Friday, November 20, 2026
Abraham Lama
- The comic-book character, or the comedy actor in movies or on the TV screen, generally performs an important social function – approving an act while generally satirizing those involved.
This concept, however, has come under fire in the case of the two most successful comic characters on Peruvian television: a “Cholo” (Indian) called Tulio Loza and a “Chola” named Chabuca.”
Some analysts accuse the creators and actors involved in portraying these characters of inciting prejudice against the indigenous roots of Peruvian culture, but others believe that they are designed in a positive light that oppose such prejudices.
This theme generates controversy among social investigators about the nature and characteristics of what the sociologist and university professor Willy Nugent terms “choledad,” referring to the cultural image and idiosyncrasy of the Peruvian citiZen of mixed blood – the “mestizo” popularly known as “cholo.”
“It is not simply establishing if Tulio Loza or Chabuca make fun of or defend the cholos – if they reflect the most predominant racial prejudices in Peru, or if, on the contrary, they fight against them. Perhaps both things are occurring at the same time,” says psychiatrist Marta Rondon.
“One mechanism of a trained comic to distance himself or herslef from the character, so that when most of the mestizo, or indigenous people, laugh at them they actually feel different from the social type which is being caricatured,” she explains.
Loza and Pimentel both say that their characters do not reflect the racial prejudice that is generally acknowledged to exist in Peru. On the contrary, they fight against the negative image of the indigenous and the mestizos from the highlands as ignorant and stupid, they say.
“I defend the cholo. My character is not the traditional ignoramus who just came down from the highlands, and who everyone can cheat, but is so sharp and on the ball, that he even competes with people from the coast. My cholo is a winner,” says Loza.
“Since I created my first cholo character, Crisologo Quispe, for a radio program in 1959, before there was television in Peru, I made him a winner, an optimist, someone who could not be cheated. Now I have created Camotillo, a politicized cholo who criticizes the corruption of the bureaucrats and the errors of the politicians,” he adds.
“The Chola Chabuca is an intelligent character, who is well- spoken and tactful. She is a character who does not try to be comical by ridiculing or making fun of her interviewee,” says Pimentel.
However “I disagree with both, with Tulio Loza and with the Chola Chabuca. I do not feel represented by either, and I think that their comedy is based on ridiculing indigenous people like myself,” says Tarcillla Rivera, reporter and director of the non- governmental organization Chirapaq.
Rivera edits a magazine published by Chirapaq about indigenous social and cultural issues, and is trying to create a political movement defending “Indianness” in Peru.
“It is true that other comics have created Indian characters or cholos who are more obviously racist, who make fun of our accent, of our way of speaking and of our values,” he says.
“But, in spite of their discourse, and perhaps unintentionally, Tulio and Chabuca fall into the same category, but within the framework of a hypocritical society like Peru, which does not want to recognize that it is racist,” he concludes.
“Fernando Oshigue, a Peruvian with Japanese roots, and director of the Latin American and Caribbean Communication Agency, who subscribes to an ecumenical Christian line, shares Rivera’s opinion.
“From what they say, I understand that Tulio Loza and Chabuca want to do something different, but the result for me is still negative. Although the racial prejudice is blanketed, it is very strong in this country,” he says.
He considers that, on the race-approval scale in Peru, whites occupy the highest level, then the mestizos who can pass for whites, immediately followed by the Asian population, then the blacks, and finally, the cholos and indigenous.
The fact that one of the characters, the “Chola Chabuca” is played by a cross-dresser Ernesto Pimentel, adds a gender factor to the discussion.
Pimentel, a young actor who says he is not gay, explains that he chose a feminine character because of his admiration for the social emergence of women, “especially the cholas.” He did not think that Chabuca would be so successful that he would want to abandon his other original masculine characters.
The 60-year-old Loza, a veteran TV performer, responds with annoyance when asked his opinion about his competitor the Chola Chabuca.
“I don’t know why the Chola is so successful…But it’s a shame, I always thought that the cholo was a synonym of macho, and now it turns out that it is a cross-dresser, a sophisticated character with false skirts,” he says.
“You have to be very macho to play a woman, whether she be a chola or a white, rich or poor, so as not to resort to imitating the falsetto, or fear confusion, ” replies Pimentel.
Willy Nugent, who created the term “choledad” 10 years ago, a word which has since been used in a sociological context, has the final word on the phenomenon created by the Chola Chabuc:
“I think that two things come together, that of the chola, because of her highlands mestizo origin, and, even more important, the increasing presence of women in Peruvian society in recent years, even to the point of creating a crisis in masculine sexuality,” says Nugent.
“We know that our country is mixed, and I think that, luckily, this mix is increasingly not seen as disorder and impurity. But it is still a labyrinth, where one can get lost, but also where one can hide, protecting himself from threats that pursue him,” he says. (FIN/IPS/al/dg/cr-pr/bj/mk/97)