Economy & Trade, Headlines, North America

CANADA-TRADE: Coffee Drinkers Can Choose Best Trade Practises

Stephen Dale

OTTAWA, Mar 31 1997 (IPS) - The simple act of buying a cup of coffee has turned complex in Canada.

An explosive growth in the number of upscale coffee bars, offering cappuccinos, espressos, lattes and drip coffees in a dazzling array of flavours and strengths has brought bewildering choice to the consumer and fresh profit to the big names in the coffee business.

A new ‘fair trade mark’ will, however, give Canadians a choice of a different sort.

Modelled on Europe’s ‘TransFair’ seal, which is licensed for 130 coffee brands in 35,000 European supermarkets, the new Canadian seal is intended to tell consumers that the people who grew and picked the beans have benefited from a fair rate of pay and decent working conditions.

“We are organising a buy-cott rather than a boycott,” says Bob Thomson, managing director of Fair TradeMark Canada. “We’re asking people to tell the coffee companies, ‘if you offer coffee that was produced under fair conditions, we will buy it’.”

Thomson and his colleagues at Fair TradeMark Canada have spent the past two-and-a-half years doing the legal legwork to establish the fair trade seal that they introduced in March.

As of March, the seal has been licensed only to Bridgehead, the marketing arm of Oxfam Canada, which supports co-ops in the developing world. In the long run, Thomson and others say that Canada’s new concern with international labour standards will translate as marketplace demand for “ethically traded” coffee that larger players in the coffee business would be unwise to ignore.

For now, the mainstream Canadian coffee concerns have told Fair TradeMark Canada that “they are not going to buy into this until we can demonstrate that there’s a marketing drive behind it that will bring customers in the door,” Thomson recounts.

That kind of marketing drive may be just around the corner.

‘Ten Days for Global Justice’, an initiative of the major Canadian churches, has adopted the fair trade issue as its campaign for 1988.

With the ability to get information into 16,000 churches across Canada and with 200 local organising committees scattered across the country, the ‘Ten Days’ project has the kind of reach that may help convince coffee companies that there is a market in ethically traded coffee.

“We are talking big numbers here,” says David Reed, the campaign’s co-ordinator of leadership training. “One of the things that we will be doing is to get people in the local parishes to commit themselves to buying the coffee that can be certified as fairly traded.”

“There will be petitions and pledge forms which people can take to their local coffee shop and say ‘get this kind of coffee; we are going to buy it’.”

Reed argues that fair trade touches a nerve in many Canadians who have heard a lot recently about poor working conditions abroad — in farment and toy factories as well as in coffee fields.

“Our belief is that people do care; there is a moral fibre in the majority of people,” Reed told IPS. “We also feel that people want to be involved in something that is concrete and tangible. In the past, most of our campaigns have involved lobbying government around policy matters. Fair trade is something different, where people can become directly involved in the solution.”

Coffee is not the only issue that has attracted Canadian public attention to the potential role of Fair Trade marks. Canada’s Parliamentary Committee on Sustainable Human Development released a report in February on the international use of child labour, in which it recommends that the Canadian government provide funding for a two-year trial to bring the Rugmark labelling programme to Canada.

Rugmark, which began as a cooperative effort between German agencies, Indian groups, and carpet manufacturers, specially labels rugs that have not been made by children. A portion of the rug profits is used for monitoring the programme and supporting schools for displaced child labourers.

Chairman of the parliamentary committee John English told IPS that voluntary labelling programmes like Rugmark are the most promising political means for dealing with labour issues, since “official trade sanctions threaten to put sand in the wheels of international trade generally” and are therefore rejected by finance and trade ministers.

But the committee’s endorsement of the Rugmark programme has stirred controversy, since it contradicts a study conducted by UNICEF Canada for the federal Department of Foreign Affairs. That report concludes that the Canadian market for hand-woven carpets is too small to justify an investment in the Rugmark programme, particularly if the money is to come from a declining aid budget.

English, however, contends that, despite the small market, Rugmark is valuable as a means of publicising the child labour problem. “Ultimately, it is public opinion that will reduce child labour,” he says.

In the context of this debate over labour standards, advocates of fairly traded coffee believe the public mood is on their side. FairTrade Mark’s Bob Thomson says market forces now favour both people- and bird-friendly coffee.

While some countries in Latin America and the Caribbean encourage the expansion of high-yield, sun-ripened coffee, environmentalists support more traditional methods, where coffee is allowed to ripen under the shade of neighbouring trees that also provide a habitat for migratory birds.

“The issue was, how do you encourage bird-friendly coffee,” says Thomson. Coffee ripened in the shade produces the more flavourful and expensive “specialty” coffee, which is the fastest growing portion of the market, he says, adding that this high end of the coffee trade is also where fair-traders see most of their supporters.

Specialty coffee companies have also indicated that they want to come out on the right side of the issue.

Starbucks, the largest U.S. retailer of specialty coffee, adopted a code of conduct to encourage good labour and environmental practices in developing countries in 1995. The move followed a grassroots campaign initiated by the U.S./Guatemala Labour Education Project that called on the company to set minimum standards for working conditions on plantations from which they buy.

Critics, however, are unimpressed, saying that charitable donations and voluntary codes of conduct do not address the fundamental injustice of a world coffee market that does not give labourers and small producers a decent income.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags