Sunday, November 22, 2026
Analysis - Antoaneta Bezlova
- Agriculture in China is fast becoming a battlefield, where the rigid policy of state planning and the growing pressure of the free market are crossing swords.
This summer, China is expected to have another bumper harvest and reach a record grain output.
But the state’s agricultural policies, which have been strictly pursuing self-reliance over the last couple of years, are now leading to saturation of grain and losses of crops due to lack of storage facilities.
Ostensibly, the Chinese government has embarked on a policy to ensure that the world’s most populous country can feed itself in the next century, and avoid the disastrous famines that have plagued it throughout its history.
In the two decades since sweeping agricultural reform freed up collectives and spurred a production boom, the government has persistently sought bigger and bigger grain outputs.
China has previously recorded three consecutive bumper harvests, and it has almost doubled grain procurement prices in the past two years. But now the bumper harvests are pushing down grain prices.
Ironically, the same market forces that have made possible a boom in grain production are now causing problems in the agriculture sector that officials fear may cause social instability.
Likewise, officials fear opening the farm market, which would lead to a free fall of grain prices and cut household income of farmers. This fuels deep concern about instability, even unrest, in the Chinese countryside where about 800 million people live.
Problems in the farm sector also speak of the internal fights within China’s leadership over how wide should be the scope of the free-market experiment in a country with a suppressive political system.
While pledging to continue the course of economic reforms set up by China’s late paramount leader Deng Xiaoping, his successor Jiang Zemin is keeping an wary eye on the pace of reforms taking place in Chinese countryside.
Since 1994, the central government has been pursuing policies of buying the grain at protective prices to keep the market stable and while using different means to urge farmers to increase grain production.
Last year, China harvested 490 million tonnes of grain and this year the figure is expected to hit 500 million tonnes — which previous estimates by Chinese experts say is a target figure for the year 2000.
However, reports quoted the ministry of internal trade as saying grain output this year is so far forecast to be at 484 million tonnes, or slightly below last year’s level.
It is clear though that the three consecutive years of good harvests have created a declining trend in grain prices. Prices for corn, wheat and rice fell by more than 30 percent since last year, making many farmers hesitant to sell.
Others are piling up grain supplies while hoping for better prices and for the government to buy their produce at subsidised prices.
Analysts fear that farmers will not want to want to plant grain in the future, which would spell trouble for a country that has to feed 1.2 billion people with only one-seventh of the world’s arable land.
At the same time, authorities are growing anxious about how to keep farmers happy as their incomes diminish. Farmers’ average annual incomes grew by 9 percent last year, but only about half that figure is projected for 1997, the agriculture ministry says.
At the end of June, China’s economic tsar Zhu Rongji pledged that the state will do all necessary to buy all the grain ordered in advance and will not lower prices fixed previously. Said Zhu: “The localities are to learn from past lessons and should take immediate steps to stabilise grain prices.”
Zhu’s appeal seemed more than compulsory to appease uneasy grain growers who have complained about falling prices and the lack of storage for bumper harvests. Grain reservers have been full due to bumper harvests since 1995.
Zhang Xinmin, chief of a research team on rural economy with the State Statistical Bureau, reveals that the real figure for last year’s grain output was actually higher than the official figure released publicly.
He attributes this to the disparity to the scattered character of Chinese agricultural production.
Land in China is cultivated on a small scale by millions of rural households through a family responsibility system introduced in the 1980s, under which leases are awarded to households that have the right to work the land and sell part of their production on the market.
This system, a major reason behind China’s hiked agricultural production, makes the collection of agro-data very difficult.
Some China watchers speculate that the record figure of grain output is intentionally being kept for this year’s harvest. The release of the harvest figure for this year is to precede the opening of the most important meeting of the Communist Party — the 15th Party Congress.
Party congresses take place every five years and the 15th Congress is to set up the course of China’s development in the 21st century, and to make major reshuffles among Communist Party and government leaders.
The leadership is expected to defend its interventionist agricultural policies by presenting the country’s record grain outputs. A figure of 500 million tonnes of grain — as rural expert Zhang hinted this year’s harvest will be — would mean that China has reached a level of grain supply able to fill demand in the year 2000.
This, Chinese leaders believe, would testify to the country’s ability to feed itself in the next century, a sensitive matter that is often the subject of international debate.
Among others, China’s food security has been questioned by people like environmental researcher Lester Brown of the U.S.- based Worldwatch Institute, who prophesies a worldwide grain crisis by the year 2030 due to China’s gigantic needs.
For the Chinese leadership, proving the ability to provide for future food needs serves as a tool to build its legitimacy as the only political body able to lead China in the coming century.
After having made great efforts to take credit for Hong Kong’s return to the motherland, the communist leadership want to score an equally significant point in the economic sphere as well.
From a larger viewpoint, a stable farm sector with satisfied farmers would balance off the restive industrial sector, where more than 40 percent of the state enterprises are in debt and the number of unemployed workers is expected to hit a record 20 million by the end of the century.