Global, Global Geopolitics, Headlines

MEXICO: Double Standards for Canada and Vatican?

Diego Cevallos

MEXICO CITY, Oct 19 1997 (IPS) - The Mexican government came under fire Tuesday from opposition legislators for allegedly applying ‘double standards’ to the ambassadors of Canada and the Vatican, both of whom recently spoke out on corruption and other internal questions considered off-limits to foreign diplomats.

While Ambassador Marc Perron was immediately sanctioned and removed from his post, it has been business as usual for Papal Nuncio Justo Mullor.

Legislators from the leading opposition parties argued that the government of President Ernesto Zedillo should have acted in a coherent manner, applying the same treatment to both diplomats.

Although few contend that Perron and Mullor’s remarks were far off the truth, their statements brought a chorus of protests from all along the political spectrum that they were “meddling in national affairs.”

According to Foreign Minister Jose Gurria, the case of Mullor is “delicate” but differs from that of the (now former) Canadian Ambassador Perron, who he said made “unfortunate” comments.

Last week, the representative of the Vatican said he knew of several cases of corruption in Mexico, insinuated that the army and the attorney-general’s office took bribes from drug traffickers and criticised the content of local school textbooks.

But Gurria was satisfied with a letter from Mullor stating that his opinions had been quoted “out of context.”

Perron was removed from his post, meanwhile, after telling the local magazine ‘Milenio’ that Mexico suffered from high levels of corruption and was a country that was “difficult to understand.” He also called for transparency in bidding processes for privatising public enterprises.

The magazine report says Perron refused, laughing, to describe Foreign Minister Gurria, saying “I want to stay a while longer in Mexico.”

The ambassador’s remarks rought a heated protest from Gurria, who personally called high-level government officials in Ottawa to ask for his removal.

Mullor, whose comments were not criticised by the government, should be given “the same medicine,” argued Senator Luis Gonzalez of the conservative National Action Party (PAN).

And Senator Cristobal Arias of the centre-left Party of the Democratic Revolution (PRD) said the Zedillo administration “overlooked the aggressive” remarks by the Vatican’s representative. “Yesterday he referred to ‘narco-bribes’, today to education; let’s see what bothers him tomorrow,” he added.

This is not the first time a representative of the Vatican has referred to internal Mexican questions. Bitter controversies have broken out in the past, and on more than one occasion an array of social sectors have asked the government to expel the Pope’s delegate.

But in te latest episode, the general secretary of the Mexican Episcopate, Ramon Godinez, warned the government that sanctioning or expelling Mullor would be a “lamentable and silly” move that would set “a bad precedent in relations” with the Vatican.

Notwithstanding the controversy, a number of analysts maintained that the diplomats’ remarks were not far from the truth.

Perron was not mistaken, and “did not say anything that we Mexicans don’t already know, and isn’t already discussed in diplomatic circles,” said PAN Senator Jose Conchelo.

Gabriel Szekely, an expert in international relations at the College of Mexico, noted that the fact that “an ambassador like Perron has such a severe opinion indicates the probability that other ambassadors have similar views.”

According to a list drawn up this year by the non-governmental organisation Transparency International, Mexico ranks sixth in the world in terms of corruption, outdone only by Nigeria, Bolivia, Colombia, Russia and Pakistan.

The president of the Employers Confederation suggested that Mexicans should arm themselves with the same sensibility demonstrated by Perron in his controversial remarks, “in order not to lose the ability to be shocked, and to denounce any incident of corruption that presents itself to us.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags