues that weren’t simply, ‘Oh, goody, we’re going to have television and be able to watch football.”

Len Masterman, communications lecturer at the University of Liverpool and contributor to the WACC’s ‘Media Development’, stressed the need for media education worldwide.

“The danger to democratic values lies precisely in the gap which has opened up between the relative sophistication and power of media producers and media audiences,” he says. “Media education is one of the few weapons any culture possesses for at least addressing — and hopefully beginning to close — that gap.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags