Friday, November 20, 2026
Nasim Zehra
- Afghan watchers in Pakistan are convinced that if the U.N seat were handed over to the Taleban or vacated, it would bolster peace efforts and force the Taleban to be more wary of world opinion in imposing their version of Islam.
The U.N. should adopt the “vacant seat” formula that was endorsed by the Organisation of Islamic Countries (OIC) at its meetings, urged an Islamabad-based political commentator.
“This would reflect reality. More importantly it would also encourage the factions to move towards a broad-based dispensation in order to secure full international legitimacy and recognition,” foreign office officials argue.
In the U.N. Security Council recently, Pakistan had also pointed out that for the U.N “it is not only important to be equitable, but also to be seen to be equitable towards the Afghan factions.”
Since its rise two years ago as a student-led Islamist force, the Taleban has gained control of more than two-thirds of Afghanistan, including Kabul which it captured last September from president Burhanuddin Rabbani’s forces who fled north.
But only three countries, Pakistan, Saudi Araia and the United Arab Emirates have recognised the Taleban’s claim to be the new rulers. At the United Nations, Rabbani’s government continues to represent the people of Afghanistan.
Islamabad, which does not deny its closeness to the Taleban whose leaders were in seminaries in Pakistan, says that it has always recognised whoever has occupied Kabul like Noor Mohammad Taraki, Bourjedi Mujadidi and Rabbani.
Afghanistan, torn by the conflicting interests of rival ethnic groups inside and by the ambtious goals of its neighbours for the last five years, requires “sincere mediation”, a political commentator said.
The U.N’s business should be of mediation. Officials in Islamabad maintain that the “U.N must play a flagship role, but its credentials are still questionable…”
If the U.N were to get the Afghan seat vacated, the Afghan expert added, the move would not mean victory for any of the contending groups, but would let the world know that the U.N means business when it talks of peace in Afghanistan.
A special envoy of U.N Secretary General Kofi Annan returned to New York last month after reviewing the United Nations Special Mission on Afghanistan (UNSMA). Lakhdar Brahimi, an experienced Algerian diplomat, logged in thusands of miles to meet with all the rival factions and regional players involved in Afghanistan.
Nothing new has emerged from those meetings. Brahimi’s initial findings, which he has shared with members of the Security Council and with the Group of 22 on Afghanistan, paints an almost hopeless picture. He is likely to present his final report to the Secretary General before month-end.
He has found that neither the Afghan factions nor regional powers with stakes in Afghanistan have taken any practical steps towards a peaceful resolution of the lingering war. He has apparently come down heavily on the Taleban for its refusal to dialogue with its opponents, the 3-party Northern Alliance.
Overall there is perhaps a deeper realisation of the quagmire the Afghan situation really presents. The U.N. has been pulled into a no-win situation and essentially there is no real support for a U.N initiated peace process from any quarter.
Afghanistan’s neighbours Iran and Pakistan have become patrons of the two main factions fighting in Afghanistan, actively fuelling the ongoing civil war, even if to a varying degree.
Brahimi’s conclusions about the complexity of the problem cannot be questioned although the recommendations may require a harder look. Reportedly Brahimi is proposing a U.N facilitated weapons and fuel embargo on Afghanistan.
Also, reflecting perhaps the assessment of the Pakistanis and the Islamabad-based Western diplomats, questions have been raised about the effectiveness of the UNSMA head Dr Nobert Holl, who began his assignment with great eagerness in July 1995 but has failed to make even the slightest difference.
The Taleban believe he is partisan, following the anti-Taleban line pursued by the international community. The Islamic movement’s restrictions particularly on women has been cited as a reason for western distancing from the Taleban.
There is speculation in Islamabad that Brahimi’s report may lead to Holl’s departure but that alone will not resolve the issue of UNSMA’s credibility. There are many other factors that
undermine the mediation role that the United Nation’s would like to play.
Most glaring is the United Nation’s decision to allow the Rabbani government to continue to hold the U.N seat. Afghan watchers here say that it is indeed strange that the seat should remain with a ousted president’s whose whereabouts are not known.
In allowing the Rabbani government to keep holding on Afghanistan’s General Assembly seat, the U.N. has opened itself to criticism. The Taleban have been in control of Kabul and 24 of Afghanistan’s 32 provinces for over a year. The Rabbani government was admitted into the U.N by the credentials committee when it controlled Kabul and six other provinces.