Friday, November 20, 2026
Silvio Hernandez
- The slow pace of justice in Panama has aroused the ire of the the Roman Catholic Church which has accused the judiciary of dragging its feet on the question of bringing criminal cases to court.
The director of the Commission of Justice and Peace of the Catholic Church, Nagally Castillo says that the constant conflicts and riots in Panama’s jails are the fault of the judges and Magistrates of the Supreme Court of Justice. She alleged that the abuse of the use of preventative detention against lawbreakers prevents a quick solution to the problem, in particular the severe overcrowding of jails.
Just two weeks ago, some 3,000 inmates in La Joya and La Joyita prisons, located in the west of the province of Panama, took several guards as hostages to demand better treatment and speedier trials.
According to statistics from the Justice Ministry, only 35 percent of the 7,800 prisoners now in the country’s 80 jails have received a firm sentence. The remaining 65 percent are awaiting trial.
Castillo says that the slow judicial process has turned Panama into the country with the highest number of prisoners per capita in the region: 270 per 100,000 population. This figure is much higher than in Honduras, with 170 prisoners per 100,000, Costa Rica, with 160, El Salvador, 100, Nicaragua, 84 and Guatemala, 59.
In the rest of Latin America, only Argentina, with 125 prisoners per 100,000 population, Mexico, with 113 and Ecuador, with 110, come close to the levels of Panama.
In response to a deluge of criticism from lawyers and human rights organizations, the President of the Supreme Court of Justice, Arturo Hoyos, says the problems encountered into bringing accused persons to trial is a lack of resources.
He is backed up by the President of the Penal Hall of the Court, Edgardo Molomino, who wants more finance to be able to appoint 500 judges to the bench and provide an urgent solution to the overpopulation in the jails.
Castillo says that justice will not be served, however, if the system is repressive. “Overcrowding is not due to an increase in crime but to the repressive attitude of judicial authorities,” he says.
Another problem lies with criminal laws, which offer mechanisms for prosecuting a crime but doesn’t defend the human integrity of the criminals.
A statement issued early this year by the Conference of Bishops said that, in addition to the slow pace of the judges, the jails are not fulfilling their function of rehabilitating inmates. The bishops also said that judicial practice is not based on the legal principal of guaranteeing the presumption of innocence “but rather the contrary, the guilt of an individual is presumed, which only helps to further crowd the jails.”
Castillo maintains that under the Panamanian penal code, in 98 percent of the cases the accused remain in jail – and that 70 percent of them could not meet bail even if it was allowed.
She said a lack of judicial independence is another problem that contributes to the overpopulation of jails, because judges often “apply with timidity” harsh measures of incarceration out of fear of being criticized by lawyers and officials of the government.
A recent survey conducted by the company Dichter and Neira revealed that 66.5 percent of the population believes that the executive branch holds power over the judicial branch.