Headlines

MALAYSIA: Stricter Islamic Laws Set off Debate

Anil Noel Netto

PENANG, Malaysia, Aug 31 1997 (IPS) - Muslims taking part in body- building contests in Malaysia’s Sarawak state have been told they risk being arrested for exposing their bodies.

Three Muslim women contestants at a June beauty pageant were rounded up and handcuffed for “indecent exposure” by religious authorities in Selangor state, which lies next to the capital of Kuala Lumpur. And Malaysian prime minister Mahathir Mohamad, wi dely seen as an Islamic moderate, is being labelled by critics a ‘murtad’ or apostate.

These incidents are triggering concern and debate about increasing signs of what some call an extreme form of ‘Islamisation’ in Malaysia.

Many Malaysians — majority are Malay, followed by Chinese and Indian — are keeping an eye on how things unfold in this multi- ethnic country that has earned a reputation for its open, tolerant and even progressive system of Islamic practice.

They are keeping track of the passage of laws on religious matters by states such as Selangor, which last year enacted a law banning Muslim women from taking part in beauty pageants.

The government is wary of the spread of an extremist brand of Islam. Recently, Mahathir announced that all Islamic Sharia laws in the country would be reviewed and those found to be “suppressing Muslims or putting the religion in a bad light”.

“You can call this effort a reformation of Islamic shariah,” said the premier, who has set up a committee to standardise the enforcement of Islamic law in Malaysia’s states.

The committee is expected to curb individual action by religious officials by deciding who can or should be accepted as ‘ulama’, or an Islamic scholars or authority.

Mahathir was said to have taken offence at being labelled an apostate by “certain” mufti (a legal functionary in issuing fatwa or religious decrees) after he slammed religious officials for the beauty pageant fiasco.

Away on hlday during the incident, Mahathir said it showed what happens when “we empower those who do not know how to use it (religion).” Deputy premier Anwar Ibrahim warned Islamic officials against being “overzealous” said Islamic regulations shoul d not abruptly enforced.

The arrest of the three three Muslim women who wore swimsuits at the ‘Miss Malaysia Petite’ beauty contest was the first time Selangor officials had implemented that law barring women’s participation in such pageants.

States have the power to legislate on religious matters. Muslim Malays are subject to both secular laws and Islamic law, which covers marriage and moral life. Malaysian Indian and Chinese are subject only to secular rules.

The beauty pageant incident also highlights the opposing undercurrents in Islam and politics in a country where Muslims, almost all of whom are Sunni, form just over half of Malaysia’s 20 million people.

On the one hand, there is Mahathir and his colleagues in the United Malays National Organisation (UMNO), the ruling colaition. Widely seen as moderates, they adopt a pragmatic, fairly progressive stance towards Islam. Mahathir has urged Muslims to progress economically and to acquire knowledge if their religion is to be respected.

On theoher side are certain groups, including religious officials, who advocate a retur to strict Islamic Shariah laws.

Critics say these groups have a somewhat legalistic and literal interpretation of the Qur’an and the hadith, or prophetic traditions. They fret about the onslaught of consumerism and material development, seeing it as a threat to Islam.

“I see recent events as a last-ditch attempt by certain groups to counter the influence of rapid economic development, which is leading to greater secularism among middle-class Muslims,” says historian Ariffin Omar, who has studied Islamic ‘deviation’

movements.

In early June, several state governments banned public concerts by the pop group KRU, which was on a nationwide tour. One state chief minister said he did not want to encourage anything that hinted of “maniacal action or madness”, while others complain ed about its “un-Islamic behaviour”.

But at the heart of the controversy lies the debate between conservatives and moderates on the Islamic notion of modesty in dressing.

In recent years some groups have been backing a conservative dress code for Muslims, especially Muslim women. This would also bar men fromexposing any part between the navel and the knees. But these are “a misguided undrstanding of what modesty is all about,” argues Ariffin.

Groups of Muslim women have also spoken out. “The Qur’an indicates that modesty arises out of our own God-consciousness and others cannot impose that God-consciousness by enforcing or coercing covering or removing covering,” a group called Sisters in I slam said in a letter to the press.

It said the Qur’an does not appear to promote any specific form of dress, but says the best garment of all is the garment of piety or ‘taqwa’.

“Yet we seem poised to introduce more laws and regulations on dressing and morality which does not encourage taqwa among the believers but fear of the State and of Islam,” the Sisters said. Qur’annic verses infer that modesty can be achieved in various forms of dress suitable to different cultures, times and places, they said.

Indeed, most Muslim women in Malaysia dress modestly, wearing full-length, loose, flowing attire. A fair number cover their heads, but not their faces, with scarves.

Hardly any Muslim Malay woman shrouds herself in black from head to toe, unlike some Islamic nations in West Asia. In fact, Islamic attire in Malaysia can be quite trendy, with a splash of colours lighting up traditional designs.

Marina Mahathir, the prime minister’s daughter, wrote in her newspaper column recently that misguided religious official wanted women to stay at home and have “babies endlessly and (be) covered head to toe”.

There seems to be no groundswell of support for stricter Islamic codes. “What you have is silent resentment,” Ariffin said. “I think there will be a backlash.”

Critics also point to declining support for the opposition Islamic party PAS, which seeks an Islamic state. In 1990, PAS captured all seats in the Kelantan state assembly. But Mahathir’s Barisan Nasional coalition made inroads on the Islamic party’s grip in recent by-elections.

In seeking to reform Malaysian society, Ariffin urges religious officials take stock of current priorities. “Religious council officials would be far better off looking into social problems such as unwanted pregnancies and drug addiction,” he said. (EN D/IPS/AP-CR/ANN/JS/97)

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags

Asia-Pacific, Development & Aid, Headlines, Population

MALAYSIA: Stricter Islamic Laws Set off Debate

Anil Noel Netto

PENANG, Malaysia, Aug 25 1997 (IPS) - Muslims taking part in body- building contests in Malaysia’s Sarawak state have been told they risk being arrested for exposing their bodies.
(more…)

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags