Friday, November 20, 2026
Marvette Darien
- One of New York City’s most notorious murderers died 38 years ago – but now, his life and crime are alive again in a new pop music album from a Broadway show.
Paul Simon’s latest release, ‘Songs from the Capeman’ (on Warner Records) revives a 1959 murder that to many New Yorkers represented a key point in the disintegration of their city’s society.
The album is a selection of 13 songs from a larger, 38-song Broadway musical also written by Simon as the singer-songwriter’s first project in six years. he co-wrote the lyrics with 1992 Nobel Laureate for Literature, Trinidadian-born poet Derek Walcott.
‘The Capeman’ is a nostalgic and sociological tribute to Salvador Agron, a poor and illiterate Puerto Rican immigrant who, in 1959 when he was 16-years-old, became the youngest person to be sentenced to death in New York State.
On the night of August 30, Agron and a gang of Puerto Rican youths from the city’s Upper West Side – called ‘The Vampires’ – went in search of another teenage gang of Irish-Americans from Hell’s Kitchen. They happened upon a group of teens not connected to gang activity, and in an ensuing fracas, Agron stabbed to death two of the bystanders before he fled.
Days later he was arrested based on an eyewitness description of the red-lined black cape he was wearing. He was dubbed ‘The Capeman’ and his accomplice, Tony Hernandez, who allegedly wielded an umbrella during the fight, was dubbed ‘The Umbrella Man’.
Agron showed no remorse for his crime and shocked New Yorkers by saying, “I don’t care if I burn. My mother could watch me.”
His death sentence was commuted, however, after prominent citizens pleaded for clemency on his behalf. He spent 20 years in prison, where he learnt to write poetry and became, by his own description, ‘rehumanised’. He was released in 1979 and died in 1986 at the age of 43.
Writing in the introduction to the album, Simon says he began thinking about the Capeman as the basis for a musical in 1989 because it was a “story with a great musical environment.”
“It raised the possibility of examining changing musical styles as the story unfolded and moved back and forth between Puerto Rico and New York,” he writes.
What has emerged in ‘Capeman’ is music that represents Simon’s ability to use culturally signicant events to tell a broader story, as in previous works such as ‘Graceland’ – based on his travels through apartheid-era South Africa – and ‘The Rhythm of the Saints,’ which drew from his familiarity with Brazilian culture.
‘Songs from the Capeman’ is an eclectic mix of salsa, doo-wop – Simon’s predominant 1950s style – and mambo. “Writing songs in a 1950s style was very appealing to me, and so was writing songs in a Latin style, which was a significant and sort of exotic New York subculture to me when I was growing up,” says Simon.
Echoes of the gangster subculture resound in the profanity- laced lyrics and racial epithets used to describe other gangs. This is most evident in “The Vampires,” which is rendered in strong mambo rhythms.
The first half of the album establishes Agron’s cultural background, and the songs are written as first-person accounts. In ‘Adios Hermanos,’ the opening song, Simon croons the story of Agron’s trial and sentencing. The second tune, ‘Born in Puerto Rico,’ focuses on the future Capeman’s familial roots, his career as a gangster, and his impressions of his transplanted environment.
‘Satin Summer Nights’ is an acapella-style rendition that both romanticises love and Spanish brown eyes and also lays bare the harshness of gang existence. “But you don’t get no respect around here unless you belong to a bopping gang … I mean, you either belong or you get hurt,” sings Marc Anthony, a popular contemporary salsero who is to play Agron in the forthcoming Broadway musical.
‘Time is an Ocean,’ another salsa-flavoured ballad from the album’s second half, also features Anthony as the younger Salvador and Panamanian salsa star Ruben Blades as the adult Capeman.
Agron’s mother’s anguish is voiced in ‘Can I Forgive Him,’ an account of her meeting with the victims’ family at their funeral. To the plaintive question the answer is a decisive “No.” In ‘Sunday Afternoon,’ sung by Ednita Nazario, Agron’s mother longs for Puerto Rico but reaffirms her commitment to her son.
Nazario, Anthony and Blades are all scheduled to appear in the Broadway musical, which is to open on Jan. 8, 1998. Meanwhile, ‘Songs from the Capeman’ was released last week in U.S. record stores. Marc Anthony and the Broadway cast are also expected to make several television appearances to support the forthcoming musical.